COMPARATIVE QUESTIONS

COMPARATIVE QUESTIONS

Document Links:

Document 18-1: Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Discourse on the Origin and Foundations of Inequality among Men

Document 18-2: Jacques-Louis Ménétra, Journal of My Life

Document 18-3: Cesare Beccaria, On Crimes and Punishments

Document 18-4: Adam Smith, An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations

Document 18-5: Frederick II, Political Testament

  1. How do Ménétra’s and Frederick II’s attitudes toward organized religion overlap? What does this suggest about Ménétra as an exception to the rule that the lower classes had little contact with Enlightenment ideas?

    Question

    MpERWg07jQ2IJQYDM/FLlrETpI2qu7O9EyROnE9NKdR09bMUFQeCsd+TE9BJJ19+n+22UAlsx91b0aGj/+9ek6wKMR97hfN+AIY+AsT/Pmg3slOYCfO1CKrU5QOyXyTqdMnaD54kQ6orEP/CukUzBc526JD8nErpp+Do/IJaWSxYPPk3hEfq30ADRIx2gQWuHCy5KFHh3AOurQPsCsnwCytCmQc3m79hxjf4Vu6JDd0pzpgfY774lJ37IOizhAzBSfF2GUTiQ8V04kGP0s4MZ6wL/33QGXojT+DyRXMBxo9wDjvmCwSLRnNjASWrTSQU0aP7afTyowIe3gliapvukXfPBQP0czTf
    How do Ménétra’s and Frederick II’s attitudes toward organized religion overlap? What does this suggest about Ménétra as an exception to the rule that the lower classes had little contact with Enlightenment ideas?
  2. What similarities and differences do you see between Frederick II’s and Beccaria’s views on the basis of good government?

    Question

    kkKf29IY4odREzWLbZBg2i2jvH9GopHiRz5ShfYjEOmzndRsdISzoU+cNqynpxd3OK9E4GKdTweIXtF+5pC2DzZ52lC58bDc4Kq7BQXef+v+wgl471C8L6zdix3Tb10y44vRp0/yASO0zYVX2ms1QJNkQzfK+6TYobgSa/mW+qDzWf9lcPQ8rrJG0wy5gXGXkw5mv1jzJofGVFOpt3dUZJuMAJgs8FqV
    What similarities and differences do you see between Frederick II’s and Beccaria’s views on the basis of good government?
  3. In what ways do the documents by Rousseau, Beccaria, Smith, and Frederick II reflect Enlightenment thinkers’ intense interest in the relationship between the individual and secular society?

    Question

    1JgU28RqWzlJFlFyHzyn+IdxI/P37t+lW88rsmmqTDn67mlJUntGv//p5jYfqpEE9muP+FI7J6+Ngb1yEJEsXQLbugl4nWKuTQ83ExykG/etzMvtbuRCqhv3p9YYJsJy3j/1OKYz0qPzqDO2L2AnvKkJQWl6RmwcI1YybhGKjBkqXfSmzNfBw36w/jo7eBkk9+Ajokw4QdGEOgw2HdewpEPvtYa0AiGR2K8w8cv3WoiTZzWxtTOsobfJ4UR279sOfHvrXLH9Opwhghp3X2J2CeqwZcQKc4kaLdljQizlFHVYhWgLvfTxzx7DfD0=
    In what ways do the documents by Rousseau, Beccaria, Smith, and Frederick II reflect Enlightenment thinkers’ intense interest in the relationship between the individual and secular society?
  4. Among the hallmarks of Enlightenment writers was their optimism about human nature and its capacity to change for the better. Do you see evidence of such optimism in the works excerpted in this chapter? Why or why not?

    Question

    HxiiI4txWqBnMcuPanrPmRkIaK5gIYIom4WTCJmVFcg/DX9P1HjeuFp4ryVANeKfG8Loy8wMLjQYytqJVuEx99+wTSXb7T60G6rm3gnjjYgdxyPA6J0jfyrltkJwL3wkhuzYe2NA3rixxkrnkuYIFZu/E6nYi8uJlrB48wLaUYvxM0yko4qet9WqlvugWUXt6sJpOXSXftNv3Yl/BGFGwNH24w7Pvom9Qm0Rom+DZ73SZwQCiufwFZjdKdF+A13q6DDaP3Aou5JizGF25CKhNKok889LL2aVlbCn8i8Gh/fBz4tQzyUNRodUX7ruBLS6ox8UVEhAAsZp/CkyIrhBBozm1h8=
    Among the hallmarks of Enlightenment writers was their optimism about human nature and its capacity to change for the better. Do you see evidence of such optimism in the works excerpted in this chapter? Why or why not?