Zolaria
Caitlin Horrocks
Caitlin Horrocks (b. 1980) is an assistant professor of writing at Grand Valley State University in Allendale, Michigan. Her first story collection, This Is Not Your City, from which this story is taken, was published to widespread acclaim in 2011. This story is about two friends who invent a magical world called Zolaria, a place that becomes more difficult to sustain as they get older.
It is July and we are a miraculous age. We have been sprung from our backyards, from the neighborhood park, from the invisible borders that rationed all our other summers. We are old enough to have earned a larger country, and young enough to make it larger still. The woods between Miller and Arborview become haunted. Basilisks patrol the Dairy Queen. We are so beset by dangers we make ourselves rulers over them, and by July we are the princesses of an undiscovered kingdom. We make maps with colored pencils. Here be Dragons, I write across the square of Wellington Park, at the end of our street. Here be Brothers, Hanna writes across her own backyard, and we avoid them both. We are too old for these games, too big for this much imagination, but we are so unpopular that summer that there is no one to care. We have finished the fifth grade alive and we consider that an accomplishment. We have earned this summer.
The neighborhood has been emptying of children. There are bigger houses being built past Wagner, past the edge of the western edge of town. The houses here, one story, one bathroom, have become a place to live after children or a place to move away from when they come. This year Hanna-
That summer we pick blackberries in the Miller woods and take them to Hanna’s house where her mother rinses them in a plastic colander. Hanna’s parents still live together and their house feels friendlier than mine. When Mr. Khoury visited our fifth-
The gas station at the comer of Miller and Maple closes and there is a sign in the windows announcing upcoming construction, Project Managers Ogan/Veen. We don’t know that the construction will never happen, that nothing will ever be built there, because the gasoline has leached into the earth 100, 200, 300 feet down, some impossible depth that no one will own up to and that can’t be cleaned. That summer we ride our bikes around and around the empty gas station and look in all the windows. Hanna says Ogan/Veen looks like the name of a monster, and from then on he haunts our summer in a friendly sort of way, a goblin who lives in an empty Shell station and wanders the neighborhood at sundown. If we are lucky, he will encounter only the children who have spent the past year tormenting us, and he will grind their bones for bread.
5 “Ogan Veen, Ogan Veen,
His farts all smell like gasoline,
His stomach’s full of children’s spleens,
Ogan Veen, Ogan Veen,” we sing. There are other verses but this one’s my favorite because I’ve come up with “spleen” all by myself. Hanna doesn’t know what it means and I’m not so clear either, but it rhymes and my mother’s said it’s a part of someone that can be eaten.
“If you’re a cannibal, I guess,” she said, and I said perfect.
10 On one of my dad’s weekends, I ask him to take us to Dolph Park, too far to bike to. The hiking path circles two lakes, Little Sister Lake and Big Sister Lake, and since I am an only child and Hanna has two brothers, we decide to split the lakes between us. We fight over who gets which. We are the same age and nearly the same size, although Hanna’s arms and legs are gangly and seem destined for great height. In seventh grade, the year Hanna will slip a note between the vents of my locker that reads “I Hate You” over and over, filling an entire notebook page, I will be 5'2" and as tall as I will ever grow. My father is 6'1" and will call me “Midget.” When I briefly register with an online dating site after college I will call myself “petite.” Hanna will never grow tall, either, and because we can’t know these things, we ask my father to flip a coin over Big Sister Lake. I can see him peek and scuttle the coin when I call heads, a move too quick for Hanna to notice. She cedes the lake to me, accepts the smaller for her kingdom, and I try to tell my father that night over carryout Chinese what I am only beginning to understand myself, that the way in which he loves me is not quite the way I wish he would.
In fifth grade Hanna and I doomed ourselves. On the second day of school we took out our folders, our pencil cases, organized our desks, and Hanna had space dolphins and I had pink unicorns. Two years ago all the girls had school supplies like this, and I don’t understand why they have abandoned the things they loved. Hanna and I were startled but not stupid, and if no one had noticed us that day we would both have begged our mothers to take us to K-
The Little and Big Sister Lakes are the eastern edge of what we name Zolaria that summer, simply for the sound of it, the exotic “Z” and the trailing vowels like a movie star’s name. The northwestern border is the Barton Dam. It takes us most of the summer to get there, sneaking closer and closer, up Newport Road and through the grounds of what will be our junior high school. One day there is a door propped open by the tennis courts and we decide to explore. There is a sticker beside the door: No Shirt, No Shoes, No Service. I am barefoot and we are so timid this sticker foils our plan until Hanna takes off her left shoe and gives it to me. Now we are within the law, and follow a chlorine smell as far as the locker rooms, the labyrinth of showers, the locked door to the pool. We hear footsteps and run, directionless, past the library, the main office, the Cafetorium, past the music room where I’ll play flute for three shrill years. Hanna will have quit band by then; Hanna has only so much energy, her mother will tell mine on the phone, and doesn’t want to waste it on the trombone. We run past the glass trophy cases in the foyer and finally we find the open door, the patch of blue sky and red and green tennis courts. In the homestretch Hanna’s shoe flies off my foot and she yells, “Forget it! Don’t stop!” but I go back and we make it out anyway.
The next day we bike through the junior high parking lot and across the freeway overpass just north, where we yank our arms up and down until three trucks have honked their horns. We take our bikes into the nature preserve and ride them until the hills get so steep they rattle our teeth. We ride bikes like girls, throw like girls, we know it, and there is no one around that summer to make us ashamed. We walk our bikes through the forest, the sound of the freeway to our right and a creek to our left, a symmetrical hum. Eventually there is a fence and a gate and a dirt road that leads to the Barton Dam. We ride to the huge gray wall of it, the rush of water at the base, the scum scudding across the surface of the river like soap suds. There is a dead animal floating at the base of the dam, bloated and spongy and colorless. Its fur is breaking off in hanks, drifting in the patches of foam. It is a cloudy day and we are alone on the river path. A man comes out of the pump station at the top of the dam and walks out along the wall. He leans against the safety railing and shades his eyes with a hand and looks down at us. We know we are in the borderlands, where our kingdom meets a stranger’s, where Ogan Veen wanders in daylight, and where we should not linger.
Thirteen years later, Cal and I will announce our engagement on Christmas morning over crumpled wrapping paper and freshly squeezed orange juice. It will be the coldest morning of any year of my life so far, the paper’s lead headline the temperature, 26 below, but as we unwrap presents we will see one of the Khoury boys outside walking their dog. My mother will call me into the kitchen to tell me I am young. “You’re young,” she’ll say. “You’re still so young.”
15 “Not that young,” I will tell her.
“Yes, that young. You barely know each other.”
“I know him.”
“You don’t know yourself,” she’ll say. “That’s what I worry about. How can you get married when you don’t know yourself yet?”
“I know myself plenty,” I’ll say. “I think I know all I want to.”
20 One night in July, Hanna and I have a sleepover and dream almost the same dream, in which Ogan Veen is chasing us, gnashing his long, stinking teeth. Zolaria is not his to haunt, so we build traps in the woods, stretch fishing line between trees, scatter tacks in the dirt and make piles of throwing-
My father will take me once more to Dolph Park, when I am in high school, for old times’ sake. The lakes are in the middle of an algae bloom, the weather hot and the water full of nitrogen and phosphorus. I will explain this to my father, nitrogen, phosphorus, when he grimaces at the damp mat of green over the pond, looking solid enough to walk on. My high school will have implemented an experimental science curriculum the year I enter tenth grade and I will know a great deal about eutrophication and very little about anything else. We will pretend to skip rocks but will really just be throwing things, stones and sticks and clods of dirt, watching them break apart the algae and sink out of sight. We will throw until our arms are tired and I will talk about the environmental benchmarks of healthy aquatic environments. We will get milkshakes at the Dairy Queen on Stadium Boulevard and two weeks later my father will move to San Diego.
In sixth grade Hanna and I will still be in the same Girl Scout troop. We will sing Christmas carols for the old people at Hillside Terrace nursing home, and in the spring we will sell cookies. I will sell enough to earn a stuffed giraffe, while Hanna sells only enough for a patch to be sewn on her vest. She will already be sick and I will have no idea. She will miss the whole last month of sixth grade, and four Girl Scout meetings, but it will be summer before my mother takes me to visit her. The hospital will remind me of a shopping mall, places to buy medicine and gifts and food, departments for having babies and looking after babies and looking after children and fixing all the different things that can go wrong with them. It is a weighty place but exciting, the way my mother asks the front desk for Pediatric Oncology and I press the button in the elevator.
Hanna’s mother and mine will go for coffee, leaving us alone. Hanna will be wearing a violet-
“I had a dream the other night that Ogan Veen was back,” I will say. “It was in the woods and he was chasing us and when we went out the fence we were saying, ‘I don’t hear him, I think we made it,’ but then he was right there in front of us smiling and then I woke up.” Hanna will look at me and her eyes will be dark and flat and I will know it was a terrible idea, to tell her this dream. She will sip her water and I will watch her sip it and we will wait for our mothers to come back and when they do we will be glad.
25 I will be unprepared for how long this sickness takes, for how long Hanna will be neither cured nor desperate. I will visit her once more at the hospital, twice more while she’s at home. I will realize I am waiting for her to be either well or dead. She will feel very far away. I will start junior high alone, and when Hanna comes for her first day, in late November, I will be startled to see her. Our morning classes must all be different because I recognize her for the first time at lunch, sitting by herself. I will already be sitting in the middle of a long table by the time I see her, my lunch unpacked in front of me. I will be pressed tight on either side by people who, if asked, would probably say I am their friend. Hanna will be wearing an awful wig, stiff and styled like an old woman’s perm. The hair will be dark brown, not black, and will no longer match her eyes. She will be pale and her face swollen and she will not seem like someone I can afford to know.
The summer we are ten we sketch maps of our kingdom and outline its Constitution, its Declaration of Independence, its City Charter. In the end they all become zoological surveys. The Haisley woods harbor griffins, borometz, simurghs. There are dragons on Linwood Street, basilisks on Duncan who turn children to stone. We understand that we have no sway over basilisks and dragons; we understand that they are the minions of Ogan Veen. He has servants now, he has armies, and despite all our efforts Zolaria is not as safe as it was.
We make other lists, too, of “People Who, In Zolaria, Would Be Imprisoned In The Dungeon FOREVER.” Hanna keeps adding her brothers’ names to the list and then erasing them until the paper is ready to tear and I tell her to leave them off, if she’s going to feel so guilty about it. We make a list of “Animals That Can Be Ridden: Pegasus, Centaur, Griffins, and Space Dolphins.” We decide this is too charitable, and amend it to “Animals That Can Be Ridden By Us.” We decide to hire young men to look after our stable of space dolphins, and when we deem ourselves a little older, and ready for love, we will notice the groomsmen and swoon. We prepare speeches of protest, in which we declare our unwillingness to marry foreign princes, our determination to follow our hearts, until we are disappointed to remember that in our kingdom we have no parents, and may marry whomever we choose.
. . .
Fourteen years later, when I marry Cal at a Unitarian church that four months later will be sold and remodeled into a bed and breakfast, Hanna Khoury’s parents will still be living down the street. My father will fly in from San Diego for the wedding, and he and my mother will agree to pose for photographs together: them, them and me, them and me and Cal, them and me and Cal and Cal’s parents, the symmetry of happy marriages. The Khourys won’t be at the wedding because I won’t have invited them. I won’t have invited them because I’m scared of what Hanna might have told them. Not about the way I never sat with her at lunch or talked to her in band, or the way I didn’t ever claim, precisely, not to know her, or the way I never said I did. Not even the way her life got worse and worse and I did nothing to make it better. Or the way when I saw how bad things got for her in school I was glad we weren’t still friends. The day I will worry she’s told them about will be a Monday in February during sixth period, Phys Ed, one of our two classes together. Hanna will be excused from almost everything except changing. She won’t have to run or throw or dribble or swim, but she will have to put on gym clothes. She’ll try to get her sweater off and T-
In the film Heavenly Creatures (1994) directed by Peter Jackson, two young girls invent a rich imaginary world for themselves.
In what ways do these images reflect or diverge from the imaginary world of “Zolaria”? What words or phrases from the short story support your response?
Hanna will be in remission by the next fall, but her parents will already have taken her out of Forsythe Junior High and placed her in a private school. I will not know when the cancer comes back. I will have discovered how easy it is to never see someone, even an eight-
30 It will be my first funeral, and my mother and I will go shopping for black clothing together. As we leave the mall I will thank her for paying, like she’s bought me birthday gifts or new back-
At the wedding Cal’s mother will squint at me and ask if I’m really Unitarian, or just needed a cheap place for the wedding. I will tell her that I’m pagan, that I make burnt offerings to forest demons in the Bird Hills Nature Preserve. She won’t laugh. Cal and I will go to Toronto for the honeymoon and three and a half years later the doctor will tell us to get ready for twins, girls. I will be terrified. It seems like a sign. It seems like a coin has already been flipped, and we will spend years waiting for it to fall. I will stare at my daughters in matching pajamas and wonder which one Ogan Veen will ask for. Which one he’ll try to take. If he will give them ten years, if he will come calling sooner.
One winter the twins, bored, will unearth old photos in the basement: their baby pictures, our wedding, school portraits of Cal and snapshots of my elementary school birthday parties. The year I turned ten there was no one I wanted to invite except Hanna, no one I thought would come if I asked. In the picture there is a cake with ten candles and only two girls grinning above it — they look as if they should be lonely but are somehow perfectly happy. Madison will ask me who the dark-
On a July morning the summer before the girls begin kindergarten I will ask them to get dressed in their swimsuits, pull old shorts and T-
Cal will get home from work and while I cook dinner the girls will tell him what I did and Cal will shout and I will try to explain myself and Cal will misunderstand and talk to his parents about having the girls baptized at First Methodist. I won’t know how to tell him that that won’t help, that it isn’t what I meant. I won’t know how to tell him that I am still bracing for a day when Sophie complains of a headache that turns out to be something more, when Madison reels dizzily in gym class and the teacher sends her home with a concerned note. When a doctor has something to tell me he asks me to sit down to hear. I will be trying not to think about the possibility of a day when I will drive to the dam again, climb the stairs to Barton Pond and wade in. I will walk until I can hear the pressing silence of the water, the rushing, vacuous weight of it. I will say, “Mr. Veen, do you remember me?” I will say, “Mr. Veen, I once ruled a kingdom and left traps for you in the woods. Don’t you want your revenge?” I will say, “Mr. Veen, you are an ogre and a thief and the patron saint of Julys, of summer Sundays, of miracles.” I will say, “Mr. Veen, do not take my children.”
35 And if he asks, and if I think it will help, and if I think it is truly what I have to do, we will be swimming and it will be July and we are a miraculous age. We are in Zolaria, we are children, our bodies are honest children’s bodies. We are narrow and quick and we still fit in all our hiding places, the sun-
After completing the story, you can probably think back on it and see how often Hanna’s death was foreshadowed. Locate as many places as you can and explain why there are so many instances of foreshadowing.
In fifth grade, Hanna and the narrator “doomed” themselves because they showed up with school supplies decorated with space dolphins and unicorns, styles that the other girls had stopped using. The narrator then says, “I don’t understand why they have abandoned the things they loved” (par. 11). How does this statement seem to reflect one of the themes of this story?
When the narrator announces her engagement, her mother says that she is too young and that she doesn’t even know herself yet. The narrator responds, “I know myself plenty. . . . I think I know all I want to.” (par. 19) What does her response reveal about her? How does it relate to what we know about her when she was a child?
In less than two years, the narrator goes from being Hanna’s co-
Zolaria means different things to the narrator as the story progresses. What does it seem to represent at the following stages?
during that first summer when she is ten (pars. 1–
when Hanna becomes sick (pars. 22–
when the narrator is an adult and has children of her own (pars. 33–
What is the narrator hoping to accomplish by pushing her children into the pond (par. 33)? How successful is she?
Read this excerpt from an interview with Caitlin Horrocks, which was published on a website called The Rumpus. What do you think of the interviewer’s, and Horrocks’s, assessment of the narrator as being too self-
The Rumpus: “I know myself plenty,” the main character in “Zolaria” says to her mother. “I think I know all I want to.” And in fact she and the other protagonists [. . .] know a great deal about themselves, maybe too much to be happy. Have you worked with characters who don’t understand themselves?
Horrocks: Self-
Reread the opening paragraph and the closing paragraph of the story. They both take place in Zolaria and are both written in the present tense, but what is the difference between them?
Look back through the story and notice the places where the narrator uses “we” and then shifts to “I.” Why do you think she switches and what is the effect of those shifts?
Notice the interesting shifts in the tense the narrator uses. For example, the story begins in the present tense with the line, “It is July and we are a miraculous age,” but at various times, she switches to the future tense, as in “My father will take me once more to Dolph Park, when I am in high school” (par. 21). Looking back through the story, when does the narrator use the present tense and when does she use the future tense? What is the effect of these shifts?
If the narrator had decided to tell this story in chronological order, she would have started when she and Hanna were in the fifth grade, continued through their one summer together, described Hanna’s illness and death, and wrapped up with her own marriage and parenthood. But instead, she shifts back and forth in time throughout the story. Look back through the story and identify one significant time shift. Why do you think Horrocks structured this portion of the story in this way? What is the effect of the time shift?
Reread the descriptions of Zolaria, the world the narrator and Hanna create when they are ten (pars. 1, 12–
One of the saddest parts of this story is when the narrator’s relationship with Hanna changes after she becomes sick. Reread the following sentences and explain the effect of the underlined words. What do they reveal about the narrator?
“She will be pale and her face swollen and she will not seem like someone I can afford to know” (par. 25).
“I will think that the feel of her wig in my hand was like a gutted animal, empty and dry and bristling” (par. 28).
“I will have discovered how easy it is to never see someone, even an eight-
It is very likely that you have had an experience similar to the narrator’s, in which you and a friend have changed to such a degree that you are no longer as close as you once were. What factors caused this change? Is this growing apart an inevitable part of growing up or can it be avoided? Why?
The narrator clearly fails in her opportunity to stand up for Hanna when she is being bullied in the locker room in junior high school; in fact, she even participates in the bullying of her friend (par. 28). Conduct a brief search on the social forces that contribute to bullying in school, focusing on the most recent research by scholars such as Jaana Juvonen from UCLA, Ken Rigby from the University of South Australia, and others. Using the findings from your research, explain the actions of the narrator toward Hanna.
It is apparent that even years after the events the narrator has still not forgiven herself for her actions (and inactions) toward Hanna. Is the narrator truly responsible for her actions, or should she be excused because of her youth and other factors? Support your response with direct evidence from the story.
Look over these two differing views about childhood and its relationship to adulthood. Explain what each is suggesting about childhood and explain how they each compare to “Zolaria.”
“When I was a child, I spoke like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child. When I became a man, I gave up childish ways.” —1 Corinthians 13:11, English Standard Version
My heart leaps up when I behold
A rainbow in the sky:
So was it when my life began;
So is it now I am a man;
So be it when I shall grow old,
Or let me die!
The Child is father of the Man;
I could wish my days to be
Bound each to each by natural piety.
—William Wordsworth