Chapter 2. Thinking Critically: Previewing (Chapter 2)

Previewing

Thinking Critically: Previewing

Sylvan Barnet, Hugo Bedau, John O’Hara

Activity Objective: Provide the missing information for Sanjay Gupta and his essay “Why I Changed My Mind on Weed.”

Author

Answer the following questions for Sanjay Gupta and his essay “Why I Changed My Mind on Weed.”

Questions to ask: Who is he? What expertise does he have? What credibility does he have? How difficult is the writing likely to be?

Question

MuCQmxGZfSWJ5jjvkZoXIOgpTJrM/HgdnJu1hT2QtoEXQvlkyRqn5jhPZ8FLa4Ja2DA1k+ZR0aHXEfPYRSpy0WmZHxpsyYdX27VlXfiaq0Ynlb/v
Your response has been provisional accepted and will be graded by your instructor.

Title

Answer the following questions for Sanjay Gupta and his essay “Why I Changed My Mind on Weed.”

Questions to ask: What does the title reveal about the essay’s content? Does it give any clues about how the argument will take shape?

Question

MuCQmxGZfSWJ5jjvkZoXIOgpTJrM/HgdnJu1hT2QtoEXQvlkyRqn5jhPZ8FLa4Ja2DA1k+ZR0aHXEfPYRSpy0WmZHxpsyYdX27VlXfiaq0Ynlb/v
Your response has been provisional accepted and will be graded by your instructor.

Place of Publication

Answer the following questions for Sanjay Gupta and his essay “Why I Changed My Mind on Weed.”

Questions to ask: How does the place of publication help you understand the argument? What type of audiences will it be likely to target?

Question

MuCQmxGZfSWJ5jjvkZoXIOgpTJrM/HgdnJu1hT2QtoEXQvlkyRqn5jhPZ8FLa4Ja2DA1k+ZR0aHXEfPYRSpy0WmZHxpsyYdX27VlXfiaq0Ynlb/v
Your response has been provisional accepted and will be graded by your instructor.

Context

Answer the following questions for Sanjay Gupta and his essay “Why I Changed My Mind on Weed.”

Questions to ask: By placing the article in the context of its time—given trends in the conversations about or popular understandings of the subject—what can you expect about the author’s position?

Question

MuCQmxGZfSWJ5jjvkZoXIOgpTJrM/HgdnJu1hT2QtoEXQvlkyRqn5jhPZ8FLa4Ja2DA1k+ZR0aHXEfPYRSpy0WmZHxpsyYdX27VlXfiaq0Ynlb/v
Your response has been provisional accepted and will be graded by your instructor.

Skimming

Answer the following questions for Sanjay Gupta and his essay “Why I Changed My Mind on Weed.”

Questions to ask: As you skim over the first several paragraphs, where do you first realize the purpose of the essay? What is Gupta’s argument? What major forms of evidence does he offer?

Question

MuCQmxGZfSWJ5jjvkZoXIOgpTJrM/HgdnJu1hT2QtoEXQvlkyRqn5jhPZ8FLa4Ja2DA1k+ZR0aHXEfPYRSpy0WmZHxpsyYdX27VlXfiaq0Ynlb/v
Your response has been provisional accepted and will be graded by your instructor.