Generating Ideas from Reading

For more on generating ideas, see Ch. 19.

Like flints that strike each other and cause sparks, readers and writers provoke one another. For example, when your class discusses an essay, you may be surprised by the range of insights your classmates report. Of course, they may be equally surprised by what you see. Above all, reading is a dynamic process. It may change your ideas instead of support them. Here are suggestions for unlocking the potential of a good text.

Looking for Meaty Pieces. Spur your thinking about current topics by browsing through essay collections or magazines in the library or online. Try Atlantic, Harper’s, New Republic, Commentary, or special-interest magazines such as Architectural Digest or Scientific American. Check editorials and op-ed columns in your local newspaper, the New York Times, or the Wall Street Journal. Search the Internet on intriguing topics (such as silent-film technology) or issues (such as homeless children). Look for meaty, not superficial, articles written to inform and convince, not entertain or amuse.

Logging Your Reading. For several days keep a log of the articles that you find. Record the author, title, and source for each promising piece so that you can easily find it again. Briefly note the subject and point of view as well, so you can identify a range of possibilities.

Recalling Something You Have Already Read. What have you read lately that started you thinking? Return to a reading — a chapter in a history book, an article for sociology, a research report for biology.

Paraphrasing and Summarizing Complex Ideas. Do you feel overwhelmed by challenging reading? If so, read slowly and carefully. Try two common methods of recording and integrating ideas from sources into papers.

For more on paraphrase and summary, see Ch. 12 and D4–D5 in the Quick Research Guide.

Accurately recording what a reading says can help you grasp its ideas, especially on literal levels. Once you understand what it says, you can agree, disagree, or question.

Reading Critically. Instead of just soaking up what a reading says, try a conversation with the writer. Criticize. Wonder. Argue back. Demand convincing evidence. Use the following checklist to get started.

CRITICAL READING CHECKLIST

  • What problems and issues does the author raise?
  • What is the author’s purpose? Is it to explain or inform? To persuade? To amuse? In addition to this overall purpose, is the author trying to accomplish some other agenda?
  • How does the author appeal to you as a reader? Where do you agree and disagree? Where do you want to say “Yeah, right!” or “I don’t think so!”?
  • How does this piece relate to your own experiences or thoughts? Have you encountered anything similar? Does the topic or approach engage you?
  • Are there any important words or ideas that you don’t understand? If so, do you need to reread or turn to a dictionary or reference book?
  • What is the author’s point of view? What does the author assume or take for granted? Where does the author reveal these assumptions? Do they make the selection seem weak or biased?
  • Which statements are facts, verifiable by observation, firsthand testimony, or research? Which are opinions? Does one or the other dominate?
  • Is the writer’s evidence accurate, relevant, and sufficient? Is it persuasive?

Analyzing Writing Strategies. Reading widely and deeply can reveal what others say and how they shape and state it. For some readings in this book, notes in the margin identify key features such as the introduction, thesis statement or main idea, major points, and supporting evidence. Ask questions such as these to help you identify writing strategies:

WRITING STRATEGIES CHECKLIST

See more on facts and opinions.

See C1–C3 in the Quick Research Guide for more on evaluating evidence.

  • How does the author introduce the reading and try to engage the audience?
  • Where does the author state or imply the main idea or thesis?
  • How is the text organized? What main points develop the thesis?
  • How does the author supply support — facts, data, statistics, expert opinions, experiences, observations, explanations, examples, other information?
  • How does the author connect or emphasize ideas for readers?
  • How does the author conclude the reading?
  • What is the author’s tone? How do the words and examples reveal the author’s attitude, biases, or assumptions?