Evaluating an argument

As you write: Evaluating an argument

Using the checklist for reading and evaluating arguments on page 155, evaluate the analysis written by student Ren Yoshida on pages 138–41. Record your notes and comments in the space below. Do you find Yoshida’s analysis persuasive? Is his argument logical and fair? Does he present himself as a trustworthy and credible writer? If you had an opportunity to talk with Yoshida, what counterarguments would you pose? Click Submit.

Question

Using the checklist for reading and evaluating arguments on page 155, evaluate the analysis written by student Ren Yoshida on pages 138–41. Record your notes and comments in the space below. Do you find Yoshida’s analysis persuasive? Is his argument logical and fair? Does he present himself as a trustworthy and credible writer? If you had an opportunity to talk with Yoshida, what counterarguments would you pose? Click Submit.