TABLE 12.1

SUPPORTIVE AND DEFENSIVE COMMUNICATION

SITUATION SUPPORTIVE COMMUNICATION RESPONSE DEFENSIVE COMMUNICATION RESPONSE
A committee member argues against every suggestion for a fund-raiser.

Uses descriptive language (“I” language, fact-based statements)

“I am sensing a lot of dissatisfaction with our ideas today. What's up?”

Employs evaluative language (“You” language, judgmental statements)

“You hould quit being such a jerk.”

A study group member fails to complete the assigned chapter outlines.

Takes a problem-orientation approach (open-ended questions, collaboration)

“We've noticed you haven't completed the outlines. Is something wrong?”

Uses controlling messages (attempts to change or exercise power over the other person)

“You need to do your work. If you don't, you are out of the group.”

A team member wants feedback on sales presentation slides.

Forms cooperative messages (honest disclosure, relevancy)

“They were good, but I find the amount of text on each slide to be overwhelming.”

Engages strategy (manipulation, dishonesty)

“It's great! Don't change a thing before the presentation.”

A work colleague is complaining about another team member's work habits.

Demonstrates empathy (active listening, responding with support)

“I know you're upset with Taylor; I'd be frustrated, too.”

Lacks concern (neutral viewpoint, apathy)

“Look, Taylor's just like that. Get used to it.”

A cousin is having trouble completing his portion of duties for a family gathering.

Conveys equality (mutual respect, open to feedback)

“How are you feeling about your tasks? Would you like me to help out?”

Shows superiority (arrogance, closed to feedback)

“Why do you have to be so helpless?”

A team disagrees about a meeting discussion topic.

Makes provisional assertions (open to alternatives, tentative statements)

“I know things were pretty hectic at the end of the last meeting, but I thought we agreed to discuss Ella's proposal tonight. What do you recall?”

Emphasizes certainty (rigid thinking, overgeneralizations)

“I know what was said at the last meeting. We agreed that we would discuss Ella's proposal tonight. This group is so forgetful!”