What is evolution and how does natural selection allow populations to adapt to changing environments?
Why You Should Care
Evolution is the founding principle for the study of modern biology because it explains how every living thing you encounter came to be the way it is. An example of evolution that has many people concerned is methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA). Staphylococcus aureus is a common, normally harmless bacterium that is found on many people’s skin and nostrils. A break in the skin can lead to the bacteria becoming infectious and cause lesions or deep-tissue infections. Normally, such an infection is treatable with antibiotics, but MRSA is resistant to all known antibiotics.
MRSA became resistant through evolution and natural selection. In a patient with a Staphylococcus infection, even if the bacterium developed antibiotic resistance, the rest of the bacteria in a patient’s body would be killed by the antibiotics, and the resistant bacterium would be killed by the patient’s immune system. If the patient only takes a partial course of antibiotics, the non-resistant bacteria may be killed back, but not enough to make the patient well. The resistant bacteria will have an advantage by being resistant and proliferate. The indiscriminate and improper use of antibiotics, therefore, is making antibiotics less useful.
Choose the correct term for each of the following definitions:
Term | Definition |
---|---|
A trait that helps an individual survive or reproduce. | |
Two species each provide the selective pressure that determines which traits are favored by natural selection in the other. | |
The heritable variation among individuals of a single population or within the species as a whole. | |
Humans decide which individuals breed and which do not in an attempt to produce a population with desired traits. | |
Stretches of DNA, the cell’s hereditary material, that each direct the production of a particular protein and influence an individual’s traits. | |
Differences in the gene frequencies within a population from one generation to the next. | |
The process by which organisms best adapted to the environment (the fittest) survive to reproduce, leaving more offspring than less well-adapted individuals. | |
A nonrandom influence affecting who survives or reproduces. | |
The assortment and abundance of particular variants of genes relative to each other within a population. |
For each of the scenarios described below, decide whether it describes stabilizing selection, directional selection, or disruptive selection.
Type of Selection | Scenario |
---|---|
Dandelions in a field grow flowering stalks to various heights; they will not reproduce if their flowers are cut off. After the field is mowed routinely for a few years, most of the dandelions only produce flowering stalks that are close to the ground. | |
A species of tree produces seeds that cannot germinate and grow in the shade. The seeds have flaps on them that are of varying size and shapes. Flaps of a certain size will allow the seeds to glide away and germinate. If the flaps are too small or narrow, they will not catch enough air and the seed will drop. If the flaps are too wide or heavy, the seeds will be too heavy to travel far. | |
A breeding pair of seed-eating sparrows gets stranded on an isolated island. Their offspring have variously sized beaks; the larger the beak the larger the seeds the sparrow can eat. Trees on the island either produce large or small seeds, but not many medium-sized seeds. Although the large-beaked birds could eat small seeds, it’s more efficient for them to eat large seeds. |
Thought Question: Click on the link below to view a photo of a sample of University of Connecticut students taken in 1996 (The Hartford Courant, “Reaching New Heights,” November 23, 1996; photo by K. Hanley.) Women are in white and men are in black. Each column consists of people who are all of the same height; the heights range from 5 ft to 6 ft 5 in.
http://mindprod.com/image/math/livinghistogram.jpg
Imagine you are a visiting alien studying humans. You haven’t figured out yet that humans have two sexes, but you have noticed that they wear different colored shirts and are of varying height. You see the group of students in the above photo and conclude that humans are exhibiting evidence of natural selection. What kind of selection would you conclude is at play here?
Try this at home: You can model natural selection in the comfort of your own habitat. It’s fun for the whole family (except the individuals being selected against).
What you need:
1) A “habitat” playing field: This can be a countertop, table, hard or carpeted floor, etc.
2) “Beetle” prey tokens in two colors: This works best if one of the colors is close to the color of the playing field (white and black beans on a white counter, for example).
• Ideas for tokens: black and white dried beans, two colors of poker chips,
squares cut out of construction paper in two colors, etc.
• The best tokens are difficult, but not impossible, to pick up with thumb and
forefinger.
• Try to have at least 30 tokens of each color.
3) A “consumer”: This is a cup or envelope into which you put eaten prey.
4) A timer (optional)
5) A partner (optional)
What you do:
1) Count out 10 tokens of each color; 20 tokens total.
2) Spread your tokens out evenly on your habitat surface; make sure there aren’t any clumps of one particular color.
3) Set your timer for a short time span; try starting with 20 seconds.
4) After you start the timer, start preying on your tokens:
• Pick tokens up one at a time with thumb and forefinger.
• Put each eaten prey in your consumer container before returning to eat again.
• Don’t scoop or scrape up tokens.
5) When the time is up, the survivors from your predation are left to reproduce:
• Add one token of the same color for each of the tokens you didn’t capture; in other words, double the tokens that survived.
TIP: If there are no survivors left, then your population has been extirpated.
This is an accurate portrayal of what may happen in nature, but we should still examine how natural selection changes species. Try again, reducing the amount of time you act as a predator and/or give yourself as disadvantage, like dimming the lights, wearing sunglasses, and using tweezers or a spoon to pick up prey tokens instead of your fingers.
6) Model a few more cycles of reproduction and predation by repeating steps 2–5.
7) After a few generations have passed, count the number of tokens in each color. Calculate the percent each color represents in the total population by dividing the number of tokens of a particular color by the total number of surviving tokens and multiplying by 100%.
8) Recall that your original population had 50% of each color. Has the relative proportion changed? If not, then you have modeled neutral selection pressure. If yes, then you have created a selection pressure that favors one trait in the population over another one.
Thought Question: What has happened to your tokens’ genes?
Take it further: For an interactive look at natural selection, go to this website http://www.techapps.net/interactives/pepperMoths.swf and click on A Bird’s Eye View of Natural Selection.
Coevolution is the process by which two species evolve in response to selective pressures from each other, and therefore adapt to each other. Consider a hypothetical relationship between a species of tree beetle and a species of bird that preys on the beetles. The beetles have naturally occurring variation in color; some colors more closely match the colors of the trees they live on than others. The birds vary in their abilities to see the beetles on the trees. The following three diagrams represent steps in a coevolutionary "arms race."
Select the proper order of events:
A. |
B. |
C. |
D. |
Which of the following is not an example of coevolution?
A. |
B. |
C. |
D. |
A species of finch colonizes a small island that has one species of tree as its dominant woody plant. The finches naturally have variation in the size of their beaks, and the larger their beak, the larger the seeds they can crack open. The trees on the island produce large seeds. What do you think is most likely to happen to the finches and trees after several generations of coevolution?
A. |
B. |
C. |
D. |
Which of the following is not an example of coevolution?
A. |
B. |
C. |
D. |
A classic example of coevolution is the case of Heliconius butterflies and passionflowers. Heliconius butterflies of several species all lay their eggs only on the leaves of different species of passionflower. Passionflowers produce toxins that are meant to deter insect predation, but the butterflies have evolved immunity to this toxin. Passionflowers produce nectaries (nectar-secreting glands) on their leaves that encourage visits from ants and wasps, which come for the nectar but stay to eat any butterfly eggs on the leaves. To prevent intraspecific competition, the butterflies will not lay eggs on leaves that already have eggs on them. Passionflowers produce nectaries and leaf spots that are shaped like butterfly eggs.
A) Thought Question: Predict the next step in this coevolutionary "tennis match."
B) Thought Question: The Butterfly or the Egg? It’s possible that passionflowers were already toxic before Heliconius butterflies began to specialize on them. How could that be?
Activity results are being submitted...