14.1 Basic Concepts of Psychological Disorders

528

14-1 How should we draw the line between normality and disorder?

Most of us would agree that a family member who is depressed and isolated for three months has a psychological disorder. But what should we say about a grieving father who can’t resume his usual social activities three months after his child has died? Where do we draw the line between clinical depression and understandable grief? Between bizarre irrationality and zany creativity? Between abnormality and normality? In their search for answers, theorists and clinicians ask:

“Who in the rainbow can draw the line where the violet tint ends and the orange tint begins? Distinctly we see the difference of the colors, but where exactly does the one first blendingly enter into the other? So with sanity and insanity.”

Herman Melville, Billy Budd, Sailor, 1924

psychological disorder a syndrome marked by a clinically significant disturbance in an individual’s cognition, emotion regulation, or behavior.

A psychological disorder is a syndrome (a symptom collection) marked by a “clinically significant disturbance in an individual’s cognition, emotion regulation, or behavior” (American Psychiatric Association, 2013). Such thoughts, emotions, or behaviors are dysfunctional or maladaptive—they interfere with normal day-to-day life. Believing your home must be thoroughly cleaned every weekend is not a disorder. But if cleaning rituals interfere with work and leisure, as Marc’s did in this chapter’s opening, they may be signs of a disorder. And occasional sad moods that persist and become disabling may likewise signal a psychological disorder.

Distress often accompanies dysfunctional behaviors. Marc, Greta, and Stuart were all distressed by their behaviors or emotions.

Over time, definitions of what makes for a “significant disturbance” have varied. In 1973, the American Psychiatric Association dropped homosexuality as a disorder after mental health workers came to consider same-sex attraction as not inherently dysfunctional or distressing. In the 1970s, high-energy children were typically viewed as normal youngsters running a bit wild. Today, more of them are seen as dysfunctional and diagnosed with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).

image
Culture and normality Young men of the West African Wodaabe tribe put on elaborate makeup and costumes to attract women. Young American men may buy flashy cars with loud stereos to do the same. Each culture may view the other’s behavior as abnormal.
Carol Beckwith; © Image Source/Corbis

529

RETRIEVE IT

Question

A lawyer is distressed by feeling the need to wash his hands 100 times a day. He has no time left to meet with clients, and his colleagues are wondering about his competence. His behavior would probably be labeled disordered, because it is CObMLklZ77WuyOm9oMu1/SoVDpp0yxtt6FfPEli/zww= —that is, it interferes with his day-to-day life.

dysfunctional or maladaptive

Understanding Psychological Disorders

14-2 How do the medical model and the biopsychosocial approach influence our understanding of psychological disorders?

image
Yesterday’s “therapy” Through the ages, psychologically disordered people have received brutal treatments, including the trephination evident in this Stone Age skull. Drilling skull holes like these may have been an attempt to release evil spirits and cure those with mental disorders. Did this patient survive the “cure”?
John W. Verano

The way we view a problem influences how we try to solve it. In earlier times, people often thought that strange behaviors were evidence that strange forces—the movements of the stars, godlike powers, or evil spirits—were at work. Had you lived during the Middle Ages, you might have said “The devil made him do it.” To drive out demons, people considered “mad” were sometimes caged or given “therapies” such as genital mutilation, beatings, removal of teeth or lengths of intestines, or transfusions of animal blood (Farina, 1982).

Reformers, such as Philippe Pinel (1745–1826) in France, opposed such brutal treatments. Madness is not demon possession, he insisted, but a sickness of the mind caused by severe stress and inhumane conditions. Curing the sickness, he said, requires “moral treatment,” including boosting patients’ morale by unchaining them and talking with them. He and others worked to replace brutality with gentleness, isolation with activity, and filth with clean air and sunshine.

Barbaric treatments for mental illness linger even today. In some places, people are chained to a bed, confined to their rooms, or even locked in a space with wild hyenas, in the belief that the animals will see and attack evil spirits (Hooper, 2013). Noting the physical and emotional damage of such restraint, the World Health Organization launched a “chain-free initiative” that aims to reform hospitals “into patient-friendly and humane places with minimum restraints” (WHO, 2014).

The Medical Model

medical model the concept that diseases, in this case psychological disorders, have physical causes that can be diagnosed, treated, and, in most cases, cured, often through treatment in a hospital.

By the 1800s, a medical breakthrough prompted further reform. Researchers discovered that syphilis, a sexually transmitted infection, invades the brain and distorts the mind. This discovery triggered an excited search for physical causes of mental disorders and for treatments that would cure them. Hospitals replaced asylums, and the medical model of mental disorders was born. This model is reflected in words we still use today. We speak of the mental health movement. A mental illness (also called a psychopathology) needs to be diagnosed on the basis of its symptoms. It needs to be treated through therapy, which may include treatment in a psychiatric hospital. Recent discoveries that genetically influenced abnormalities in brain structure and biochemistry contribute to many disorders have energized the medical perspective.

The Biopsychosocial Approach

To call psychological disorders “sicknesses” tilts research heavily toward the influence of biology and away from the influence of our personal histories and social and cultural surroundings. But as we have seen throughout this text, biological, psychological, and social-cultural influences together weave the fabric of our thoughts, feelings, and behaviors (FIGURE 14.1). As individuals, we differ in the amount of stress we experience and in the ways we cope with stressors. Cultures also differ in the sources of stress they produce and in the traditional ways of coping they provide. We are physically embodied and socially embedded.

image
Figure 14.1: FIGURE 14.1 The biopsychosocial approach to psychological disorders Today’s psychology studies how biological, psychological, and social-cultural factors interact to produce specific psychological disorders.
Wavebreakmedia Ltd./ Getty Images

530

The environment’s influence on disorders can be seen in culture-related symptoms (Beardsley, 1994; Castillo, 1997). Anxiety, for example, may be manifested in different ways in different cultures. In Latin American cultures, people may display symptoms of susto, a condition marked by severe anxiety, restlessness, and a fear of black magic. In Japanese culture, people may experience taijin-kyofusho—social anxiety about their appearance, combined with a readiness to blush and a fear of eye contact. The eating disorders anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa occur mostly in food-abundant North American and other Western cultures. Increasingly, however, such North American disorders have, along with McDonald’s and MTV, spread across the globe (Watters, 2010). Even disordered aggression may be explained differently in other cultures. In Malaysia, a sudden outburst of violent behavior, called amok (as in the English phrase “run amok”), was traditionally attributed to an evil spirit.

Two other disorders—depression and schizophrenia—occur worldwide. From Asia to Africa and across the Americas, people with schizophrenia often act irrationally and speak in disorganized ways; people with depression experience long-term hopelessness and lethargy, have trouble concentrating, and lose interest in activities that once brought them pleasure.

epigenetics the study of environmental influences on gene expression that occur without a DNA change.

Disorders reflect genetic predispositions and physiological states, psychological dynamics, and social and cultural circumstances. The biopsychosocial approach emphasizes that mind and body are inseparable (see FIGURE 14.1). Negative emotions contribute to physical illness, and physical abnormalities contribute to negative emotions. As research on epigenetics shows, our environment can also affect whether a gene is expressed, thus affecting the development of psychological disorders.

RETRIEVE IT

Question

gptazWMcrrTwizzWp99kZydJRKJYgZD1+pqGWWKLa19sHVSr0cgGtH97lCgIAUC4OhXIZ6j89kWJzYQCAgYJmraFVcPRdDjPLDCQbzWjTlrulILLWqs+R5sfRwpffTZH51XnpkTVKSXYn7nKG3ooMpvk06ReuqQNH/Cm8iYM9Wj0/hwdVgILuEUwkLStPDyLWeDXzXVw6N1nDFjZcp7idzxVttuOQDUR/roULMDyc1RdRacM85tUAg==
ANSWER: Some psychological disorders are culture-specific. For example, anorexia nervosa occurs mostly in North American cultures, and taijin-kyofusho appears largely in Japan. Other disorders, such as schizophrenia, are universal—occurring in all cultures.

Question

FqBs1PiHT69jltkPvhCg/ne25lmlPXNy4X6mLgDZWM4SyjsN69WlHsivpJal3ZaU95LvgnrXpaApU2+TGaHs8eDI8ZGCAMiog6tZ9C3Ci5esEZrvWIv/UN/7xChzHWZxDZoCiiV/d64ov2Brmj0fBZcWg0jbu3bNXyBkQUo/BEzl/GH7RVAo4XOeUggrEeutB7C557+ppADU1hsT
ANSWER: Biological, psychological, and social-cultural influences combine to produce psychological disorders. This broad perspective helps us understand that our well-being is affected by our genes, brain functioning, inner thoughts and feelings, and the influences of our social and cultural environment.

Classifying Disorders—and Labeling People

14-3 How and why do clinicians classify psychological disorders, and why do some psychologists criticize the use of diagnostic labels?

In biology, classification creates order. To classify an animal as a “mammal” says a great deal—that it is warm-blooded, has hair or fur, and produces milk to feed its young. In psychiatry and psychology, too, classification orders and describes symptoms. To classify a person’s disorder as “schizophrenia” suggests that the person talks incoherently, has bizarre beliefs, shows either little emotion or inappropriate emotion, or is socially withdrawn. “Schizophrenia” is a quick way of describing a complex disorder.

image
Sidney Harris

But diagnostic classification gives more than a thumbnail sketch of a person’s disordered behavior, thoughts, or feelings. In psychiatry and psychology, classification also attempts to

531

DSM-5 the American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition; a widely used system for classifying psychological disorders.

The most common tool for describing disorders and estimating how often they occur is the American Psychiatric Association’s 2013 Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, now in its fifth edition (DSM-5). Physicians and mental health workers use the DSM-5 to guide medical diagnoses and treatment. For example, a person may be diagnosed with and treated for “insomnia disorder” if he or she meets all of the criteria in TABLE 14.1.

Table 14.1: TABLE 14.1
Insomnia Disorder (American Psychiatric Association, 2013)
  • Feeling unsatisfied with amount or quality of sleep (trouble falling asleep, staying asleep, or returning to sleep)

  • Sleep disruption causes distress or diminished everyday functioning

  • Happens three or more nights each week

  • Occurs during at least three consecutive months

  • Happens even with sufficient sleep opportunities

  • Independent from other sleep disorders (such as narcolepsy)

  • Independent from substance use or abuse

  • Independent from other mental disorders or medical conditions

In the new DSM-5, some diagnostic labels changed. The conditions formerly called “autism” and “Asperger’s syndrome” were combined under the label autism spectrum disorder. “Mental retardation” became intellectual disability. New categories, such as hoarding disorder and binge-eating disorder, were added.

Real-world tests (field trials) have assessed the reliability of the new DSM-5 categories (Freeman et al., 2013). Some diagnoses—such as adult posttraumatic stress disorder and childhood autism spectrum disorder—fared well, with clinician agreement near 70 percent (meaning that if one psychiatrist or psychologist diagnosed someone with one of these disorders, there was a 70 percent chance that another mental health worker would independently give the same diagnosis). Others, such as antisocial personality disorder and generalized anxiety disorder, have fared poorly, with about 20 percent agreement.

Critics have long faulted the DSM for casting too wide a net, and for bringing “almost any kind of behavior within the compass of psychiatry” (Eysenck et al., 1983). Some now worry that the DSM-5’s even wider net will extend the pathologizing of everyday life—for example, by turning bereavement grief into a depressive disorder and childish rambunctiousness into ADHD (Frances, 2013). (See Thinking Critically About: ADHD—Normal High Energy or Disordered Behavior? below.) Others respond that enduring hyperactivity and grief-related depression are genuine disorders (Kendler, 2011; Kupfer, 2012).

THINKING CRITICALLY ABOUT

ADHD—Normal High Energy or Disordered Behavior?

14-4 Why is there controversy over attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder?

Eight-year-old Todd has always been energetic. At home, he chatters away and darts from one activity to the next, rarely settling down to read a book or focus on a game. At play, he is reckless and overreacts when playmates bump into him or take one of his toys. At school, Todd fidgets, and his exasperated teacher complains that he doesn’t listen, follow instructions, or stay in his seat to do his lessons. As Todd matures to adulthood, his hyperactivity likely will subside, but his inattentiveness may persist (Kessler et al., 2010).

attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) a psychological disorder marked by extreme inattention and/or hyperactivity and impulsivity.

If taken for a psychological evaluation, Todd may be diagnosed with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Some 11 percent of American 4- to 17-year-old children receive the diagnosis after displaying its key symptoms (extreme inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity) (Schwarz & Cohen, 2013). Studies also find 2.5 percent of adults—though the number diminishes with age—exhibiting ADHD symptoms (Simon et al., 2009). The looser criteria for adult ADHD in the DSM-5 has led critics to fear increased diagnosis and overuse of prescription drugs (Frances, 2012, 2014).

To skeptics, being distractible, fidgety, and impulsive sounds like a “disorder” caused by a single genetic variation: a Y chromosome (the male sex chromosome). And sure enough, ADHD is diagnosed three times more often in boys than in girls. Does energetic child + boring school = ADHD overdiagnosis? Is the label being applied to healthy schoolchildren who, in more natural outdoor environments, would seem perfectly normal? Is ADHD a disease that is marketed by companies offering drugs that treat it (Thomas, 2015)?

Skeptics think so. In the decade after 1987, they note, the proportion of American children being treated for ADHD nearly quadrupled (Olfson et al., 2003). Minority youth less often receive an ADHD diagnosis than do White youth, but this difference has shrunk as minority ADHD diagnoses have increased (Genahun at al., 2013). How commonplace the diagnosis is depends in part on teacher referrals. Some teachers refer lots of kids for ADHD assessment, others none. ADHD rates have varied by a factor of 10 in different counties of New York State (Carlson, 2000). Depending on where they live, children who are “a persistent pain in the neck in school” are often diagnosed with ADHD and given powerful prescription drugs, notes Peter Gray (2010). But the problem may reside less in the child than in today’s abnormal environment, which forces children to do what evolution has not prepared them to do—to sit for long hours in chairs. In more natural outdoor environments, these children might seem perfectly healthy. When given cognitive tests, children with ADHD concentrate better when allowed to fidget (Hartanto et al., 2015).

Not everyone agrees that ADHD is being overdiagnosed. Some argue that today’s more frequent diagnoses of ADHD reflect increased awareness of the disorder, especially in those areas where rates are highest. They acknowledge that diagnoses can be inconsistent—ADHD is not as clearly defined as a broken arm. Nevertheless, declared the World Federation for Mental Health (2005), “there is strong agreement among the international scientific community that ADHD is a real neurobiological disorder whose existence should no longer be debated.” A consensus statement by 75 neuroimaging researchers noted that abnormal brain activity often accompanies ADHD (Barkley et al., 2002).

What, then, is known about ADHD’s causes? It is not caused by too much sugar or poor schools. ADHD often coexists with a learning disorder or with defiant and temper-prone behavior. ADHD is heritable, and research teams are sleuthing the culprit genes and abnormal neural pathways (Lionel et al., 2013; Poelmans et al., 2011; Volkow et al., 2009; Williams et al., 2010). It is treatable with medications such as Ritalin and Adderall, which are considered stimulants but help calm hyperactivity and increase one’s ability to sit and focus on a task—and to progress normally in school (Barbaresi et al., 2007). Psychological therapies, such as those focused on shaping classroom and at-home behaviors, also help to address the distress of ADHD (Fabiano et al., 2008).

The bottom line: Extreme inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity can derail social, academic, and vocational achievements, and these symptoms can be treated with medication and other therapies (Hinshaw & Scheffler, 2014). But the debate continues over whether normal high energy is too often diagnosed as a psychiatric disorder, and whether there is a cost to the long-term use of stimulant drugs in treating ADHD.

Other critics register a more basic complaint—that these labels are at best subjective and at worst value judgments masquerading as science. Once we label a person, we view that person differently (Bathje & Pryor, 2011; Farina, 1982; Sadler et al., 2012). Labels can change reality by putting us on alert for evidence that confirms our view. When teachers were told certain students were “gifted,” they acted in ways that brought out the creative behaviors they expected (Snyder, 1984). If we hear that a new co-worker is a difficult person, we may treat this person suspiciously. He or she may in turn react to us as a difficult person would. Labels can be self-fulfilling.

The biasing power of labels was clear in a classic study. David Rosenhan (1973) and seven others went to hospital admissions offices, complaining (falsely) of “hearing voices” saying empty, hollow, and thud. Apart from this complaint and giving false names and occupations, they answered questions truthfully. All eight healthy people were misdiagnosed with disorders.

image
Struggles and recovery During his campaign, Boston Mayor Martin Walsh spoke openly about his past struggles with alcohol. In the process, he moved beyond potentially biasing labels, and won a close election.
Gretchen Ertl/The New York Times/Redux

Should we be surprised? Surely not. As one psychiatrist noted, if someone swallowed blood, went to an emergency room, and spat it up, would we blame a doctor for diagnosing a bleeding ulcer? But what followed the Rosenhan study diagnoses was startling. Until being released an average of 19 days later, these eight “patients” showed no other symptoms. Yet after analyzing their (quite normal) life histories, clinicians were able to “discover” the causes of their disorders, such as having mixed emotions about a parent. Even the patients’ routine note-taking behavior was misinterpreted as a symptom.

532

In another study, people watched videotaped interviews. If told the interviewees were job applicants, the viewers perceived them as normal (Langer & Abelson, 1974, 1980). Other viewers who were told they were watching psychiatric or cancer patients perceived the same interviewees as “different from most people.” Therapists who thought they were watching an interview of a psychiatric patient perceived him as “frightened of his own aggressive impulses,” a “passive, dependent type,” and so forth. As Rosenhan discovered, a label can have “a life and an influence of its own.” Labels matter.

533

Labels also have power outside the laboratory. Getting a job or finding a place to rent can be a challenge for people recently released from a mental hospital. Label someone as “mentally ill” and people may fear them as potentially violent (see Thinking Critically About: Are People With Psychological Disorders Dangerous?). Such negative reactions may fade as people better understand that many psychological disorders involve diseases of the brain, not failures of character (Solomon, 1996). Public figures have helped foster this understanding by speaking openly about their own struggles with disorders such as depression and substance abuse. The more contact we have with people with disorders, the more accepting our attitudes become (Kolodziej & Johnson, 1996).

THINKING CRITICALLY ABOUT

Are People With Psychological Disorders Dangerous?

14-5 Do psychological disorders predict violent behavior?

September 16, 2013, started like any other Monday at Washington, DC’s, Navy Yard, with people arriving early to begin work. Then government contractor Aaron Alexis parked his car, entered the building, and began shooting people. An hour later, 13 people were dead, including Alexis. Reports later confirmed that Alexis had a history of mental illness. Before the shooting, he had stated that an “ultra low frequency attack is what I’ve been subject to for the last three months. And to be perfectly honest, that is what has driven me to this.” After a horrifying mass shooting in a Connecticut elementary school in 2012, New York’s governor declared, “People who have mental issues should not have guns” (Kaplan & Hakim, 2013). These devastating mass shootings, like many others since then, reinforced public perceptions that people with psychological disorders pose a threat (Barry et al., 2013; Jorm et al., 2012). So did an incident in March of 2015, when Germanwings co-pilot Andreas Lubitz, who had a history of mental illness, killed 150 people by locking his pilot out of the cockpit and intentionally crashing a commercial jet into the French Alps.

Does scientific evidence support the governor’s statement? If disorders actually increase the risk of violence, then denying people with psychological disorders the right to bear arms might reduce violent crimes. But real life tells a different story. Most people with mental disorders commit no violent crimes, and the vast majority of violent crimes are committed by people with no diagnosed disorder (Fazel & Grann, 2006; Skeem et al., 2015; Walkup & Rubin, 2013).

People with disorders are more likely to be victims than perpetrators of violence (Marley & Bulia, 2001). According to the U.S. Surgeon General’s Office (1999, p. 7), “There is very little risk of violence or harm to a stranger from casual contact with an individual who has a mental disorder.” The bottom line: Psychological disorders only rarely lead to violent acts, and focusing gun restrictions only on mentally ill people will likely not reduce gun violence (Friedman, 2012).

image
How to prevent mass shootings? Following the Newtown, Connecticut, slaughter of 20 young children and 6 adults, people wondered: Could those at risk for violence be identified in advance by mental health workers and reported to police? Would laws that require such reporting discourage disturbed gun owners from seeking mental health treatment?
Adrees Latif/Reuters/Landov

If mental illness is not a good predictor of violence, what is? Better predictors are a history of violence, use of alcohol or drugs, and access to a gun. The mass-killing shooters have one more thing in common: They tend to be young males. “We could avoid two-thirds of all crime simply by putting all able-bodied young men in cryogenic sleep from the age of 12 through 28,” said one psychologist (Lykken, 1995).

Mental disorders seldom lead to violence, and clinical prediction of violence is unreliable. What, then, are the triggers for the few people with psychological disorders who do commit violent acts? For some, the trigger is substance abuse. For others, like the Navy Yard shooter, it’s threatening delusions and hallucinated voices that command them to act (Douglas et al., 2009; Elbogen & Johnson, 2009; Fazel et al., 2009, 2010). Whether people with mental disorders who turn violent should be held responsible for their behavior remains controversial. U.S. President Ronald Reagan’s near-assassin, John Hinckley, was sent to a hospital rather than to prison. The public was outraged. “Hinckley insane. Public mad,” declared one headline. They were outraged again in 2011, when Jared Lee Loughner killed six people and injured several others, including U.S. Representative Gabrielle Giffords. Loughner was diagnosed with schizophrenia and twice found incompetent to stand trial. He was later judged competent to stand trial, pled guilty to 19 charges of murder and attempted murder, and was sentenced to life in prison without parole.

Which decision was correct? The first two, which blamed Loughner’s “madness” for clouding his judgment? Or the final one, which decided that he should be held responsible for the acts he committed? As we come to better understand the biological and environmental bases for all human behavior, from generosity to vandalism, when should we—and should we not—hold people accountable for their actions?

534

image
Better portrayals Old stereotypes are slowly being replaced in media portrayals of psychological disorders. Recent films offer fairly realistic depictions. Iron Man 3 (2013) portrayed a main character, shown here, with posttraumatic stress disorder. Black Swan (2010) dramatized a lead character suffering a delusional disorder. A Single Man (2009) depicted depression.
Paramount Pictures/Photofest

“What’s the use of their having names,” the Gnat said, “if they won’t answer to them?”

“No use to them,” said Alice; “but it’s useful to the people that name them, I suppose.”

Lewis Carroll, Through the Looking-Glass, 1871

Despite their risks, diagnostic labels have benefits. They help mental health professionals communicate about their cases and study the causes and treatments of disorder. Clients are often relieved to learn that the nature of their suffering has a name, and that they are not alone in experiencing their symptoms.

image To test your ability to form diagnoses, visit LaunchPad’s PsychSim 6: Classifying Disorders.

RETRIEVE IT

Question

G8C6DutxbmPuKY4XEscgxx4lWGZB5QZ2RLxXQn4fnDgEakcUmEWUTVqscvYSIdzo8XQG66hhXp4wf5qib5cnfhkjGaYfuzkMSFBAGc7xqdPkRTijERt7e4CJ6uDLh0VDLd2ncnIS+ube62VoqnhHBI5XMJ0XLwktc1VV/L7FWAGw9/7p
ANSWER: Therapists and others apply disorder labels to communicate with one another using a common language, and to share concepts during research. Clients may benefit from knowing that they are not the only ones with these symptoms. The dangers of labeling people are that (1) people may begin to act as they have been labeled, and (2) the labels can trigger assumptions that will change people's behavior toward those labelled.

Rates of Psychological Disorders

14-6 How many people have, or have had, a psychological disorder? Is poverty a risk factor?

image

Who is most vulnerable to psychological disorders? At what times of life? To answer such questions, various countries have conducted lengthy, structured interviews with representative samples of thousands of their citizens. After asking hundreds of questions that probe for symptoms—“Has there ever been a period of two weeks or more when you felt like you wanted to die?”—the researchers have estimated the current, prior-year, and lifetime prevalence of various disorders.

How many people have, or have had, a psychological disorder? More than most of us suppose:

Data from: National Institute of Mental Health, 2008.

image
Figure 14.2: FIGURE 14.2 Prior-year prevalence of disorders in selected areas From World Health Organization interviews in 20 countries (WHO, 2004a).

image See LaunchPad’s Video: Correlational Studies below for a helpful tutorial animation about this research design.

What increases vulnerability to mental disorders? As we have seen, the answer varies with the disorder (TABLE 14.3). One predictor of mental disorders—poverty—crosses ethnic and gender lines. The incidence of serious psychological disorders has been doubly high among those below the poverty line (Centers for Disease Control, 1992). This correlation, like so many others, raises further questions: Does poverty cause disorders? Or do disorders cause poverty? It is both, though the answer varies with the disorder. Schizophrenia understandably leads to poverty. Yet the stresses and demoralization of poverty can also breed disorders, especially depression in women and substance abuse in men (Dohrenwend et al., 1992). In one natural experiment investigating the poverty-pathology link, researchers tracked rates of behavior problems in North Carolina Native American children as economic development enabled a dramatic reduction in their community’s poverty rate. As the study began, children of poverty exhibited more deviant and aggressive behaviors. After four years, children whose families had moved above the poverty line exhibited a 40 percent decrease in behavior problems. Those who maintained their previous positions below or above the poverty line exhibited no change (Costello et al., 2003).

535

image

At what times of life do disorders strike? Usually by early adulthood. “Over 75 percent of our sample with any disorder had experienced [their] first symptoms by age 24,” reported Lee Robins and Darrel Regier (1991, p. 331). Among the earliest to appear are the symptoms of antisocial personality disorder (median age 8) and of phobias (median age 10). Alcohol use disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, bipolar disorder, and schizophrenia symptoms appear at a median age near 20. Major depressive disorder often hits somewhat later, at a median age of 25.

RETRIEVE IT

Question

P9okGsJY7uABLzoJoDzBf0xS75JRVxMk8a0OngtUmhxFEB+F7azSmv/x88T/KdXRdlgwr7mc62hlKihXXn50gDq2N7YfNNNwyBGiAqu+dG6V28gMd5mPTCF6SGU4jKvCCKIww4qjzNpVWmC7PbQp3xTR7yM=
ANSWER: Poverty-related stresses can help trigger disorders, but disabling disorders can also contribute to poverty. Thus, poverty and disorder are often a chicken-and-egg situation: It's hard to know which came first.

REVIEW Basic Concepts of Psychological Disorders

536

Learning Objectives

Test Yourself by taking a moment to answer each of these Learning Objective Questions (repeated here from within the chapter). Research suggests that trying to answer these questions on your own will improve your long-term memory of the concepts (McDaniel et al., 2009).

Question

BzV7yuKTYlYEKOUoMUcp4SnlKUcYvlHap4JZJcjb0t2Y6eam2mMhJQfAZgl7rdBl9C9GAva31HlYnfDNf9mCKRTQRhyZNUhbV/52dgPggLxLFRJaB5GIsq8A4ZwclYo2AN9Yqy8ntEguzOj2H1fOHH/VkXRKHvk0vLAyPTPQaegpWFkzcdqfhzA8W3gVRIgiMFbsrLf6ufdOKzSX2OrASwZNpsyfNm3wJwMZALtEpbs=
ANSWER: According to psychologists and psychiatrists, psychological disorders are marked by a clinically significant disturbance in an individual's cognition, emotion regulation, or behavior.

Question

7o9gbQgyGT2h3ABUaPU5YO38Lmdh+r5KU4XbHtnHzIg4nCe7ccHQj5uNFxDWroco5KInkJ/yxBq3bIZpQYMwCJ34LeAfSO6JLupEtmBgQNs3GErdUalWIpln/vOS/hIIY+5N4+fQtTgn8G0PyL0++kCL3jI8nMY4aEWmVGZrP6Zy+HvCPJQrLbsdZFOn1F3eIn2JnNZX2p/e94grBp0+V1oj9FY13PU3AFaMkFeDsSrKGaptN9vg/Lr+GI0sPALTS1y0xleHjvkUkAWBRfcx1O2VitsqWvhKdC2xjVakhPhUg/xM
ANSWER: The medical model assumes that psychological disorders are mental illnesses with physical causes that can be diagnosed, treated, and, in most cases, cured through therapy, sometimes in a hospital. The biopsychosocial perspective assumes that three sets of influences—biological (evolution, genetics, brain structure and chemistry), psychological (stress, trauma, learned helplessness, mood-related perceptions and memories), and social and cultural circumstances (roles, expectations, definitions of “normality” and “disorder”)—interact to produce specific psychological disorders. Epigenetics also informs our understanding of disorders.

Question

+Ak0zQmiGJNSIB6mcMAyjeAy9Q6uovMJyJCvmn7R9wBM+tFRu8HSC1XQ8xP+co1yCvxkKMYAwRNr/+ufGrvYzQzc7orcoxoWoYmKy+KEwRM0rXQuyuOTRazXI8TGAoBbg4G3c8C4WrIJRtmEtjE+1KrH5gIWeuhoEAjgVW2q27L5htiAcM+LlRAPsauoTG68j/gGdn0leqDPUXBz7M5KUpKVDEAaFxvuJcKGDuGtAYTbjDcNEevQ92hddQmIem8EkH9pSx3FNXgI9ARMA1eRnHNv2iJE5c27uPn7cJ9pJzxot4fDpp7i2yrlpbTKDcCxCkc8Hw==
ANSWER: The American Psychiatric Association's DSM-5 (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition) contains diagnostic labels and descriptions that provide a common language and shared concepts for communication and research. Most U.S. health insurance organizations require a DSM diagnosis before paying for treatment. Some critics believe the DSM editions have become too detailed and extensive. Others view DSM diagnoses as arbitrary labels that create preconceptions, which bias perceptions of the labeled person's past and present behavior.

Question

+xoKXHLxQGBcgHV7Oq34ETDbwtUMXoWN/6yom4SaUCi+nYqISRtXGr/vS2wO6mTtjJOfmRsoF3MCKyJRRdVC3B/YNdnkFtCFd7Si6MpG2xi2ZHBkJi2K+LUAxguM9v5zX7bjpdJ+acX1BFglKOf1JcrTBqcDazQXMoGZ3eHAdEU5GALahCt+sDI5c7m0x0uAKCiPFTkNTfqW4FVHzryRcYT1xcvdfShDi42PUA/I3Rsh0WtBKKCnoKtay4N+9whQJfhQOA9jGo1WldM4ZBnpAuvjfHmYvdPOk4SK2Y7P9K/MsTvf4Vw0Vi1tE5A=
ANSWER: A child (or, less commonly, an adult) who displays extreme inattention and/or hyperactivity and impulsivity may be diagnosed with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and treated with medication and other therapy. The controversy centers on whether the growing number of ADHD cases reflects overdiagnosis or increased awareness of the disorder. Long-term effects of stimulant-drug treatment for ADHD are not yet known.

Question

SGFHOHmX/S/CYCpIE3F/Atd/lu2gAan5OTKLk6aZUhPCldt91LwXFTpGT3YzOQnVh2XEBFWhGodsBurZD606SpJfvsDqhnDZFjLjN8jop1E+EhgsIxCPHS+dcwBmIID/81mQoaLaa5cUct16rdu79BtiqouHfnFHi72k8aAzEXPZ+AKek4BfcvjzyXTD0iEbAlANqtEjhNr7vcOFSMFHogHlndBtJCbB
ANSWER: Mental disorders seldom lead to violence, but when they do, they raise moral and ethical questions about whether society should hold people with disorders responsible for their violent actions. Most people with disorders are nonviolent and are more likely to be victims than attackers.

Question

7le9yGeqxpgciHOo9yS5ynSkZPcNtn3lyibl5Nc5qbLvl6h9x9CWgFmuY6wsc9n5oNmWzje53E77pA+QIvdoP4Oj6opst+MwjcujBrCGi5+OnIo7vY7bbwW392GjDUfuZ6IQ96ZDzetkl5OcfZaHDzYJFoHyLG0h6s9+Jl23VUmapAcbkq1dM/IMkdOO7OBhrakmW3tz0CYatYA02jhOc4sLL1NeMCzPDLquwx9vau76RD4IHcTEtpQjdFMAxbj4Q6CmFxWYYiCDBh11
ANSWER: Psychological disorder rates vary, depending on the time and place of the survey. In one multinational survey, rates for any disorder ranged from less than 5 percent (Shanghai) to more than 25 percent (the United States). Poverty is a risk factor: Conditions and experiences associated with poverty contribute to the development of psychological disorders. But some disorders, such as schizophrenia, can drive people into poverty.

Terms and Concepts to Remember

Test yourself on these terms.

Question

LfTJRAOog+3pNYrR5x4YoL0bSJ+Z+XZDkyPAoxyZmiSkKhNlW2cCIcYts5v0L+IoicJRdltkYtPOKOvQ+wFdU3NqQyTdCZbM0+cKysa/aCsTE+wx7jQX4g6JSfDQxmwyx0Lxg5sWNXtTA2jW6p8E7VbNj2Fjl2uH8eWvJ9rzU02Gn1XGlFaZqgiZe/BkMKYAN3GLkABWo9Zf4YZjSIHZTTE68A0vyOseSZk0F08R2XqB8oVbDga00eBysQF0okUUKQq2zjuep9HBBiQlZmUDK0d56QIKdh2GY04Zvez3astjtKOA0FJ9GNdJ6zrGzNqWGUNgNKuFqz0diWHb0GOIRrkvUx6ol+XgcC+prCBB0HEEgD5QU2noif2yZURBnGWIeGN9AIrg8BtSZ6uaZF9OeT7IGFQVb0IZvdwCKMZpL1Uk3bHtGI6EBozAz036DleXFHii54NLhXz8UxbvrCYWs96qFIy5vUA6zoDKuS3h73rvgnDl1w/hfKr6Ifx4I9WkLFFNAT/3YZveRLf/WwnP6ZH6FDYYBNftZcNZSZcWdyibbYkX9avZz8XTY9KU6elfvX0W06eOITvg19YzgL6ww07kwHLRyXbjyxxHJWhKJSUKpH7ZPct7KE5eWMwKvjbp2+uSnqE//STHk7JpDRqUrS0gT/N9lVdRjEsDeFrOvtnyd7PaLVZIAD3jdf1YIPlq8oWClyAAmwTDO+/4Bcrj1U4HJaQCQyaeFZ2GP3MQVVpYdadou5ARHcmYPn6fH7Tqmzd0v3U75iEzZ9hjPbMhfSlDST3HBMsc+WiQ2caMHnUWvRCqF1HlU61oXpBebtHZ42tLaM2TQf6Poq8QpkBW8myCYCFVA8zvaDGrN/6rMaml40wn7RKEfYq1lu0GrEbHhERy1TRGvifunOyRF9Qm9NXcIbCAzE049K68DTWegm0UfGS+nni2SH52QbXRcUiT4vPClZ9Zj1zlYQSeApCJhVcuqBf5jXT50abQl65RZtfAdEHsmn+XhmwE/VHUz0cNHuK/3h8gSyJoAWoXcYznzCTV1gX2eIeW16KuPl+tlkCp9EUycu9H4c+s31YPpwJPYrO6FW1Cxn/BTjV3Qu+vaZdM6iFr1f4cCyqtZo2XIiLB3Foje58E9qVSJCOMsmlvD2D/R6fuQJMwLCi9dZB4OsjwGv06AnfRbPSe1jDF6HGxFwC5tHQRno7Wrt7kWtUKeUf2YL9UNDdSM12/0yPBRe4LBrxZ0KJbXzW/bNlJolaDjS+06iUif5xe7atusuJUa0KADQ==

Experience the Testing Effect

Test yourself repeatedly throughout your studies. This will not only help you figure out what you know and don’t know; the testing itself will help you learn and remember the information more effectively thanks to the testing effect.

Question 14.1

1. Two major disorders that are found worldwide are schizophrenia and wghD5aUvBBjyKn8zyv+ChQ== .

Question 14.2

T0CbAUId5JwbX0RsL+ylAA2zcVcqpHp2xHk0/K34NjehcM0zOtR6JqCkpojDyo7OChCKMazMPdfBfyk850kLh4T5tkKreM6hk0xO5eDr3/mKDrkhwhA9NXEIDZfcHhfQ3wXKNHHMeukGDwrwBOVAUGcTjPYGI697w8WksJaEbLC6lX+a6oxhJAkgitQQCp/98XChjWWI4jbDT70Yk6XFdRRt1YPKUq0HmKnRjDNeCZ7u6TXiDot1QSZjhrEK7tqib7njS0g3Ywbhgb6Ld7T+Cbs5bY2dMiVfNjtwp1DyadUrYj9Ff0aOLJJRah2GhLODBgEIVHeHMdLebDBWLHsq0CfPKVv4+CWIlcVOtPnNajv79+EhjZcVn8PaO2PCjDmXPKkKPXsD5VRDBmHVpbseDtobaGmhf9bEE7HKP9X23WjaeWdqMiNj8+ryWq08SjVIDn0R+Fra6ME=
ANSWER: No. Anna's behavior is unusual, causes her distress, and may make her a few minutes late on occasion, but it does not appear to significantly disrupt her ability to function. Like most of us, Anna demonstrates some unusual behaviors that are not disabling or dysfunctional, and, thus, do not suggest a psychological disorder.

Question 14.3

PJAnyj/UCFXipNYUchg46clDH2STt2eUdIzRf05sn2FzBVfGYBpAWsRShfK1cR1ZzwFOmwsUn6gnzVgVqTXfYsgNuAeJCFH/S3xduqLl+OFaDry9f8pvOy7sihOEd5zx5NM5h6vFZlMnbRtVrevfR30b2S5OynQQlnFF4K5PjAOwxqq3Zl5kMS+KNiY7NmUWgha27OVrFpGykTiPjKeHkM0NKE+r5kJ19GMjYaTXsoLcgkk9rNOVMQ==
ANSWER: Susto is a condition marked by severe anxiety, restlessness, and fear of black magic. It is culture-specific to Latin America.

Question 14.4

4. A therapist says that psychological disorders are sicknesses and people with these disorders should be treated as patients in a hospital. This therapist believes in the N7ppw6c8g3pLcw1C model.

Question 14.5

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

Question 14.6

65IY8T07qDMMtwZInksva05hz0MIzLfDDgZ6Hs1lRgj0WlVsnpDYWqXCOavRxiuAZk28SL1r/DM7JeFPbal45V37QFlFX5NsKEsp8JcEsZs+cUbSbQOQJysG87EG4NJrUGdEQ5uT06x6WOZ5ui7BF/SdL/r+IHLr3iWKFXRpeVHbHJUqpJur8d7zyB3H0/2mhpHLno395kDSsiotnblUDhIVKj1QldPX7jyhZ9XxncB+C85kFqMOA5M2AdWT6S0bjWNxEejs5YIqt3XMV6/kaKOZL+A=
ANSWER: Critics have expressed concerns about the negative effects of the DSM's labeling. Recent critics suggest the DSM-5 casts too wide a net on disorders, pathologizing normal behavior.

Question 14.7

7. One predictor of psychiatric disorders that crosses ethnic and gender lines is KxmVKoBR2UZYYyt5 .

Question 14.8

0vRdVLpVARrkNom1XiIJ/6UuOq48rE7xIFejIeARsEU7gsRJcOzlT3HBZ1pNYPdxdWkSiRXeDn1DNF0D3t4T4EpKq7lYO1DXI0Jm48m9cz1eRmVfkf8fBFifeSuhQqfiayZx5IzlyLQzR+/eJQGCjUuCZE8HC7w4hYu5M1tyPWp8BJT5ZUBxgGlCZgC+5LmRar9j+ww8kFj4GyAMCNfDe7FySxam3X7vsmVb4V0itwpB9R2NpkOQChDOpgQEC87HNtKdOHntHJvHlPmcIch7OhG4whWHGMxkk9cpa5BRXlEmJTpuO3s2vVfWnxe3F1lFtIE71RTVrIB7hALFRvRN5NPSFELOV5VjuEw147n3UutsHymMTfj8smpGzz3KhmtuvrC6Sw==

Use image to create your personalized study plan, which will direct you to the resources that will help you most in image .