45.4 Therapeutic Lifestyle Change

45-3 How, by taking care of themselves with a healthy lifestyle, might people find some relief from depression? How does this reinforce the idea that we are biopsychosocial systems?

The effectiveness of the biomedical therapies reminds us of a fundamental lesson: We find it convenient to talk of separate psychological and biological influences, but everything psychological is also biological. Every thought and feeling depends on the functioning brain. Every creative idea, every moment of joy or anger, every period of depression emerges from the electrochemical activity of the living brain. The influence is two-way: When psychotherapy relieves obsessive-compulsive behavior, PET scans reveal a calmer brain (Schwartz et al., 1996).

image
Forest bathing In several small studies, Japanese researchers have found that walks in the woods—a practice called shinrin-yoku, or forest bathing—help lower stress hormone and blood pressure levels (Phillips, 2011).
©Randy Faris/Corbis

For years, we have trusted our bodies to physicians and our minds to psychiatrists and psychologists. That neat separation no longer seems valid. Stress affects body chemistry and health. Anxiety disorders, obsessive-compulsive disorder, posttraumatic stress disorder, major depressive disorder, bipolar disorder, and schizophrenia are all biological events. As we have seen over and again, a human being is an integrated biopsychosocial system. Thus, our lifestyle—our exercise, nutrition, relationships, recreation, relaxation, and religious or spiritual engagement—affects our mental health (Walsh, 2011).

image
Figure 15.8: FIGURE 45.4 Mind-body interaction The biomedical therapies assume that mind and body are a unit: Affect one and you will affect the other.

That lesson has been applied by Stephen Ilardi (2009) in training seminars promoting therapeutic lifestyle change. Human brains and bodies were designed for physical activity and social engagement, he notes. Our ancestors hunted, gathered, and built in groups. Indeed, those whose way of life entails strenuous physical activity, strong community ties, sunlight exposure, and plenty of sleep (think of foraging bands in Papua New Guinea, or Amish farming communities in North America) rarely experience depression. For both children and adults, outdoor activity in natural environments—perhaps a walk in the woods—reduces stress and promotes health (MacKerron & Mourato, 2013; NEEF, n.d., Phillips, 2011). “We were never designed for the sedentary, indoor, sleep-deprived, socially-isolated, fast-food-laden, frenetic pace of modern life,” says Ilardi (2014).

601

Ilardi was also impressed by research showing that regular aerobic exercise rivals the healing power of antidepressant drugs, and that a complete night’s sleep boosts mood and energy. So he invited small groups of people with depression to undergo a 12-week training program with the following goals:

image
Nicole Hill/Rubberball/Getty Images

In one study of 74 people, 77 percent of those who completed the program experienced relief from depressive symptoms, compared with 19 percent in those assigned to a treatment-as-usual control condition. Future research will seek to replicate this striking result of lifestyle change. Researchers will also try to identify which parts of the treatment produce the therapeutic effect. There is wisdom in the Latin adage Mens sana in corpore sano: “A healthy mind in a healthy body.” (FIGURE 45.4)

TABLE 45.1 summarizes selected biomedical therapies.

Table 15.4: TABLE 45.1
Comparing Biomedical Therapies
Therapy Presumed Problem Therapy Aim Therapy Technique
Drug therapies Neurotransmitter malfunction Control symptoms of psychological disorders. Alter brain chemistry through drugs.
Brain stimulation Severe, treatment-resistant depression Alleviate depression that is unresponsive to drug therapy. Stimulate brain through electroconvulsive shock, magnetic impulses, or deep brain stimulation.
Psychosurgery Brain malfunction Relieve severe disorders. Remove or destroy brain tissue.
Therapeutic lifestyle change Stress and unhealthy lifestyle Restore healthy biological state. Alter lifestyle through adequate exercise, sleep, and other changes.

RETRIEVE IT

Question

jcpj+dL23vY8zcFaB/m12S4cE7tHsO7pYIc4q67yfLllbNMIQUH1je2xgBfo2Z/BCBbofHSXFcKsJuvYGcWZM4umweJeX2jJvli1c0dJobNG/h7NdOlc5oGwbLM=
ANSWER: Exercise regularly, get enough sleep, get more exposure to light (get outside and/or use a light box), nurture important relationships, redirect negative thinking, and eat a diet rich in omega-3 fatty acids.