module 25 Weathering and Soil Science

274

Soil is a combination of geologic and organic material that forms a dynamic membrane over much of the surface of Earth. A variety of processes that occur in soil connect the overlying biology with the underlying geology. In this module we will explore the weathering of rocks that leads to the formation of soil and the development of specific soil horizons. We will discuss physical, chemical, and biological processes that take place in soils. Finally, we will examine human activities that degrade soils, including the process of mining.

Learning Objectives

After reading this module, you should be able to

The processes of weathering and erosion contribute to the recycling of elements

We have seen that rock forms beneath Earth’s surface under intense heat, pressure, or both heat and pressure. When rock is exposed at Earth’s surface, it begins to break down through the processes of weathering and erosion. These processes are components of the rock cycle, returning chemical elements and rock fragments to the crust by depositing them as sediments through the hydrologic cycle. This physical breakdown and chemical alteration of rock begins the cycle all over again, as shown in FIGURE 24.15. Without this part of the rock cycle, elements would never be recycled and the precursors of soils would not be present.

Weathering

Weathering occurs when rock is exposed to air, water, certain chemical compounds, or biological agents such as plant roots, lichens, and burrowing animals. There are two major categories of weathering—physical and chemical—that work in combination to degrade rocks.

Physical weathering The mechanical breakdown of rocks and minerals.

Physical weathering is the mechanical breakdown of rocks and minerals, shown in FIGURE 25.1. Physical weathering can be caused by water, wind, or variations in temperature such as seasonal freeze-thaw cycles. When water works its way into cracks or fissures in rock, it can remove loose material and widen the cracks, as illustrated in FIGURE 25.1a. When water freezes in the cracks, the water expands, and the pressure of its expansion can force rock to break. Different responses to temperature can cause two minerals within a rock to expand and contract differently, which also results in splitting or cracking. Coarse-grained rock formed by slow cooling or metamorphism tends to weather more quickly than fine-grained rock formed by rapid cooling or metamorphism.

275

image
Figure 25.1: FIGURE 25.1 Physical weathering. (a) Water can work its way into cracks in rock, where it can wash away loose material. When the water freezes and expands, it can widen the cracks. (b) Growing plant roots can force rock sections apart.

Chemical weathering The breakdown of rocks and minerals by chemical reactions, the dissolving of chemical elements from rocks, or both.

Biological agents can also cause physical weathering. Plant roots can work their way into small cracks in rocks and pry them apart, as illustrated in FIGURE 25.1b. Burrowing animals may also contribute to the breakdown of rock material, although their contributions are usually minor. However it occurs, physical weathering exposes more surface area and makes rock more vulnerable to further degradation. By producing more surface area for weathering processes to act on, physical weathering increases the rate of chemical weathering. Chemical weathering is the breakdown of rocks and minerals by chemical reactions, the dissolving of chemical elements from rocks, or both these processes. It releases essential nutrients from rocks, making them available for use by plants and other organisms.

image
Figure 25.2: FIGURE 25.2 Chemical weathering. Water that contains carbonic acid wears away limestone, sometimes forming spectacular caves.
(Mauritius/SuperStock)

Chemical weathering occurs most rapidly on newly exposed minerals, known as primary minerals. It alters primary minerals to form secondary minerals and the ionic forms of their constituent chemical elements. For example, when feldspar—a mineral found in granitic rock—is exposed to natural acids in rain, it forms clay particles and releases ions such as potassium, an essential nutrient for plants. Lichens can break down rock in a similar way by producing weak acids. Their effects can commonly be seen on soft gravestones and masonry. Rocks that contain compounds that dissolve easily, such as calcium carbonate, tend to weather quickly. Rocks that contain compounds that do not dissolve readily are often the most resistant to chemical weathering. In examining element cycles in Chapter 3, we noted that weathering of rocks is an important part of the phosphorus cycle.

Recall from Chapter 2 that solutions can be basic or acidic. Depending on the starting chemical composition of rock and the pH of the water that comes in contact with it, hundreds of different chemical reactions can take place. For example, as we saw in Chapter 2, carbon dioxide in the atmosphere dissolves in water vapor to create a weak acid, called carbonic acid. When waters containing carbonic acid flow into geologic regions that are rich in limestone, they dissolve the limestone (which is composed of calcium carbonate) and create spectacular cave systems (FIGURE 25.2).

Acid precipitation Precipitation high in sulfuric acid and nitric acid from reactions between water vapor and sulfur and nitrogen oxides in the atmosphere. Also known as Acid rain.

Some chemical weathering is the result of human activities. For example, sulfur emitted into the atmosphere from fossil fuel combustion combines with oxygen to form sulfur dioxide. That sulfur dioxide reacts with water vapor in the atmosphere to form sulfuric acid, which then causes acid precipitation. Acid precipitation, also called acid rain, is precipitation high in sulfuric acid and nitric acid from reactions between water vapor and sulfur and nitrogen oxides in the atmosphere. Acid precipitation is responsible for the rapid degradation of certain old statues and gravestones and other limestone and marble structures. When acid precipitation falls on soil, it can promote chemical weathering of certain minerals in the soil, releasing elements that may then be taken up by plants or leached from the soil into groundwater and streams.

image
Figure 25.3: FIGURE 25.3 Erosion. Some erosion, such as the erosion that created these formations in the Badlands of South Dakota, occurs naturally as a result of the effects of water, glaciers, or wind. The Badlands are the result of the erosion of softer sedimentary rock types, such as shales and clays. Harder rocks, including many types of metamorphic and igneous rocks, are more resistant to erosion.
(welcomia/Shutterstock)

276

Chemical weathering, due to either natural processes or acid precipitation, can contribute additional elements to an ecosystem. Knowing the rate of weathering helps researchers assess how rapidly soil fertility can be renewed in an ecosystem. In addition, because the chemical reactions involved in the weathering of certain granitic rocks consume carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, weathering can actually reduce atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations.

Erosion

Erosion The physical removal of rock fragments from a landscape or ecosystem.

We have seen that physical and chemical weathering results in the breakdown and chemical alteration of rock. Erosion is the physical removal of rock fragments (sediment, soil, rock, and other particles) from a landscape or ecosystem. Erosion is usually the result of two mechanisms. In one, wind, water, and ice move soil and other materials by downslope creep under the force of gravity. In the other, living organisms, such as animals that burrow under the soil, cause erosion. After eroded material has traveled a certain distance from its source, it accumulates. Deposition is the accumulation or depositing of eroded material such as sediment, rock fragments, or soil.

Erosion is a natural process: Streams, glaciers, and wind-borne sediments continually carve, grind, and scour rock surfaces (FIGURE 25.3). In many places, however, human land use contributes substantially to the rate of erosion. Poor land use practices such as deforestation, overgrazing, unmanaged construction activity, and road building can create and accelerate erosion problems. Furthermore, erosion usually leads to deposition of the eroded material somewhere else, which may cause additional environmental problems. We discuss human-caused erosion further in Chapters 10 and 11.

Soil links the rock cycle and the biosphere

Soil has a number of functions that benefit organisms and ecosystems. As you can see in FIGURE 25.4, soil is a medium for plant growth. It also serves as the primary filter of water as water moves from the atmosphere into rivers, streams, and groundwater. Soil contributes greatly to biodiversity by providing habitat for a wide variety of living organisms—from bacteria, algae, and fungi to insects and other animals. Soil and the organisms within it filter chemical compounds deposited by air pollution and by household sewage systems; some of these materials remain in the soil and some are released to the atmosphere or into groundwater.

image
Figure 25.4: FIGURE 25.4 Ecosystem services provided by soil. Soil serves as a medium for plant growth, as a habitat for other organisms, and as a recycling system for organic wastes. Soil also helps to filter and purify water.

277

In this section we will look at the formation and properties of soil.

The Formation of Soil

In order to appreciate the role of soil in ecosystems, we need to understand how and why soil forms and what happens to soil when humans alter it. It takes hundreds to thousands of years for soil to form. Soil is the result of physical and chemical weathering of rocks and the gradual accumulation of detritus from the biosphere. We can determine the specific properties of a soil if we know its parent rock type, the amount of time it has been forming, and its associated biotic and abiotic components.

FIGURE 25.5 shows the stages of soil development from rock to mature soil. The processes that form soil work in two directions simultaneously. The breakdown of rocks and primary minerals by weathering provides the raw material for soil from below. The deposition of organic matter from organisms and their wastes contributes to soil formation from above. What we normally think of as “soil” is a mix of these mineral and organic components. A poorly developed (young) soil has substantially less organic matter and fewer nutrients than a more developed (mature) soil. Very old soils may also be nutrient poor because over time plants remove many essential nutrients and water leaches away others. Five factors simultaneously determine the properties of soils: parent material, climate, topography, organisms, and time.

image
Figure 25.5: FIGURE 25.5 Soil formation. Soil is a mixture of organic and inorganic matter. The breakdown of rock and primary minerals from the parent material provides the inorganic matter. The organic matter comes from organisms and their wastes.

Parent Material

Parent material The rock material from which the inorganic components of a soil are derived.

A soil’s parent material is the underlying rock material from which a soil’s inorganic components are derived. Different soil types arise from different parent materials. For example, a quartz sand (made up of silicon dioxide) parent material will give rise to a soil that is nutrient poor, such as those along the Atlantic coast of the United States. By contrast, a soil that has calcium carbonate as its parent material will contain an abundant supply of calcium, have a high pH, and may also support high agricultural productivity. Such soils are found in the area surrounding Lake Champlain in Vermont and northern New York, as well as in many other locations.

Climate

278

Climate influences soil formation in a number of ways. Soils do not develop well when temperatures are below freezing because decomposition of organic matter and water movement are both extremely slow in frozen or nearly frozen soils. Therefore, soils at high latitudes of the Northern Hemisphere are composed largely of organic material in an undecomposed state, as we saw in Chapter 4. In contrast, soil development in the humid tropics is accelerated by rapid weathering of rock and soil minerals, leaching of nutrients, and decomposition of organic detritus. Climate also has an indirect effect on soil formation because it affects the type of vegetation that develops, and therefore the type of detritus left after the vegetation dies.

Topography

Topography—the surface slope and arrangement of a landscape—is another factor in soil formation. Soils that form on steep slopes are constantly subjected to erosion and, on occasion, more drastic mass movements of material as happens in landslides. In contrast, soils that form at the bottoms of steep slopes may continually accumulate material from higher elevations and become quite deep.

Organisms

Many organisms influence soil formation. Plants remove nutrients from soil and excrete organic acids that speed chemical weathering. Animals that tunnel or burrow—for example, earthworms, gophers, and voles—mix the soil, uniformly distributing organic and mineral matter. Collectively, soil organisms act as recyclers of organic matter. In the process of using dead organisms and wastes as an energy source, soil organisms break down organic detritus and release mineral nutrients and other materials that benefit plants.

Soil degradation The loss of some or all of a soil’s ability to support plant growth.

image
Figure 25.6: FIGURE 25.6 Erosion from human activity. Erosion in this cornfield in Tennessee is obvious after a brief rainstorm.
(Tim McCabe/USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service)

Human activity has dramatic effects on soils. For centuries, the use and overuse of land for agriculture, forestry, and other human activities has led to significant soil degradation: the loss of some or all of the ability of soils to support plant growth. One of the major causes of soil degradation is soil erosion, which occurs when topsoil is disturbed—for example, by plowing—or when vegetation is removed. As we saw in Chapter 3, these activities lead to erosion by water or wind (FIGURE 25.6).

279

While topsoil loss can happen rapidly—in as little as a single growing season—it takes centuries for the lost topsoil to be replaced. Compaction of soil by machines, humans, and livestock can alter its properties and reduce its ability to retain moisture. Compaction and drying of soil can, in turn, reduce the amount of vegetation that grows in the soil and thereby increase erosion. Intensive agricultural use and irrigation can deplete soil nutrients, and the application of agricultural pesticides can pollute the soil. In Chapters 11 and 14 we will return to the ways in which human activity affects the soil.

Time

The final factor that determines the properties of a soil is the amount of time during which the soil has developed. As soils age, they develop a variety of characteristics. The grassland soils that support much of the food crop and livestock feed production in the United States are relatively old soils. Because they have had continual inputs of organic matter for hundreds of thousands of years from the grassland and prairie vegetation growing above them, they have become deep and fertile. Other soils that are equally old, but with less productive communities above them and perhaps greater quantities of water moving through them, can become relatively infertile.

Soil Horizons

Horizon A horizontal layer in a soil defined by distinctive physical features such as texture and color.

O horizon The organic horizon at the surface of many soils, composed of organic detritus in various stages of decomposition.

image
Figure 25.7: FIGURE 25.7 Soil horizons. All soils have horizons, or layers, which vary depending on soil-forming factors such as climate, organisms, and parent material. Most soils have either an O or A horizon and usually not both. Some soils that have an O horizon also have an E horizon.

As soils form, they develop characteristic horizons, which are horizontal layers with distinct physical features such as color or texture, shown in FIGURE 25.7. The specific composition of those horizons depends largely on climate, vegetation, and parent material. At the surface of many soils is a layer known as the O horizon, composed of organic detritus such as leaves, needles, twigs, and even animal bodies, all in various stages of decomposition. The O horizon is most pronounced in forest soils and is also found in some grasslands. Organic matter is sometimes called humus (pronounced “hu-mus,” but often mispronounced by beginning students as hummus, the delicious food made from chickpeas, olive oil, and garlic). In actuality, only the most decomposed organic matter at the lowest part of the organic horizon is truly humus.

A horizon Frequently the top layer of soil, a zone of organic material and minerals that have been mixed together. Also known as Topsoil.

E horizon A zone of leaching, or eluviation, found in some acidic soils under the O horizon or, less often, the A horizon.

B horizon A soil horizon composed primarily of mineral material with very little organic matter.

C horizon The least-weathered soil horizon, which always occurs beneath the B horizon and is similar to the parent material.

In a soil that is mixed, either naturally or by human agricultural practices, the top layer is the A horizon, also known as topsoil, a zone of organic material and minerals that have been mixed together. In some acidic soils, an E horizon—a zone of leaching, or eluviation—forms under the O horizon or, less often, the A horizon. When an E horizon is present, iron, aluminum, and dissolved organic acids from the overlying horizons are transported through and removed from the E horizon and then deposited in the B horizon, where they accumulate. When an E horizon is present, it always occurs above the B horizon. The B horizon, commonly known as subsoil, is composed primarily of mineral material with very little organic matter. If nutrients are present in the soil, they will be in the B horizon. The C horizon—the least weathered soil horizon—occurs beneath the B horizon and is similar to the parent material.

Properties of Soil

280

Soils with different properties serve different functions for humans. For example, some soil types are good for growing crops and others are more suited for building a housing development. Therefore, to understand and classify soil types, we need to understand the physical, chemical, and biological properties of soils.

Physical Properties of Soil

The physical properties of soil refer to features related to physical characteristics such as size and weight. Sand, silt, and clay are mineral particles of different sizes. The texture of a soil is determined by the percentages of sand, silt, and clay it contains. FIGURE 25.8A plots those percentages on a triangle-shaped diagram that allows us to identify and compare soil types. Each location on the diagram has three determinants: the percentages of sand, of silt, and of clay. A point in the middle of the “loam” category (approximately at the “a” in “loam” in FIGURE 25.8) represents a soil that contains 40 percent sand, 40 percent silt, and 20 percent clay. We can determine this by following the lines from that point to the scales on each of the three sides of the triangle. If you are not certain which line to follow from a given point, always follow the line that leads to the lower value. For example, if you want to determine the percentage of sand in a sample represented by the red dot in FIGURE 25.8, you might follow the line out to either 60 percent sand or 40 percent sand; however, since you should always follow the line to the lower value, in this case the percentage of sand is 40 percent. The sum of sand, silt, and clay will always be 100 percent. Conversely, in the laboratory, a soil scientist can determine the percentage of each component in a soil sample and then plot the results. The name for the soil, for example “silty clay loam,” follows from the percentage of the components in the soil.

image
Figure 25.8: FIGURE 25.8 Soil properties. (a) Soils consist of a mixture of clay, silt, and sand. The relative proportions of these particles determine the texture of the soil. (b) The relative sizes of sand, silt, and clay.

The permeability of soil—how quickly soil drains—depends on its texture, shown in FIGURE 25.9. Sand particles—the largest of the three components—pack together loosely. Water can move easily between the particles, making sand quick to drain and quick to dry out. Soils with a high proportion of sand are also easy for roots to penetrate, making sandy soil somewhat advantageous for growing plants such as carrots and potatoes. Clay particles—the smallest of the three components—pack together much more tightly than sand particles. As a result, there is less pore space in a soil dominated by clay, and water and roots cannot easily move through it. Silt particles are intermediate both in size and in their ability to drain or retain water.

image
Figure 25.9: FIGURE 25.9 Soil permeability. The permeability of soil depends on its texture. Sand, with its large, loosely packed particles, drains quickly. Clay drains much more slowly.

281

The best agricultural soil is a mixture of sand, silt, and clay. This mixture promotes balanced water drainage and retention. In natural ecosystems, however, various herbaceous and woody plants have adapted to growing in wet, intermediate, and dry environments, so there are plants that thrive in soils of virtually all textures.

Soil texture can have a strong influence on how the physical environment responds to environmental pollution. For example, the ground water of western Long Island in New York State has been contaminated over the years by toxic chemicals discharged from local industries. One major reason for the contamination is that Long Island is dominated by sandy soils that readily allow surface water to drain into the groundwater. While soil usually serves as a filter that removes pollutants from the water moving through it, sandy soils are so permeable that pollutants move through them quickly and therefore are not filtered effectively.

Clay is particularly useful where a potential contaminant needs to be contained. Many modern landfills are lined with clay, which helps keep the contaminants in solid waste from leaching into the soil and groundwater beneath the landfill.

Chemical Properties of Soil

Chemical properties are also important in determining how a soil functions. Clay particles contribute the most to the chemical properties of a soil because of their ability to attract positively charged mineral ions, referred to as cations. Because clay particles have a negative electrical charge, cations are adsorbed—held on the surface—by the particles. The cations can be subsequently released from the particles and used as nutrients by plants.

Cation exchange capacity (CEC) The ability of a particular soil to absorb and release cations.

The ability of a particular soil to adsorb and release cations is called its cation exchange capacity (CEC), sometimes referred to as the nutrient holding capacity. The overall CEC of a soil is a function of the amount and types of clay particles present. Soils with high CECs have the potential to provide essential cations to plants and therefore are desirable for agriculture. If a soil is more than 20 percent clay, however, its water retention becomes too great for most crops as well as many other types of plants. In such waterlogged soils, plant roots are deprived of oxygen. Thus there is a trade off between CEC and permeability.

Base saturation The proportion of soil bases to soil acids, expressed as a percentage.

The relationship between soil bases and soil acids is another important soil chemical property. Calcium, magnesium, potassium, and sodium are collectively called soil bases because they can neutralize or counteract soil acids such as aluminum and hydrogen. Soil acids are generally detrimental to plant nutrition, while soil bases tend to promote plant growth. With the exception of sodium, all the soil bases are essential for plant nutrition. Base saturation is the proportion of soil bases to soil acids, expressed as a percentage.

image
Figure 25.10: FIGURE 25.10 Soil organisms. Bacteria, fungi, and protozoans account for 80 to 90 percent of soil organisms. Also present are snails, slugs, insects, earthworms, and rodents.

Because of the way they affect nutrient availability to plants, CEC and base saturation are important determinants of overall ecosystem productivity. If a soil has a high CEC, it can retain and release plant nutrients. If it has a relatively high base saturation, its clay particles will hold important plant nutrients such as calcium, magnesium, and potassium. A soil with both high CEC and high base saturation is likely to support high productivity.

Biological Properties of Soil

As we have seen, a diverse group of organisms populates the soil. FIGURE 25.10 shows a representative sample. Three groups of organisms account for 80 to 90 percent of the biological activity in soils: fungi, bacteria, and protozoans (a diverse group of single-celled organisms). Rodents and earthworms contribute to soil mixing and the breakdown of large organic materials into smaller pieces. Earthworms are responsible for abundant humus formation in soils. Some soil organisms, such as snails and slugs, are herbivores that eat plant roots as well as the aboveground parts of plants. However, the majority of soil organisms are detritivores, which consume dead plant and animal tissues and recycle the nutrients they contain. Some soil bacteria also fix nitrogen, which, as we saw in Chapter 3, is essential for plant growth.

282

The distribution of mineral resources on Earth has social and environmental consequences

image
Figure 25.11: FIGURE 25.11 Elemental composition of Earth’s crust. Oxygen is the most abundant element in the crust. Silicon, aluminum, and iron are the next three most abundant elements.

The tectonic cycle, the rock cycle, and soil formation and erosion all influence the distribution of rocks and minerals on Earth. These resources, along with fossil fuels, exist in finite quantities, but are vital to modern human life. In this section we will discuss some important nonfuel mineral resources and how humans obtain them; we will discuss fuel resources in Chapters 12 and 13. Some of these resources are abundant, whereas others are rare and extremely valuable.

Abundance of Ores and Metals

Crustal abundance The average concentration of an element in Earth’s crust.

As we saw at the beginning of this chapter, early Earth cooled and differentiated into distinct vertical zones. Heavy elements sank toward the core, and lighter elements rose toward the crust. Crustal abundance is the average concentration of an element in Earth’s crust. Looking at FIGURE 25.11, we can see that four elements—oxygen, silicon, aluminum, and iron—constitute over 88 percent of the crust. However, the chemical composition of the crust is highly variable from one location to another.

Ore A concentrated accumulation of minerals from which economically valuable materials can be extracted.

Metal An element with properties that allow it to conduct electricity and heat energy, and to perform other important functions.

Environmental scientists and geologists study the distribution and types of mineral resources around the planet in order to locate them and to manage their extraction or conservation. Ores are concentrated accumulations of minerals from which economically valuable materials can be extracted. Ores are typically characterized by the presence of valuable metals, but accumulations of other valuable materials, such as salt or sand, can also be considered ores. Metals are elements with properties that allow them to conduct electricity and heat energy and to perform other important functions. Copper, nickel, and aluminum are common examples of metals. They exist in varying concentrations in rock, usually in association with elements such as sulfur, oxygen, and silicon. Some metals, such as gold, exist naturally in a pure form.

Ores are formed by a variety of geologic processes. Some ores form when magma comes into contact with water, heating the water and creating a solution from which metals precipitate, while others form after the deposition of igneous rock. Some ores occur in relatively small areas of high concentration, such as veins, and others, called disseminated deposits, occur in much larger areas of rock, although often in lower concentrations. Still other ores, such as copper, can be deposited both throughout a large area and in veins. Nonmetallic mineral resources, such as clay, sand, salt, limestone, and phosphate, typically occur in concentrated deposits. These deposits occur as a result of their chemical or physical separation from other materials by water, in conjunction with the tectonic and rock cycles. Some ores, such as bauxite—the ore in which aluminum is most commonly found—are formed by intense chemical weathering in tropical regions.

Reserve In resource management, the known quantity of a resource that can be economically recovered.

The global supply of mineral resources is difficult to quantify. Because private companies hold the rights to extract certain mineral resources, information about the exact quantities of resources is not always available to the public. The publicly known estimate of how much of a particular resource is available is based on its reserve: the known quantity of the resource that can be economically recovered. TABLE 25.1 lists the estimated number of years of remaining supplies of some of the most important metal resources commonly used in the United States, assuming that rates of use do not change. Some important metals, such as tantalum, have never existed in the United States. The United States has used up all of its reserves of some other metals, such as nickel, and must now import those metals from other countries.

image

283

Mining Techniques

Mineral resources are extracted from Earth by mining the ore and separating any other minerals, elements, or residual rock away from the sought-after element or mineral. As illustrated in FIGURE 25.12, two kinds of mining take place on land: surface mining and subsurface mining. Each method has different benefits and costs in terms of environmental, human, and social perspectives.

image
Figure 25.12: FIGURE 25.12 Surface and subsurface mining. Surface mining methods include strip, open-pit, mountaintop removal, and placer mining.

Surface Mining

Strip mining The removal of strips of soil and rock to expose ore.

Mining spoils Unwanted waste material created during mining. Also known as Tailings.

284

A variety of surface mining techniques can be used to remove a mineral or ore deposit that is close to the surface of Earth. Strip mining, or the removal of “strips” of soil and rock to expose the underlying ore, is used when the ore is relatively close to Earth’s surface and runs parallel to it, which is often the case for deposits of sedimentary materials such as coal and sand. In these situations, miners remove a large volume of material, extract the resource, and return the unwanted waste material, called mining spoils or tailings, to the hole created during the mining. A variety of strategies can be used to restore the affected area to something close to its original condition.

Open-pit mining A mining technique that uses a large visible pit or hole in the ground.

Open-pit mining, a mining technique that creates a large visible pit or hole in the ground, is used when the resource is close to the surface but extends beneath the surface both horizontally and vertically. Copper mines are usually open-pit mines. One of the largest open-pit mines in the world is the Kennecott Bingham Canyon mine near Salt Lake City, Utah. This copper mine is 4.4 km (2.7 miles) across and 1.1 km (0.7 miles) deep.

Mountaintop removal A mining technique in which the entire top of a mountain is removed with explosives.

In mountaintop removal, miners remove the entire top of a mountain with explosives. Large earth-moving equipment removes the resource and deposits the tailings in lower-elevation regions nearby, often in or near rivers and streams.

Placer mining The process of looking for minerals, metals, and precious stones in river sediments.

Placer mining is the process of looking for metals and precious stones in river sediments. Miners use the river water to separate heavier items, such as diamonds, tantalum, and gold, from lighter items, such as sand and mud. The prospectors in the California gold rush in the mid 1800s were placer miners, and the technique is still used today.

Subsurface Mining

Subsurface mining Mining techniques used when the desired resource is more than 100 m (328 feet) below the surface of Earth.

When the desired resource is more than 100 m (328 feet) below Earth’s surface, miners must turn to subsurface mining, which is mining that occurs below the surface of Earth. Typically, a subsurface mine begins with a horizontal tunnel dug into the side of a mountain or other feature containing the resource. From this horizontal tunnel, vertical shafts are drilled, and elevators are used to bring miners down to the resource and back to the surface. The deepest mines on Earth are up to 3.5 km (2.2 miles) deep. Coal, diamonds, and gold are some of the resources removed by subsurface mining.

The Environment and Safety

The extraction of mineral resources from Earth’s crust has a variety of environmental impacts on water, soil, biodiversity, and other areas. In addition, mineral resource extraction can have human health consequences that affect the miners directly as well as other individuals who are affected by the mining process.

Mining and the Environment

As you can see in TABLE 25.2 all forms of mining affect the environment. Mining almost always requires the construction of roads, which can result in soil erosion, damage to waterways, and habitat fragmentation. In addition, all types of mining produce tailings, the residue that is left behind after the desired metal or ore is removed, and some tailings contaminate land and water with acids and metals.

image

In mountaintop removal, the mining spoils are typically deposited in the adjacent valleys, sometimes blocking or changing the flow of rivers. Mountaintop removal is used primarily in coal mining and is safer for workers than subsurface mining. In environmental terms, mining companies do sometimes make efforts to restore the mountain to its original shape. However, there is considerable disagreement about whether these reclamation efforts are effective. Damage to streams and nearby groundwater during mountaintop removal cannot be completely rectified by the reclamation process.

Placer mining can also contaminate large portions of rivers, and the areas adjacent to the rivers, with sediment and chemicals. In certain parts of the world, the toxic metal mercury is used in placer mining of gold and silver. Mercury is a highly volatile metal; that is, it moves easily among air, soil, and water. Mercury is harmful to plants and animals and can damage the central nervous system in humans; children are especially sensitive to its effects.

The environmental impacts of subsurface mining may be less apparent than the visible scars left behind by surface mining. One of these impacts is acid mine drainage. To keep underground mines from flooding, pumps must continually remove the water, which can have an extremely low pH. Drainage of this water lowers the pH of nearby soils and streams and can cause damage to the ecosystem.

285

Mining Safety and Legislation

Subsurface mining is a dangerous occupation. Hazards to miners include accidental burial, explosions, and fires. In addition, the inhalation of gases and particles over long periods can lead to a number of occupational respiratory diseases, including black lung disease and asbestosis, a form of lung cancer. In the United States, between 1900 and 2006, more than 11,000 coal miners died in underground coal mine explosions and fires. A much larger number died from respiratory diseases. Today, there are relatively few deaths per year in coal mines in the United States, in part because of improved work safety standards and in part because there is much less subsurface mining. In other countries, especially China, mining accidents remain fairly common.

As human populations grow and developing nations continue to industrialize, the demand for mineral resources continues to increase. But as the most easily mined mineral resources are depleted, extraction efforts become more expensive and environmentally destructive. The ores that are easiest to reach and least expensive to remove are always recovered first. When these sources are exhausted, mining companies must turn to deposits that are more difficult to reach. These extraction efforts result in greater amounts of mining spoils and more of the environmental problems we have already noted. Learning to use and reuse limited mineral resources more efficiently will help protect the environment as well as human health and safety.

Governments have sought to regulate the mining process for many years. Early mining legislation was primarily focused on promoting economic development, but later legislation became concerned with worker safety as well as environmental protection. The effectiveness of these mining laws has varied.

Congress passed the Mining Law of 1872 to regulate the mining of silver, copper, and gold ores as well as fuels, including natural gas and oil, on federal lands. This law, also known as the General Mining Act, allowed individuals and companies to recover ores or fuels from federal lands. The law was written primarily to encourage development and settlement in the western United States and, as a result, it contains very few provisions for environmental protection.

The Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act of 1977 regulates surface mining of coal and the surface effects of subsurface coal mining. The act mandates that land be minimally disturbed during the mining process and reclaimed after mining is completed. Mining legislation does not regulate all of the mining practices that can have harmful effects on air, water, and land. In later chapters we will learn about other U.S. legislation that does, to some extent, address these issues, including the Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, and Superfund Act.