Correct. The answer is d. The three diaries are simple reports of these women’s feelings and experiences, recorded only for themselves, and not intended to influence or reinforce others’ opinions or conclusions. McDonald’s and McGuire’s diaries depict instances of Union soldiers’ generosity, which, as Confederates, they would have been unlikely to manufacture. Trezevant’s report might well be accurate, but because he was a southerner reporting Union brutality, and because it was a document likely to have been created for the consumption of others, it is a less trustworthy source.
Incorrect. The answer is d. The three diaries are simple reports of these women’s feelings and experiences, recorded only for themselves, and not intended to influence or reinforce others’ opinions or conclusions. McDonald’s and McGuire’s diaries depict instances of Union soldiers’ generosity, which, as Confederates, they would have been unlikely to manufacture. Trezevant’s report might well be accurate, but because he was a southerner reporting Union brutality, and because it was a document likely to have been created for the consumption of others, it is a less trustworthy source.