3.16 Does echinacea reduce the severity of the common cold? In a study designed to evaluate the benefits of taking echinacea when you have a cold, 719 patients were randomly divided into four groups. The groups were (1) no pills, (2) pills that had no echinacea, (3) pills that had echinacea but the subjects did not know whether or not the pills contained echinacea, and (4) pills that had echinacea and the bottle containing the pills stated that the contents included echinacea. The outcome was a measure of the severity of the cold.7

  1. (a) Identify the type of data collected in this study. Give reasons for your answer.

  2. (b) Is this an experiment? If yes, what is the treatment?