www.macmillanhighered.com/
Our new course space, combines an interactive e-
is an adaptive quizzing engine that automatically adjusts questions to the student’s mastery level. With LearningCurve activities, each student follows a unique path to understanding the material. The more questions a student answers correctly, the more difficult the questions become. Each question is written specifically for the text and is linked to the relevant e-
NEW Work It Out Tutorials New to this edition, these tutorials guide students through the process of applying economic analysis and math skills to solve the final problem in each chapter. Choice-
Economics in Action Based on the feature from the text, these real-
Living Graphs Based on figures from the text, Living Graphs are animated and interactive graphs that first demonstrate a concept to students and then ask them to manipulate the graph or answer questions to check understanding.
Interactive Tutorials These interactive modules are designed to teach students key principles and concepts through example problems, animated graphs, and interactive activities.
Graphing Questions As a further question bank for instructors building assignments and tests, the electronically gradable graphing problems utilize our own robust graphing engine. In these problems, students will be asked to draw their response to a question, and the software will automatically grade that response. Graphing questions are tagged to appropriate textbook sections and range in difficulty level and skill.
Test Bank The Test Bank, coordinated by Doris Bennett, Jacksonville State University, provides a wide range of questions appropriate for assessing your students’ comprehension, interpretation, analysis, and synthesis skills. The Test Bank offers multiple-
End-
Practice and Graded Homework Assignments Each LaunchPad unit contains prebuilt assignments, providing instructors with a curated set of multiple-
Instructor’s Resource Manual The Instructor’s Resource Manual, revised by Nora Underwood, University of Central Florida, is a resource meant to provide materials and tips to enhance the classroom experience as it provides chapter objectives, chapter outlines, and teaching tips and ideas.
Solutions Manual Prepared by the authors of the text, the Solutions Manual contains detailed solutions to all of the end-
Interactive Presentation Slides This set of Interactive Presentation slides, designed by Solina Lindahl, CalPoly San Luis Obispo, is available as an alternative to traditional lecture outline slides. The slides are brief, interactive, and visually interesting to keep students’ attention in class. They offer instructors the following:
Additional graphics and animations to demonstrate key concepts
Many additional (and interesting) real-
Hyperlinks to other relevant outside sources, including links to videos, that provide even more helpful real-
Opportunities to incorporate active learning in your classroom
Aplia Worth/Aplia courses are all available with digital textbooks, interactive assignments, and detailed feedback. For a preview of Aplia materials and to learn more, visit www.aplia.com/
www.saplinglearning.com
Sapling Learning provides the most effective interactive homework and instruction that improves student-
We are indebted to the following reviewers, class testers, focus group participants, and other consultants for their suggestions and advice on previous editions.
Carlos Aguilar, El Paso Community College
Giuliana Campanelli Andreopoulos, William Patterson University
Seemi Ahmad, Dutchess Community College
Terence Alexander, Iowa State University
Morris Altman, University of Saskatchewan
Farhad Ameen, State University of New York, Westchester Community College
Dean Baim, Pepperdine University
Christopher P. Ball, Quinnipiac University
David Barber, Quinnipiac College
Janis Barry-
Sue Bartlett, University of South Florida
Hamid Bastin, Shippensburg University
Scott Beaulier, Mercer University
David Bernotas, University of Georgia
Marc Bilodeau, Indiana University and Purdue University, Indianapolis
Kelly Blanchard, Purdue University
Michael Bonnal, University of Tennessee, Chattanooga
Milicia Bookman, Saint Joseph’s University
Anne Bresnock, California State Polytechnic University, Pomona
Douglas M. Brown, Georgetown University
Joseph Calhoun, Florida State University
Colleen Callahan, American University
Charles Campbell, Mississippi State University
Douglas Campbell, University of Memphis
Randall Campbell, Mississippi State University
Kevin Carlson, University of Massachusetts, Boston
Joel Carton, Florida International University
Andrew Cassey, Washington State University
Shirley Cassing, University of Pittsburgh
Sewin Chan, New York University
Mitchell M. Charkiewicz, Central Connecticut State University
Joni S. Charles, Texas State University, San Marcos
Adhip Chaudhuri, Georgetown University
Sanjukta Chaudhuri, University of Wisconsin, Eau Claire
Eric Chiang, Florida Atlantic University
Hayley H. Chouinard, Washington State University
Abdur Chowdhury, Marquette University
Kenny Christianson, Binghamton University
Lisa Citron, Cascadia Community College
Steven L. Cobb, University of North Texas
Barbara Z. Connolly, Westchester Community College
Stephen Conroy, University of San Diego
Thomas E. Cooper, Georgetown University
Cesar Corredor, Texas A&M University and University of Texas, Tyler
Chad Cotti, University of Wisconsin, Oshkosh
Jim F. Couch, University of Northern Alabama
Maria DaCosta, University of Wisconsin, Eau Claire
Daniel Daly, Regis University
H. Evren Damar, Pacific Lutheran University
James P. D’Angelo, University of Cincinnati
Antony Davies, Duquesne University
Greg Delemeester, Marietta College
Patrick Dolenc, Keene State College
Christine Doyle-
Ding Du, South Dakota State University
Jerry Dunn, Southwestern Oklahoma State University
Robert R. Dunn, Washington and Jefferson College
Ann Eike, University of Kentucky
Harold Elder, University of Alabama
Tisha L. N. Emerson, Baylor University
Hadi Salehi Esfahani, University of Illinois
William Feipel, Illinois Central College
Rudy Fichtenbaum, Wright State University
David W. Findlay, Colby College
Mary Flannery, University of California, Santa Cruz
Sherman Folland, Oakland University
Robert Francis, Shoreline Community College
Amanda Freeman, Kansas State University
Shelby Frost, Georgia State University
Frank Gallant, George Fox University
Robert Gazzale, Williams College
Satyajit Ghosh, University of Scranton
Robert Godby, University of Wyoming
Fidel Gonzalez, Sam Houston State University
Michael G. Goode, Central Piedmont Community College
Douglas E. Goodman, University of Puget Sound
Marvin Gordon, University of Illinois at Chicago
Kathryn Graddy, Brandeis University
Alan Gummerson, Florida International University
Eran Guse, West Virginia University
Alan Day Haight, State University of New York, Cortland
Mehdi Haririan, Bloomsburg University
Clyde A. Haulman, College of William and Mary
Richard R. Hawkins, University of West Florida
Mickey A. Hepner, University of Central Oklahoma
Michael Hilmer, San Diego State University
Tia Hilmer, San Diego State University
Jane Himarios, University of Texas, Arlington
Jim Holcomb, University of Texas, El Paso
Don Holley, Boise State University
Alexander Holmes, University of Oklahoma
Julie Holzner, Los Angeles City College
Robert N. Horn, James Madison University
Scott Houser, Colorado School of Mines
Steven Husted, University of Pittsburgh
Hiro Ito, Portland State University
Mike Javanmard, Rio Hondo Community College
Jonatan Jelen, The City College of New York
Robert T. Jerome, James Madison University
Shirley Johnson-
David Kalist, Shippensburg University
Lillian Kamal, Northwestern University
Roger T. Kaufman, Smith College
Elizabeth Sawyer Kelly, University of Wisconsin, Madison
Herb Kessel, St. Michael’s College
Rehim Kilic, Georgia Institute of Technology
Grace Kim, University of Michigan, Dearborn
Miles Kimball, University of Michigan
Michael Kimmitt, University of Hawaii, Manoa
Robert Kling, Colorado State University
Colin Knapp, University of Florida
Sherrie Kossoudji, University of Michigan
Stephan Kroll, Colorado State University
Charles Kroncke, College of Mount Saint Joseph
Reuben Kyle, Middle Tennessee State University (retired)
Katherine Lande-
Vicky Langston, Columbus State University
Richard B. Le, Cosumnes River College
Yu-
David Lehr, Longwood College
Mary Jane Lenon, Providence College
Mary H. Lesser, Iona College
Solina Lindahl, California Polytechnic Institute, San Luis Obispo
Haiyong Liu, East Carolina University
Jane S. Lopus, California State University, East Bay
María José Luengo-
Volodymyr Lugovskyy, Indiana University
Rotua Lumbantobing, North Carolina State University
Ed Lyell, Adams State College
John Marangos, Colorado State University
Ralph D. May, Southwestern Oklahoma State University
Mark E. McBride, Miami University (Ohio)
Wayne McCaffery, University of Wisconsin, Madison
Larry McRae, Appalachian State University
Mary Ruth J. McRae, Appalachian State University
Ellen E. Meade, American University
Meghan Millea, Mississippi State University
Norman C. Miller, Miami University (Ohio)
Michael Mogavero, University of Notre Dame
Khan A. Mohabbat, Northern Illinois University
Myra L. Moore, University of Georgia
Jay Morris, Champlain College in Burlington
Akira Motomura, Stonehill College
Gary Murphy, Case Western Reserve University
Kevin J. Murphy, Oakland University
Robert Murphy, Boston College
Ranganath Murthy, Bucknell University
Anna Musatti, Columbia University
Christopher Mushrush, Illinois State University
Anthony Myatt, University of New Brunswick, Canada
ABM Nasir, North Carolina Central University
Gerardo Nebbia, El Camino College
Pattabiraman Neelakantan, East Stroudsburg University
Randy A. Nelson, Colby College
Charles Newton, Houston Community College
Daniel X. Nguyen, Purdue University
Pamela Nickless, University of North Carolina, Asheville
Dmitri Nizovtsev, Washburn University
Nick Noble, Miami University (Ohio)
Thomas A. Odegaard, Baylor University
Constantin Oglobin, Georgia Southern University
Charles C. Okeke, College of Southern Nevada
Terry Olson, Truman State University
Una Okonkwo Osili, Indiana University and Purdue University, Indianapolis
Maxwell Oteng, University of California, Davis
P. Marcelo Oviedo, Iowa State University
Jeff Owen, Gustavus Adolphus College
Orgul Demet Ozturk, University of South Carolina
James Palmieri, Simpson College
Walter G. Park, American University
Elliott Parker, University of Nevada, Reno
Michael Perelman, California State University, Chico
Nathan Perry, Utah State University
Brian Peterson, Central College
Dean Peterson, Seattle University
Ken Peterson, Furman University
Paul Pieper, University of Illinois at Chicago
Dennis L. Placone, Clemson University
Michael Polcen, Northern Virginia Community College
Linnea Polgreen, University of Iowa
Raymond A. Polchow, Zane State College
Eileen Rabach, Santa Monica College
Matthew Rafferty, Quinnipiac University
Jaishankar Raman, Valparaiso University
Margaret Ray, Mary Washington College
Helen Roberts, University of Illinois at Chicago
Jeffrey Rubin, Rutgers University, New Brunswick
Rose M. Rubin, University of Memphis
Lynda Rush, California State Polytechnic University, Pomona
Michael Ryan, Western Michigan University
Sara Saderion, Houston Community College
Djavad Salehi-
Jesse A. Schwartz, Kennesaw State University
Chad Settle, University of Tulsa
Steve Shapiro, University of North Florida
Robert L. Shoffner III, Central Piedmont Community College
Joseph Sicilian, University of Kansas
Judy Smrha, Baker University
John Solow, University of Iowa
John Somers, Portland Community College
Stephen Stageberg, University of Mary Washington
Monty Stanford, DeVry University
Rebecca Stein, University of Pennsylvania
William K. Tabb, Queens College, City University of New York (retired)
Sarinda Taengnoi, University of Wisconsin, Oshkosh
Henry Terrell, University of Maryland
Rebecca Achée Thornton, University of Houston
Michael Toma, Armstrong Atlantic State University
Brian Trinque, University of Texas, Austin
Boone A. Turchi, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill
Nora Underwood, University of Central Florida
J. S. Uppal, State University of New York, Albany
John Vahaly, University of Louisville
Jose J. Vazquez-
Daniel Vazzana, Georgetown College
Roger H. von Haefen, North Carolina State University
Andreas Waldkirch, Colby College
Christopher Waller, University of Notre Dame
Gregory Wassall, Northeastern University
Robert Whaples, Wake Forest University
Thomas White, Assumption College
Jennifer P. Wissink, Cornell University
Mark Witte, Northwestern University
Kristen M. Wolfe, St. Johns River Community College
Larry Wolfenbarger, Macon State College
Louise B. Wolitz, University of Texas, Austin
Gavin Wright, Stanford University
Bill Yang, Georgia Southern University
Jason Zimmerman, South Dakota State University
Our deep appreciation and heartfelt thanks to the following reviewers, whose input helped us shape this fourth edition.
Innocentus Alhamis, Southern New Hampshire University
Becca Arnold, San Diego Mesa College
Dean Baim, Pepperdine University
Jeremy Baker, Owens Community College
Jim Barbour, Elon University
Richard Beil, Auburn University
Joydeep Bhattacharya, Iowa State University
Joanne Blankenship, State Fair Community College
Emma Bojinova, Canisius College
Milica Bookman, Saint John’s University
Ralph Bradburd, Williams College
Mark Brandly, Ferris State University
Douglas Campbell, University of Memphis
Semih Cekin, Texas Tech University
Timothy Classen, Loyola University Chicago
Maryanne Clifford, Eastern Connecticut State University
Attila Cseh, Valdosta State University
Sean D’Evelyn, Loyola Marymount University
Ronald Dieter, Iowa State University
Christina Edmundson, North Idaho College
Hossein Eftekari, University of Wisconsin-
Mark Evans, California State University-
Cynthia Foreman, Clark College
Bruce Gervais, California State University-
Stuart Glosser, University of Wisconsin at Whitewater
Julie Gonzalez, University of California-
Robert Harris, Indiana University and Purdue University, Indianapolis
Hadley Hartman, Santa Fe College
Ryan Herzog, Gonzaga University
Scott Houser, Colorado School of Mines
Steven Husted, University of Pittsburgh
Ali Jalili, New England College
Carl Jensen, Seton Hall University
Donn Johnson, Quinnipiac University
Elizabeth Sawyer Kelly, University of Wisconsin, Madison
Farida Khan, University of Wisconsin-
Ara Khanjian, Ventura College
Janet Koscianski, Shippensburg University
Sherrie Kossoudji, University of Michigan
Stephan Kroll, Colorado State
Liaoliao Li, Kutztown University
Solina Lindahl, California Polytechnic State University
Haiyong Liu, East Carolina University
Fernando Lozano, Claremont McKenna College
Martin Ma, Washington State University
Stephen Marks, Claremont McKenna College
Mark McBride, Miami University
Ashley Miller, Mount Holyoke College
Myra Moore, University of Georgia
Kevin Murphy, Oakland University
Steven Nafziger, Williams College
Kathryn Nantz, Fairfield University
Gerald Nyambane, Davenport University
Fola Odebunmi, Cypress College
Tomi Odegaard, University of Nevada-
Tomi Ovaska, Youngstown State University
Tim Payne, Shoreline College
Sonia Pereira, Barnard College, Columbia University
David Pieper, City College of San Francisco
Paul Pieper, University of Illinois at Chicago
Arthur Raymond, Muhlenberg College
Greg Rose, Sacramento City College
Matt Rutledge, Boston College
Martin Sabo, Community College of Denver
Mikael Sandberg, University of Florida
Michael Sattinger, University at Albany
Duncan Sattler, Wilbur Wright College
Lucie Schmidt, Williams College
Zamira Simkins, University of Wisconsin-
Ralph Sonenshine, American University
Daniel Talley, Dakota State University
Kerry Tan, Loyola University, Maryland
Julianne Treme, University of North Carolina at Wilmington
Nora Underwood, University of Central Florida
Lee Van Scyoc, University of Wisconsin, Oshkosh
Mark Witte, Northwestern University
Jadrian Wooten, Pennsylvania State University
A special thanks must go to Ryan Herzog, Gonzaga University, for all of his hard work and many contributions to this edition. Ryan’s role began in the manuscript stage as data researcher, continued into pages with accuracy reviewing, and has now extended to the text’s media, with his expertly prepared Work It Out items. This is the first time we’ve had the opportunity to work with Ryan, and we count ourselves extremely fortunate to have found him (thank you, Charles Linsmeier, for that). Ryan has quickly become an indispensable and tireless advisor to everyone involved in the revision. Many thanks, as well, to Annie Voy, for her consulting work with Ryan on chapters like “Externalities.” Ryan’s efforts were also supported by accuracy checkers Dixie Dalton, Southside Virginia Community College, and Janet Koscianski, Shippensburg University. Dixie and Janet began their accuracy work on the third edition of our Economics in Modules text. They are both very good at what they do, and we are so happy that they were able to continue their work with us on the fourth edition of this text. Thanks to Marilyn Freedman, as well, for her contributions.
We must also thank the many people at Worth Publishers for their contributions: vice president, editorial, Charles Linsmeier, who ably oversaw the revision and contributed throughout; Shani Fisher, our new publisher, with whom we look forward to working on this and upcoming editions; Craig Bleyer, our original publisher at Worth and now national sales director, who always puts so much effort into making each edition a success; and Sharon Balbos, executive development editor on each of our editions, for her continued dedication and professionalism while working on our chapters.
We have had an incredible production and design team on this book, people whose hard work, creativity, dedication, and patience continue to amaze us. Once again, you have outdone yourselves. Thank you all: Tracey Kuehn, Lisa Kinne, and Jeanine Furino, for producing this book; Vicki Tomaselli for the beautiful interior design and cover; Diana Blume for her assistance with design and art preparation; Deb Heimann, for her thoughtful copyedit; Barbara Seixas and Stacey Alexander, who have worked magic with the project schedule; Cecilia Varas and Elyse Rieder for photo research and the many beautiful, new images you see in this edition; Edgar Bonilla for coordinating all the production of the supplemental materials; Mary Walsh and Bruce Kaplan for their ongoing assistance; and Carlos Marin for preparing the manuscript for production.
Many thanks to Lukia Kliossis and Rachel Comerford for devising and coordinating the impressive collection of online resources for students and instructors that accompany our book. Thanks to the incredible team of writers and coordinators who worked with Lukia; we are forever grateful for your tireless efforts.
Thanks to Tom Digiano, marketing manager, for his enthusiastic and tireless advocacy of this book; to Tom Acox, digital solutions director, who once worked on this text as an editorial assistant and now, from his new perch, offers an array of creative suggestions for our book, its website, and media.
And lastly, to all of you who have introduced our books to your students and colleagues, and who continue to shape our experience as textbook authors, we welcome and encourage your feedback, formal or informal, as we look forward to future revisions.
Please send your comments to wortheconomics@macmillan.com
Paul Krugman
Paul Krugman
Robin Wells
Robin Wells