Resistance, Rebellion, and Independence

The mid-eighteenth century witnessed frequent Andean Indian rebellions. In 1780, under the leadership of a descendant of the Inca rulers who took the name Túpac Amaru II, a massive insurrection exploded. Creoles joined forces with Spaniards and Indian nobles to crush the rebellion, shocked by the radical social and economic reforms promised by its leaders.

As news of the rebellion of Túpac Amaru II trickled northward, it helped stimulate the 1781 Comuneros Revolt in the New Granada viceroyalty (see Map 22.4). In this uprising, an Indian and mestizo peasant army commanded by Creole captains marched on Bogotá. Dispersed by the ruling Spanish, who made promises they did not intend to keep, the revolt in the end did little to improve the Indians’ lives.

image
MAP 22.4Latin America ca. 1780 and 1830By 1830 almost all of Central America, South America, and the Caribbean islands had won independence. Note that the many nations that now make up Central America were unified when they first won independence from Mexico. Similarly, modern Venezuela, Colombia, and Ecuador were still joined in Gran Colombia.

While these revolts shook authorities, two events outside of Spanish America did more to shape the ensuing struggle for independence. First, the revolution on Saint-Domingue and the subsequent independence of the nation of Haiti in 1804 convinced Creole elites, many of whom were slaveholders, of the dangers of slave revolt and racial warfare (see Map 22.3). Their plans and strategies would henceforth be shaped by their determination to avoid a similar outcome in Spanish America.

Second, in 1808 Napoleon Bonaparte deposed Spanish king Ferdinand VII and placed his own brother on the Spanish throne (see “The Grand Empire and Its End”). The Creoles in Latin America claimed that the removal of the legitimate king shifted sovereignty to the people — that is, to themselves.

The great hero of the movement for independence was Simón Bolívar (1783–1830). Under his leadership, a regional congress in Caracas declared the independence of the United States of Venezuela in July 1811 and quickly drafted a constitution guaranteeing freedom of the press and racial equality. The republic failed after only one year, but Bolívar continued to fight royalist forces for the next eight years, with assistance from the newly formed Haitian republic. His victories over Spanish armies won him the presidency of the new republic of Gran Colombia (formerly the New Granada viceroyalty) in 1819. The territories of Gran Colombia, however, soon splintered (see Map 22.4), and a sadly disillusioned Bolívar went into exile.

In 1808, after Napoleon’s coup, the Spanish viceroy assumed control of the government of New Spain from its capital in Mexico City. Meanwhile, groups of rebels plotted to overthrow royalist power. Under the leadership of two charismatic priests, poor Creoles and indigenous peasants rose up against the Spanish. This movement from below fell to royalist forces, but in 1821 a new movement commanded by Creole elites succeeded in winning independence from Spain.

Although Creole officers dominated rebel armies, their success depended on a rank and file largely composed of nonwhites. These included many blacks and free people of color. In Mexico many indigenous people also fought for the patriots, but elsewhere Indians were often indifferent to independence or felt their status was more secure with the royal government than with the Creoles.

In the 1830s regional separatism resulted in New Spain’s breakup into five separate countries. The failure of political union in New Spain and Gran Colombia isolated individual countries, prevented collective action, and later paved the way for the political and economic intrusion of the United States and other powers.

Brazil followed a different path to independence. When Napoleon’s troops entered Portugal, the royal family fled to Brazil and made Rio de Janeiro the capital of the Portuguese Empire. The king returned to Portugal in 1821, leaving his son Pedro in Brazil as regent. Under popular pressure, Pedro proclaimed Brazil’s independence in 1822, issued a constitution, and even led resistance against Portuguese troops. He accepted the title Emperor Pedro I (r. 1822–1831). Even though Brazil was a monarchy, Creole elites dominated society as they did elsewhere in Latin America.

1759–1788 Reign of Charles III, who instituted administrative and economic reforms
1794 Colombian Antonio Nariño publishes the French Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen
July 1811 Regional congress in Caracas declares independence of the United States of Venezuela
1822 Proclamation of Brazil’s independence from Portugal
1826 Call by Simón Bolívar for Panama conference on Latin American union
1830s New Spain breaks up into five separate countries
1888 Emancipation of slaves in Brazil
Table 22.5: KEY EVENTS IN EARLY LATIN AMERICAN REVOLUTIONS