FIG. 24.8
When and where did the most recent common ancestor of all living humans live?
BACKGROUND With the availability of DNA sequence analysis tools, it became possible to investigate human prehistory by comparing the DNA of living people from different populations.
HYPOTHESIS The multiregional hypothesis of human origins suggests that our most recent common ancestor was living at the time Homo ergaster populations first left Africa, about 2 million years ago.
METHOD Rebecca Cann compared mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequences from 147 people from around the world. This approach required a substantial amount of mtDNA from each individual, which she acquired by collecting placentas from women after childbirth. Instead of sequencing the mtDNA, Cann inferred differences among sequences by digesting the mtDNA with different restriction enzymes, each of which cuts DNA at a specific sequence (Chapter 12). If the sequence is present, the enzyme cuts. If any base in the recognition site of the restriction enzyme has changed in an individual, the enzyme does not cut. The resulting fragments were then separated by gel electrophoresis. By using 12 different enzymes, Cann was able to assay a reasonable proportion of all the mtDNA sequence variation present in the sample.
Here, we see a sample dataset for four people and a chimpanzee. There are seven varying restriction sites:
ANALYSIS The data were converted into a family tree by using shared derived characters, described in Chapter 23. By mapping the pattern of changes in this way, the phylogenetic relationships of the mtDNA sequences can be reconstructed. For example, the derived “cut” state at restriction site 1 shared by the East African, Japanese, and Native American sequences implies that the three groups had a common ancestor in which the mutation that created the new restriction site occurred.
493
RESULTS AND CONCLUSION A simplified version of Cann’s phylogenetic tree based on mtDNA is shown below. Modern humans arose relatively recently in Africa, and their most common ancestor lived about 200,000 years ago. The multiregional hypothesis is rejected. Also, the data revealed that all non-
FOLLOW-
SOURCE Cann, R. L., M. Stoneking, and A. C. Wilson. 1987. “Mitochondrial DNA and Human Evolution.” Nature 325:31–