Food for a Dollar

[[Patterns 13e_e-Reading for Exemplification]]

Kerri MacDonald

Photographs by Jonathan Blaustein

Kerri MacDonald is a freelance journalist and photographer who regularly contributes to the Lens blog at the New York Times. Her work has appeared in various outlets, including the Huffington Post and Crain’s New York Business. She has a BA from Queen’s University in Ontario, Canada, and an MA from the City University of New York.

Jonathan Blaustein is a photographer, writer, teacher, and artist whose work has been widely exhibited in the United States. He graduated from Duke University and earned an MFA in photography from the Pratt Institute. He created the conceptual photo series The Value of a Dollar between 2008 and 2010. The project aims to use food as a symbol language to discuss issues like health, wealth, commodification, and climate change in the twenty-first century. Each photograph represents one dollar’s worth of food purchased in the markets of northern New Mexico, where the artist resides. The images were created without any styling, retouching, or artificial light, so the food items are depicted as they actually appear, not as they are presented to us through traditional advertisements in the media.

One dollar’s worth of Shurfine flour, 2008One dollar’s worth of Shurfine flour, 2008

One dollar’s worth of double cheeseburger from McDonalds, 2008One dollar’s worth of double cheeseburger from McDonalds, 2008

One dollar’s worth of organic grapefruit from a natural food store, 2008One dollar’s worth of organic grapefruit from a natural food store, 2008

One dollar’s worth of conventional grapefruit from Supersave, 2008One dollar’s worth of conventional grapefruit from Supersave, 2008

One dollar’s worth of tomatillos from Mexico, 2008One dollar’s worth of tomatillos from Mexico, 2008

One dollar’s worth of candy necklaces from China, 2008One dollar’s worth of candy necklaces from China, 2008

One dollar’s worth of panko breadcrumbs from Japan, 2008One dollar’s worth of panko breadcrumbs from Japan, 2008

One dollar’s worth of Shurfine white bread, 2008One dollar’s worth of Shurfine white bread, 2008

One dollar’s worth of potted meat food product, 2008One dollar’s worth of potted meat food product, 2008

One dollar’s worth of organic basmati rice from Whole Foods, 2008One dollar’s worth of organic basmati rice from Whole Foods, 2008

One dollar’s worth of tea biscuits from Spain, 2008One dollar’s worth of tea biscuits from Spain, 2008

One dollar’s worth of shrimp-flavored ramen noodles, 2008One dollar’s worth of shrimp-flavored ramen noodles, 2008

One dollar’s worth of beef shank from Supersave, 2008One dollar’s worth of beef shank from Supersave, 2008

One dollar’s worth of pork floss, 2008One dollar’s worth of pork floss, 2008

One dollar’s worth of saffron, 2008One dollar’s worth of saffron, 2008

One dollar’s worth of side salad with ranch dressing from Burger King, 2008One dollar’s worth of side salad with ranch dressing from Burger King, 2008

One dollar’s worth of escargot from Indonesia, 2008One dollar’s worth of escargot from Indonesia, 2008

One dollar’s worth of early-season organic blueberries from California, 2008One dollar’s worth of early-season organic blueberries from California, 2008

One dollar’s worth of dried smelt, 2008One dollar’s worth of dried smelt, 2008

[image gallery goes here. captions for each image given below]

When Jonathan Blaustein bought 10 early-season organic blueberries for $1, he was a little upset by the price tag.

It wasn’t the visual contrast — one dime to one blueberry — that perturbed him. It was the fact that six weeks earlier, he had purchased 17 organic blueberries from Chile for the same price.

“The blueberries from Chile were almost half the cost of the blueberries from 800 miles away,” said Mr. Blaustein, a cook-turned-photographer who arranged the berries in two neat rows of five and photographed them, in all of their organic goodness.

He did the same thing with seven packages of shrimp-flavored ramen noodles, 48 tea biscuits from Spain, a little pile of rice.

It was a cheeseburger that initially encouraged Mr. Blaustein, 36, to pursue his project, “The Value of a Dollar.” When the economy was in the midst of its downward spiral, he visited a fast-food chain in New Mexico, where he lives.

“On one menu they had a cheeseburger for a dollar,” he said. What caught his eye, though, was another menu, which featured a double cheeseburger for the same price. That additional piece of meat, and the extra slice of cheese, somehow didn’t change the price.

So he set out to see what he could buy for one dollar in New Mexico. Then he turned the techniques used in advertising on their head, showcasing food in its most realistic form.

“I thought, Well, I know what they tell me it looks like,” he said. “What about what it actually looks like?”

Mr. Blaustein painted the walls of his apartment white and used what he had at his disposal — a sharp lens and a shallow depth of field — to create the same illusions used in the ad industry. Rather than setting up a tripod and shooting every image the same way, he got personal with his food. He wanted to represent it as it really is.

“We’re all bombarded with images in the mass media, and these images are not true representations of the food item itself,” Mr. Blaustein said. “It’s sort of like a simulacrum of the burger.”

Mr. Blaustein, who is represented by Zane Bennett Contemporary Art in Santa Fe, is originally from New Jersey. In 2004, he received a master of arts from the Pratt Institute, where he studied conceptual art and photography. He has also studied economics and globalization — interests that worked their way into the series.

The project allowed him to ask questions about the things North Americans eat in a fast-food culture. Is this food? Just because we can put something in our mouths, does that make it food? At what point do we decide that something isn’t food?

To let the global supply chain work its magic, Mr. Blaustein used only products he could find in northern New Mexico. He wants viewers to visualize how interconnected global commerce can be.

So did he eat the food? Yes — the blueberries, organic grapefruit, tomatillos, basmati rice, Spanish cookies and saffron. He gave the flour to a nearby soup kitchen.

And the rest?

“I put some of the nastier items outside for the birds, dogs, and coyotes.”

Source: http://lens.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/10/08/food-for-a-dollar/?_r=1

Questions

Read the text and examine the images in “Food for a Dollar,” and respond to the following questions.

Comprehension

Question 8.1

RXkA4Z8y1mJ2fEb0DJ9wFWNk4PeVhqx4kcIjNTGIEdUIsR5Mprf/CLOwLtopJigB+8KMmUgNWob4MF6MiWdBn5v3scPGL/Ar64VLtsNAeGc=

Question 8.2

Bk4Mw3KbyvszzdlRVkCckxamSmOhNlTK31RIgBs6bcGOV+v5twbn1QgFJMozPzrw+5JFS16ea9qRWcredZAh1k6SxuPBYdSguiE7qo11neV1Xr8camvODKXzdII=

Purpose and Audience

Question 8.3

sNod7MxTjIzw2/PzFB3kKsz6pkxuJReNTrW0dJDYXJP/3VQBPuUg1H3DRJnEj+pevxV/CEDAdAhEtZjXq3Lcx4ALD2sCUjG28WaU/FVm9510Mx2B6+eytyap1jZ9KInjf2x3XcaWwJ7AjH57BxsM88rkyKVuo2DOJps8NuBK+NinjeJPfPF8r8mLYxg8w/U6cCr8D+k3YLRxhQUTHxRk1YWSIBhfuO6YISbZ9LZ5r9ZiIAPR4XQqo4RfKe/AupJQo7fB1dWxWrwjUSU64xdIlku6f45LDTA7cvPoppplkFKPTcE4f2nKLYvQb0mNZNpT6Bbwblm0YEFbt+Tc4JVI3oYzom3io5ibQy+w880SDMvQzXVY8x5iVg==

Question 8.4

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

Mode

Question 8.5

NvTCl2+JMicWwiyHTN9WVXv7eBUG+ISdFK6dNdw6qcA+F+oN5jVwUKhT5TK8A/+qxkA/W9n4PRTy8q5G9flRLh3MSjQbvSAJ7jtttejEg2luCQW9s7FyC9yuFtW4fzPaxTjD0ca6yAZS9R8R7Hql84qhvbBJk5J+VF+WSVcwB9ZaoWVEtncowHy461Jt/vIl6iU+LWrwqpzjZgP+swJ1evVp+KjyX0QSOQFZP3bfpvfIaJPpKT4Csf1C/fktiOuyc5c9Di9OQ/K5AAPyv+2/ZhHNcBgHMDibZCDVrBkO4Ct7GxSssLN2ZNcTCB24E4gxgDh2q3/3nfiBwIdajagqaL06TTHYsq3MaPnObicZipSWm1NL

Question 8.6

KF1omosuXyiktDoJyQHrEon3r/IPVXRQ9A7SRocxMI7OUVBnSfkaar8YaJas/fbfK3cCPAQ/zzQQ/2YJO4324pJTdPZlTBc88jUmmX/dNvImsuAEY11gW0sMmaDlfC8uLKAMIJV4fYApCmx47k8hqkLT8AlTQOrxqmeDkWdcwqG9qV360t752gow8bWgbL8mroeC98GdEkvBpp4l/TpTbDUdq1+itWXZ

Writing Workshop

Question 8.7

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

Question 8.8

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