A Day at the Beach
By Justin Hines, Lafayette College and Marcy Osgood, University of New Mexico
Instructor Notes for “A Day at the Beach”, Lipid Metabolism Case Study
Topic Pre-requisites: Students should have exposure to the topics through Chapter 22 in Berg Biochemistry, 8th ed.
Overview
This case is designed to help students understand the importance of fatty acid transport into mitochondria, the role of carnitine in this process, and the interconnections between carbohydrate and lipid metabolism in humans. The case also explores the roles of the hormones insulin and glucagon in regulating energy metabolism in humans. As such, we have anticipated that students will have been exposed to material in the textbook through Chapter 22 of Berg Biochemistry, 8th ed. before beginning the case (coverage of chapters 19 and 20 is not necessary). Students may work individually or in groups to complete this case study. Students are constantly encouraged to refer to their textbook throughout the case, and internet access is permitted, although it is not necessary for the completion of the case. Students are required to iteratively acquire, analyze, and integrate data as they progress through the case and answer assessment questions found throughout the case. All assessment questions are automatically scored.
The case will also keep track of the number of investigations that students conduct and report this number to the instructor; students are made aware of this fact as a means to encourage careful consideration of investigation options and discourage guessing. It is entirely up to the instructor what to do with this information; we suggest potentially rewarding students who efficiently solve the case and/or penalizing students who obviously relied on blanket guessing (evident by the use of all or nearly all investigative options). For reference: there are 34 total investigative options within the case and 13 are minimally required to complete the case. We anticipate that careful students will typically make use of 15-20 options in solving this case.
Learning Objectives
This case is intended for remediating or extending these student capabilities:
1. The real-world application of the study of human metabolism. Students will:
2. Making connections between carbohydrate and fat metabolism in humans. Students should be able to:
3. Practicing critical thinking skills involving data. Students will:
Some questions are designed to show areas of difficulty for students
Suggested implementation
Below we describe two options for course implementation. The hybrid Online/In-class approach is recommended. Time required for students to complete the online case will vary by group depending on the level of discussion between each investigation. The case study can be started and stopped, and so it is recommended to give students a window of 3-5 days in which to complete the assignment.
Hybrid: Online/In-class (recommended approach; ~30 minutes of class-time expected):
1. Share the case study link with your students to use to work online outside of class, preferably in pairs or groups of three. Assign the case study to be due before your next class meeting. Students should be instructed to bring copies of notes, and/or printed answers to assessment questions to the following class period.
2. Review the online answers before the following class for difficult areas for students (see expected areas of difficulty above).
3. Lead students in a discussion in pairs, groups, or as a class (depending upon class size and instructor preference) to address unresolved difficulties (~30 minutes in-class time).
4. We recommend using the supplied assessment questions on exams or as homework assignments to reinforce the difficult concepts covered. Please see the document “Exam Questions Case 3- Lipid Metabolism”
Online only approach (minimal in-class time required):
1. Share the case study link with your students to work online, preferably in pairs or groups of three. Assign the case study to be due before your next class meeting.
2. Review the online answers for difficult areas for students (see expected areas of difficulty above).
3. Mention or remediate tough points during a portion of lecture.
4. We recommend using the supplied assessment questions on exams or as homework assignments to reinforce the difficult concepts covered. Please see the document “Exam Questions – A Day at the Beach - Lipid Metabolism Case”
Suggestions for in-class discussions (these questions may also be used in summative assessments such as exams and scored quizzes):
You may be missing vital information needed to sufficiently explain this incident. You must complete all investigations before proceeding to the final assessment questions.
You may be missing vital information needed to sufficiently explain this incident. You must complete all investigations before proceeding to the final assessment questions.
This activity has already been completed, however feel free to review the information contained within.
I am finished gathering information for this investigation and feel I am able to fully explain the reason(s) for Jesse’s incident in biochemical and physiological terms, and I can fully justify and completely explain my reasoning based on the evidence I have gathered.
Jessie knew she was late for the family reunion, probably too late for the big picnic lunch at Forest Lake Beach, but too early for the barbecue dinner. “Too bad” she thought, because she had skipped breakfast as well, trying to get out of the city and on the road to the lake. Perhaps there would be some leftovers; she hoped so, because she was beginning to get that slightly dizzy feeling that meant she was pushing her limits.
No leftovers, but the whole extended family was there: sitting and talking on the beach, playing Frisbee golf, and throwing a football. Some of the younger cousins were having swimming contests out from the floating platform at the edge of the swimming area. Jessie watched the kids swimming, and smiled sadly. She had been a competitive swimmer as a teenager and still missed it. As she watched the group of splashing children, Jessie began to think that something wasn’t right about a little boy off to the right of all the others. She put her hand up to shade her eyes from the sun and squinted; the kid was in trouble! He was throwing his arms around randomly, and thrashing the water into froth. None of the other children were close enough to notice, and there didn’t seem to be any other adults near enough to raise the alarm.
Without any further thought, Jessie ran into the lake, and after the first few lunges through the water, dove shallowly and began swimming towards the now sinking child. Her muscle memory kicked in and her strokes became fast, efficient, and powerful. With each stroke she raised her head enough to keep the small head in sight; she was making progress, but he was going down! She pushed harder, picked up speed, and then she saw him, underwater, sinking quickly despite his frenzied paddling. Jessie took a breath and dove; she grabbed the little guy’s surfer swim shorts, and kicked hard back toward the surface. She began the one-sided stroke that allowed her to keep his head above the water, and swam toward the beach, which seemed, strangely, to be disappearing into a haze. Jessie felt exhausted, but kept swimming, breathing in short gasps. Her vision narrowed, and she barely felt the sand under her knees as reached the shallow water. As the little boy was taken from her arms, Jessie lost consciousness.
Jessie woke up in the hospital emergency room, very weak and confused. She tried to sit up, but her arms and legs felt heavy, completely without strength. She was dizzy, disoriented, and exhausted. A gray-haired woman in a short white coat came into view, as well as a younger person dressed in scrubs.
“Hello, Jessie. Glad to see you’re finally awake. You were out for a pretty long time. I understand you are a hero; saved the day and your little cousin. Can you tell me what happened to make you faint? Did you hit your head, or swallow too much water? Everyone said that you were a really good swimmer, and so no one understood why you fainted.”
Jessie took a deep and unsteady breath. “I haven’t tried to swim that hard since I had a head injury, 5 years ago." When the ER doctor asked Jessie if anything like this had happened to her before, she looked sheepish and said “yes”. She recalled similar episodes, all under similar circumstances—"pushing herself too hard".
You are a biochemistry student who is shadowing the ER doctor. With the assistance of the physician, you may conduct additional investigations to determine the cause of Jessie’s incident. The goal of this exercise is to correctly solve the biochemical case without carrying out completely unnecessary investigations; hence, you are encouraged to carefully consider the information you receive with each investigation and avoid haphazard guessing. You will be scored on this exercise based on your answers to assessment questions found throughout the case so you are STRONGLY encouraged to use your textbook to complete this exercise; you may also use the internet as necessary.
Please note that there is a minimum set of investigations that must be conducted in order to have all the necessary information to fully understand the case. The number of investigations you select will be recorded and reported to your instructor, so randomly guessing could adversely affect your score. You should be both thorough and thoughtful in conducting your investigation. Hint: we recommend that you first thoroughly exhaust the use of broader initial investigation options, like interviewing someone, before proceeding to test specific hypotheses by doing more specific tests for particular enzyme activities, for example. After completing these initial investigations, ask yourself, what further investigations or lab tests would you like to conduct based on the information gathered so far? For starters, you might also consider what, metabolically, might make a person lose consciousness…
RECOMMENDED INITIAL INVESTIGATIONS
Evaluate overall physical appearance including the presence of insect bites or other injuries
Results: Subject is a young, adult female with a slim, athletic frame but otherwise appears normal.
Fecal analysis – Look for blood, intestinal parasites, high levels of fat in stool
Results: No blood or intestinal parasites were found. Levels of fat in the stool were normal considering the subject’s recent food intake.
Interview patient to determine dietary habits and look for neurological problems
Results: No abnormalities in cognitive function were found. Jessie reported being a strict vegan for many years; however, she claims to get a large amount of protein from plant sources. She also reports eating a high calorie diet and occasional, moderate alcohol consumption. She says that she is a non-smoker, does not use illegal drugs, and does not recall eating anything unusual recently; in fact, she had not eaten anything yet on the day of the fainting episode because she was in a rush. You ask whether she knows whether she might be diabetic or has had any trouble in the past controlling her blood sugar levels and she responds by saying “I really don’t know.”
Investigate past medical history
Results: Jessie explained that she was on the verge of gaining a swimming scholarship to college when she injured her head in a rock climbing accident. Her head injury led to epileptic episodes that were now controlled by regularly taking anticonvulsant drugs. Swimming was one of the activities she gave up because of the fear of seizures. She reports that, since the accident, she has had less endurance, which she had always ascribed to the fact that she was no longer working out regularly. She sighed and said longingly, “I don’t swim anymore… don’t really do much of anything in terms of hard exercise. I am just miserably out of shape, I guess.” You ask whether she has had a blood test to look at her blood lipid profile recently and she responds that she has not had a full physical since she was dismissed from the hospital five years ago.
SECONDARY INVESTIGATIONS
Determine Blood Serum Concentrations
Common electrolytes: Ca2+, K+, Na+, Cl-, PO43-
Results: All values are in normal ranges. (normal ranges: [Ca2+] = 8.5-10.5 gm/dL; [K+] = 3.5-5.0 meq/L; [Na+] = 135-145 meq/L; [Cl-] = 100-106 meq/L; total phosphorus = 2.6 – 4.5 mg/dL)
Common lipids: free fatty acids (FFAs), triacylglycerides (TAGs), total cholesterol, and ketone bodies (acetoacetate as a marker)
Results: [FFAs] = 500 mg/dL (normal range: 190-420 mg/dL); [TAGs] = 175mg/dL (normal range: 40-150 mg/dL); [Total cholesterol] = 140 mg/dL (normal range: 120-200 mg/dL); acetoacetate was undetectable
Glucose
Results: [Glc] = 60 mg/dL (normal range: 70-110 mg/dL)
H3O+ ions: blood pH
Results: pH = 7.41 (normal range: 7.35 – 7.45)
Lactate and pyruvate
Results: [lactate] = 1.0 meq/L (normal range: 0.5-2.2 meq/L); [pyruvate] = 0.05 meq/L (normal range: 0 – 0.11 meq/L)
NH4+ (total ammonia)
Results: [NH4+] = 45 mmol/L (normal range: 12-48 mmol/L)
O2 and CO2
Results: pO2 = 88 mmHg (normal range: 75-100 mmHg); pCO2 = 41 mmHg (normal range: 35-45 mmHg)
Total protein (mostly albumin)
Results: [total protein] = 4.9 g/dL (normal range: 6.0-8.0 g/dL)
Specific enzyme tests
Asp amino-transaminases (AST) and Ala amino-transferase (ALT)
Results: Both enzymes are within normal range (normal range: 7-55 U/L)
Aldolase
Results: [Aldolase] = 1.0 U/mL (normal range: 0-7 U/mL)
Carnitine acyltransferases I & II (CAT I & CAT II)
Results: The activity of both transporters was found to be well below normal. Expression levels of both proteins were actually slightly elevated, however.
Test cells for Electron Transport Chain enzyme activities
Results: ETC enzyme activities were normal
Creatine kinase (CK)
Results: [CK] = 100 U/L (normal range: 40-150 U/L)
Glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD)
Results: [G6PD] = 8 U/g Hb (normal range: 5-13 U/g Hb)
Lactate dehydrogenase (LDH)
Results: [LDH] = 150 U/L (normal range: 110-210 U/L)
Pyruvate dehydrogenase (PDH)
Results: PDH complex activity= 2.5 nmol/min*mg (normal range: 2-2.5 nmol/min*mg)
Measure blood levels of glycosylated Hb (HbA 1c as a marker)
Results: HbA1c = 3.2 % (normal range: 4 - 6.5%)
Conduct an oral glucose tolerance test to measure changes in insulin, glucagon, and blood glucose when oral glucose is administered.
Results: Jessie fasted for 12 hours prior to the test, and her glucose, glucagon, and insulin levels were measured just before the test began. She was then given 75 grams of glucose in water to drink, and her blood was drawn and tested every 60 minutes for 5 hours. Results were as follows: She was hypoglycemic when the test began but otherwise showed completely normal responses to the glucose challenge (to be explained in greater detail in the following assessment questions!). In the very last hour, her blood glucose slowly decreased to below normal levels (hypoglycemia).
Conduct a fasting metabolism study to monitor subject’s FFAs and ketone bodies in response to fasting
Results: A 40-hr fasting study was performed. Refer to the figure below to see how Jessie’s blood FFAs, and acetoacetate and γ-hydroxybutyrate levels changed during the fasting study. (Note that at the beginning of the study, she had just eaten!)
The physician who oversaw the study noted two things that were abnormal compared to a normal person who participates in the same fasting study:
1. Healthy individuals produce significant levels of ketone bodies by the end of the 36-hour fast whereas Jessie produced barely any.
2. The study was abruptly halted after only 36 hours because Jessie fainted again! Fasting for 36 hours is clearly not safe for Jessie! Depending on what other investigations you have already conducted, it may or may not be clear why Jessie would faint during this study but her glucose levels are something that would be important to investigate if you have not already…
Continue the case
There are multiple possible explanations for how and why β-oxidation might be blocked. Consider that there could be an inborn error in metabolism (a polymorphism in a gene coding for an enzyme in the pathway), a vitamin deficiency leading to the lack of enzyme action, or a problem with the transport of fatty acids into the mitochondria among other possibilities.
Investigate short-chain (12 carbons or less) fatty acid metabolism: Monitor ketone body formation in the blood
Results: Interestingly, when Jessie was fed a solution containing short-chain fatty acids and again fasted, plasma acetoacetate and γ-hydroxybutyrate concentrations increased.
Conduct an MRI to determine liver fat levels.
Results: Concentrations of liver fat were found to be 12%. (normal range = 3-5.5%)
I have reviewed my options and I still need help. I would like to hire an outside consultant to review this case to provide guidance about what I might be missing.
This person reviews your notes and gives you this helpful advice: In this case, it is important to consider the details that would cause abnormalities in Jesse’s physiological (metabolic) state at the time of the accident. You should completely examine her regular dietary habits, her past medical history, and her blood glucose and lipid levels. You should also make sure that you continue as in depth as possible in these lines of investigation.
You have uncovered almost all the information necessary to explain Jessie’s health issues, but something still does not add up: specifically, why is she having these problems now and not all of her life? For example, if she has an inborn error of one of the genes encoding for CAT I or CAT II, you would expect that she would have always suffered from bouts of hypoglycemia. You discuss all the results with the physician you are working with and she suggests that you never actually asked Jessie what medication she was taking for the seizures she was having! It may be nothing, but what an oversight! The following new investigation is now available:
Ask again about past medical history including a list of current medications
Results: She reported, “I take an anticonvulsant drug, valproic acid, to control the seizures. Why, what does that have to do with anything?”
Investigate the physiological side effects of valproic acid
You quickly look up the side effects of valproic acid on your smart phone; it can cause nausea and vomiting, anorexia, carnitine deficiency, and abnormal bleeding, in patients on certain diets. You ask Jessie, and she says that she has experienced none of these—as far as she knows…
The investigation into the potential side effects of valproic acid has opened up seven new investigation options! Review your previous results so far in this case and consider whether this new information provides any logical explanation for Jessie’s odd metabolic limitations. What would you like to investigate next? The new options opened are:
Ask Jessie to think hard about whether she has been vomiting recently
Result: Jessie restates that she has not had any bouts of nausea or vomiting recently. She is mildly annoyed by this question.
Ask Jessie to think hard about whether she might have a carnitine deficiency
Result: Jessie responds with a puzzled look and says: “Umm… I don’t think so…but what is carnitine anyway?”. The physician you are shadowing steps in and clarifies that Jessie would not know whether she has a carnitine deficiency or not.
Look for abnormal bleeding in the GI tract
Result: You request that Jessie submit to an endoscopy and a colonoscopy. However, the physician you are shadowing disagrees with you - this is not a necessary set of procedures since Jessie does not report any bleeding and does not have any other apparent symptoms that would justify doing these procedures. She also notes that bleeding in the GI tract, even if it is found, does not explain the symptoms that Jessie is exhibiting.
Measure blood levels of carnitine
Result: [Carnitine] = 5 µmol/L (normal range: 24-64 µmol/L)
Jessie has a severe carnitine deficiency! Carnitine is synthesized in humans from the amino acids methionine and lysine, but it is also acquired in the diet. As the name implies, carnitine is especially abundant in meat and dairy products. Because a typical omnivorous diet provides ~75% of a person’s carnitine, carnitine is sometimes considered a vitamin. However, since it can be synthesized de novo this means that it is not a true vitamin. Valproic acid depletes carnitine stores in the body by multiple mechanisms but rarely results in true carnitine deficiency in most people. Something to consider: Why is Jessie experiencing carnitine deficiency? Is there any other aspect about her that might make her particularly sensitive to this side-effect of valproic acid?
Measure blood levels of CoA
Result: Levels of Coenzyme A are normal
Measure blood levels of valproic acid
Result: Valproic acid and its metabolites are detected in the blood. Levels are normal and appropriate for the dose that Jessie is taking to control her seizures
Send Jessie to a counselor to discuss the possibility that she might be anorexic
Result: Jessie is deeply insulted by the insinuation; she has already stated that she eats a high calorie, but vegan, diet and takes your suggestion as an insinuation that she has been lying to you. She restates that she eats regularly and abundantly.
Congratulations on completing this Case Study! The following Case Summary gives a full explanation of Jessie's condition.
Case Summary
Jessie was suffering from a deficiency of carnitine, caused by a combination of her vegan diet and her long-term use of the anticonvulsant drug valproic acid, which depletes the body’s stores of carnitine. Carnitine is synthesized in the liver and kidney from amino acid precursors, especially lysine. Carnitine deficiencies can also occur in people undergoing regular renal hemodialysis (which increases excretion of carnitine) or in people taking drugs for AIDS or long-term bacterial infections, which can deliver toxic insults to liver or kidneys. Dietary sources of carnitine include meat and dairy products; Jessie, as a vegan, was taking in little carnitine from her diet.
Lack of carnitine caused Jessie’s muscles to lose the ability to use fatty acids as substrates for β-oxidation; without sufficient carnitine, the fatty acids cannot be converted from fatty acyl-CoA to fatty acyl-carnitine, which can enter the mitochondrial matrix, where the enzymes of β-oxidation are located. The result is a decrease in ATP made from oxidative metabolism. The unused fatty acids are stored (in the form of triglycerides) in liver and muscle tissue. Short-chain fatty acids of 12 carbons or less, do not require a carrier to enter the matrix, so such fatty acids can serve as β-oxidation substrates, and ketone bodies can be generated from the acetyl-CoA generated from this catabolic process. However, these fatty acids are relatively rare in the human diet and the majority of fatty acids stored in triglycerides are long-chain fatty acids. The inability to use long-chain fatty acids as fuel leads to higher use of glucose. Secretion of glucagon, as glucose is depleted, causes triacylglycerol stores to be mobilized, leading to an increase in fatty acids in the blood (carried by serum albumin.) With a carnitine deficiency, ketones are not made from the breakdown of fatty acids, so there is no increase in ketones seen during the fasting. In normal patients, ketones increase as glucose levels drop and fatty acids become the primary fuel for muscle. Finally, without the ATP generated from β-oxidation, there may be a lack of energy to generate glucose through the process of liver gluconeogenesis.
That fateful day, Jessie had also skipped breakfast and lunch, and so she was particularly hypoglycemic, and glycogen-depleted, before she started her heroic swim. The strenuous swim triggered glucose uptake by her muscles. The glucose used by her muscles could not be supplemented or replaced by stored glycogen, fatty acid metabolism, or ketone body formation, and therefore her blood glucose dropped to levels that cause loss of consciousness.
Finally, there are also genetic conditions that can lead to carnitine deficiencies. Examples are the lack of a functional enzyme in the carnitine biosynthesis pathway, defective transport proteins to allow entry of carnitine into the heart and muscle cells, and defective reabsorption of carnitine at the renal tubule. However, until her head injury and pharmacological intervention via valproic acid to prevent seizures, Jessie showed no symptoms, and was in fact a high-end athlete, making genetic conditions less likely as the basis for her carnitine deficiency.