11.2.3 Cross-Category Friendships
Printed Page 363
Cross-Category Friendships
Given that friendships center on shared interests and identity support, it’s no surprise that people tend to befriend those who are similar demographically (with regard to age, gender, economic status, etc.). As just one example, studies of straight, gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgendered persons find that, regardless of sexual orientation or gender identity, people are more likely to have close friendships with others of the same ethnicity (Galupo, 2009). But people also regularly defy this norm, forging friendships that cross demographic lines, known as cross-category friendships (Galupo, 2009). Such friendships are a powerful way to break down ingrouper and outgrouper perceptions and purge people of negative stereotypes. The four most common cross-category friendships are cross-sex, cross-orientation, intercultural, and interethnic.
Cross-Sex Friendships One of the most radical shifts in interpersonal relationship patterns over the past few decades has been the increase in platonic (nonsexual) friendships between men and women in the United States and Canada. In the nineteenth century, friendships were almost exclusively same-sex, and throughout most of the twentieth century, cross-sex friendships remained a rarity (Halatsis & Christakis, 2009). For example, a study of friendship conducted in 1974 found that, on average, men and women had few or no close cross-sex friends (Booth & Hess, 1974). However, by the mid-1980s, 40 percent of men and 30 percent of women reported having close cross-sex friendships (Rubin, 1985). By the late 1990s, 47 percent of tenth- and twelfth-graders reported having a close cross-sex friend (Kuttler, LaGreca, & Prinstein, 1999).
Most cross-sex friendships are not motivated by sexual attraction (Messman, Canary, & Hause, 1994). Instead, men and women agree that through cross-sex friendships, they gain a greater understanding of how members of the other sex think, feel, and behave (Halatsis & Christakis, 2009). For men, forming friendships with women provides the possibility of greater intimacy and emotional depth than is typically available in male-male friendships (Monsour, 1997).
Despite changing attitudes toward cross-sex friendships, men and women face several challenges in building such relationships. For one thing, they’ve learned from early childhood to segregate themselves by sex. In most schools, young boys and girls are placed in separate gym classes, asked to line up separately for class, and instructed to engage in competitions pitting “the boys against the girls” (Thorne, 1986). It’s no surprise, then, that young children overwhelmingly prefer friends of the same sex (Reeder, 2003). As a consequence of this early-life segregation, most children enter their teens with only limited experience in building cross-sex friendships. Neither adolescence nor adulthood provides many opportunities for gaining this experience. Leisure-oriented activities such as competitive sports, community programs, and social organizations—including the Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts—typically are sex segregated (Swain, 1992).
Another challenge is that our society promotes only same-sex friendship and cross-sex coupling as the two most acceptable relationship options between men and women. So no matter how rigorously a pair of cross-sex friends insist that they’re “just friends,” their surrounding friends and family members will likely meet these claims with skepticism or even disapproval (Monsour, 1997). Family members, if they approve of the friendship, often pester such couples to become romantically involved: “You and Jen have so much in common! Why not take things to the next level?” If families disapprove, they encourage termination of the relationship: “I don’t want people thinking my daughter is hanging out casually with some guy. Why don’t you hang out with other girls instead?” Romantic partners of people involved in cross-sex friendships often vehemently disapprove of such involvements (Hansen, 1985). Owing to constant disapproval from others and the pressure to justify the relationship, cross-sex friendships are far less stable than same-sex friendships (Berscheid & Regan, 2005).
Cross-Orientation Friendships As illustrated by the friendship between Carrie and Stanford in Sex and the City, a second type of cross-category friendship is cross-orientation: friendships between lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgendered, or queer (LGBTQ ) people and straight men or women. As within all friendships, cross-orientation friends are bonded by shared interests and activities, and provide each other with support and affection. But these friendships also provide unique rewards for the parties involved (Galupo, 2007). For straight men and women, forming a cross-orientation friendship can help correct negative stereotypes about persons of other sexual orientations and the LGBTQ community as a whole. For LGBTQ persons, having a straight friend can provide much-needed emotional and social support from outside of the LGBTQ community, helping to further insulate them from societal homophobia (Galupo, 2007).
Although cross-orientation friendships are commonplace on television and in the movies (e.g., Glee, Degrassi, Sex and the City), they are less frequent in real life. Although LGBTQ persons often have as many cross-orientation friends as same-orientation, straight men and women over-whelmingly form friendships with other straight men and women (Galupo, 2009). The principal reason is homophobia, both personal and societal. Straight persons may feel reluctant to pursue such friendships because they fear being associated with members of a marginalized group (Galupo, 2007). By far the group that has the fewest cross-orientation friendships is straight men. In fact, the average number of cross-orientation friendships for straight men is zero: most straight men do not have a single lesbian, gay, bisexual, or transgendered friend (Galupo, 2009). This tendency may perpetuate homophobic sentiments, because these men are never exposed to LGBTQ persons who might amend their negative attitudes. The Focus on Culture box “Cross-Orientation Male Friendships” on page 366 explores the challenges of such relationships in depth.
Intercultural Friendships A third type of cross-category friendship is intercultural: friendships between people from different cultures or countries. Similar to cross-sex and cross-orientation affiliations, intercultural friendships are both challenging and rewarding (Sias et al., 2008). The challenges include overcoming differences in language and cultural beliefs and negative stereotypes. Differences in language alone present a substantial hurdle. Incorrect interpretations of messages can lead to misunderstanding, uncertainty, frustration, and conflict (Sias et al., 2008). The potential rewards of intercultural friendships, however, are great, and include gaining new cultural knowledge, broadening one’s worldview, and breaking stereotypes (Sias et al., 2008).
As noted throughout this chapter, the most important factor that catapults friendships forward is similarity in interests and activities. However, the defining characteristic of intercultural interactions is difference, and this makes formation of intercultural friendships more challenging (Sias et al., 2008). How can you overcome this? By finding, and then bolstering, some significant type of ingroup similarity. For example, a good friend—who is Japanese—and I—of Irish descent—founded our friendship upon a shared love of techno and house music. But the strongest predictor of whether someone will have an intercultural friendship is prior intercultural friendships. People who have had close friends from different cultures in the past are substantially more likely to forge such friendships in the future (Sias et al., 2008). This is because they learn the enormous benefits that such relationships provide, and lack fear and uncertainty about “outgroupers.”
Interethnic Friendships The final type of cross-category friendship is illustrated by Carrie and Louise in the first Sex and the City movie. This is an interethnic friendship: a bond between people who share the same cultural background (for example, “American”), but who are of different ethnic groups (“African American,” “Asian American,” “Euro-American,” and so forth). Similar to cross-orientation and intercultural friendships, interethnic friendships boost cultural awareness and commitment to diversity (Shelton, Richeson, & Bergsieker, 2009). In addition, interethnic friends apply these outcomes broadly. People who develop a close interethnic friendship become less prejudiced toward ethnicities of all types as a result (Shelton et al., 2009).
The most difficult barriers people face in forming interethnic friendships are attributional and perceptual errors. Too often we let our own biases and stereotypes stop us from having open, honest, and comfortable interactions with people from other ethnic groups. We become overly concerned with the “correct” way to act and end up behaving nervously. Such nervousness may lead to awkward, uncomfortable encounters and may cause us to avoid interethnic encounters in the future, dooming ourselves to friendship networks that lack diversity (Shelton et al., 2010).
How can you overcome these challenges and improve your ability to form interethnic friendships? Review Chapter 3’s discussion of attributional errors and perception-checking. Look for points of commonality during interethnic encounters that might lead to the formation of a friendship—such as a shared interest in music, fashion, sports, movies, or video games. Keep in mind that sometimes encounters are awkward, people don’t get along, and friendships won’t arise—and it has nothing to do with ethnic differences.