Table : TABLE 4.1 • Research Methods in Psychopathology
Research methodImportant feature(s)Drawback(s)
Experimental designUse of independent and dependent variables and random assignment allows researchers to infer cause and effectMost etiological factors that contribute to psychopathology cannot be studied with experiments (but experiments are often used to study the effects of treatment).
Quasi-experimentsUsed when it is possible to identify independent and dependent variables, but random assignment of participants to groups is not possible; researchers can still infer cause and effectBecause random assignment isn’t possible, possible confounds are difficult to eliminate.
Correlational researchUsed when it is not possible to manipulate independent variables such as etiological factors; researchers can examine relationships between variablesResults indicate only related factors, not causal factors.
Case studiesOften descriptive, but can use various research methods applied to a single participantCaution must be exercised in generalizing from the sole participant to others; there are many possible confounding factors.
Single-participant experimentsAn experiment with one participant (and so random assignment isn’t possible); cause and effect can be inferredCaution must be exercised in generalizing from the sole participant to others; there are many possible confounding factors.
Meta-analysisA statistical analysis that combines the results of a number of studies that examine the same general question to determine the overall effectIt is difficult to estimate the number of studies that failed to find an effect and thus were not published and not included in the analysis; the studies analyzed are often not of equal quality but their results are nevertheless weighted equally in the analysis.