The oldest son of former president George H. W. Bush, George W. Bush was the governor of Texas when he won the Republican presidential nomination. Inexperienced in national and international affairs, Bush chose for his running mate a seasoned official, Richard B. Cheney, who had served in three previous Republican administrations. Many observers predicted that the thriving economy would benefit the Democratic contender, Vice President Al Gore, and he did surpass Bush by more than half a million votes. But Florida’s 25 electoral college votes would decide the presidency. Bush’s tiny margin in Florida prompted an automatic recount of the votes, which eventually gave him an edge of 537 votes in that state.

The Democrats asked for hand-counting of Florida ballots in several heavily Democratic counties where machine errors and confusing ballots may have left thousands of Gore votes unrecorded. The Republicans, in turn, went to court to try to stop the hand-counts. The outcome of the 2000 election hung in the balance for weeks as cases went up to the Supreme Court. Finally, the sharply divided justices ruled five to four against allowing the state to conduct further recounts. While critics charged partisanship, noting that the conservative justices had abandoned their principle of favoring state over federal authority, Gore conceded to Bush. For the first time since 1888, a president who failed to win the popular vote took office (Map 31.3).