Checklist: Questions for Peer Reviewers
CHECKLIST
Questions for Peer Reviewers
What is the main point?
Can I do anything to make my opening more interesting?
Do I have enough support for my main point? Where could I use more?
Where could I use more details?
Are there places where you have to stop and reread something to understand it? If so, where?
Do I give my reader clues as to where a new point starts? Does one point “flow” smoothly to the next?
What about my conclusion? Does it just fade out? How could I make my point more forcefully?
Where else could the paper be better? What would you do if it were your paper?
If you were going to be graded on this paper, would you turn it in as is? If not, why not?
What other comments or suggestions do you have?