A Fair and Impartial Presentation: Choice of Verbs

Printed Page 188
 Analyze 
Use the basic features.

Writers of common ground essays try to use descriptive but unbiased language when they introduce quotations. For example, Jeremy Bernard uses verbs like concludes, argues, cites, expresses, and assumes. Melissa Mae, whose essay appears later in this chapter, uses writes, thinks, asserts, argues, and labels. With these descriptive verbs, Bernard and Mae do not reveal their attitude toward the authors or what they wrote. They express no judgments but act as impartial reporters.

ANALYZE & WRITE

Printed Page 189

Write a few paragraphs analyzing and assessing Samson’s fairness and impartiality:

  1. Skim Samson’s essay, noting the verbs she uses to introduce quotations from Chua and Rosin.
  2. Consider whether the verbs Samson uses present Chua’s and Rosin’s ideas fairly and impartially.
  3. Where, if anywhere, do you think Samson implies her own opinion or evaluates the authors she’s analyzing? How can you tell?

    Question