Appendix

Printed Page 218

Following are three clusters of essays taking positions on two different issues: parenting, helmet use among athletes, and compensating organ donors. These clusters include two argument essays and one informative essay that may be used for background. You may read the first cluster to compare the arguments by Chua and Rosin with Betsy Samson’s representation of them in her essay “Does Mother Know Best?” (pp. 183–87). You may select from the essays in this appendix, along with essays on several other debate topics that are available in the e-Pages or that you can link to from the book’s companion site.

Issue 1: Parenting Style

Amy Chua, Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior   219

Hanna Rosin, Mother Inferior?   222

Don Aucoin, For Some, Helicopter Parenting Delivers Benefits   225

Issue 2: Sports Helmet Use

Nate Jackson, The NFL’s Head Cases   227

David Weisman, Disposable Heroes   229

Lane Wallace, Do Sports Helmets Help or Hurt?   231

Issue 3: Compensating Organ Donors

Sally Satel, Yuan a Kidney?   234

National Kidney Foundation, Financial Incentives for Organ Donation   236

Scott Carney, Inside the Business of Selling Human Body Parts   238