A Critical Reading Guide

Printed Page 286

A Focused, Well-Presented Issue

How well does the writer present the issue?

  • Summarize: Tell the writer what you understand the issue to be. If you were already familiar with it and understand it differently, briefly explain.
  • Praise: Give an example from the essay where the issue and its significance come across effectively.
  • Critique: Tell the writer where more information about the issue is needed, where more might be done to establish its seriousness, or how the issue could be framed or reframed in a way that would better prepare readers for the argument.
Table 6.16: A CRITICAL READING GUIDE
Printed Page 287
A Well-Supported Position

How well does the writer argue in support of the position?

  • Summarize: Underline the thesis statement and the main reasons.
  • Praise: Give an example in the essay where the argument is especially effective; for example, indicate which reason is especially convincing or which supporting evidence is particularly compelling.
  • Critique: Tell the writer where the argument could be strengthened; for example, indicate how the thesis statement could be made clearer or more appropriately qualified, how the argument could be developed, or where additional support is needed.
An Effective Response to Opposing Views

How effectively has the writer responded to others’ reasons and likely objections?

  • Summarize: Identify where the writer responds to a reason others use to support their argument or an objection they have to the writer’s argument.
  • Praise: Give an example in the essay where a concession seems particularly well done or a refutation is convincing.
  • Critique: Tell the writer how a concession or refutation could be made more effective, a reason or objection the writer should respond to, or where common ground could be found.
A Clear, Logical Organization

How clearly and logically has the writer organized the argument?

  • Summarize: Find the sentence(s) in which the writer states the thesis and forecasts supporting reasons, as well as transitions or repeated key words and phrases.
  • Praise: Give an example of how or where the essay succeeds in being especially easy to read, perhaps in its overall organization, clear presentation of the thesis, clear transitions, or effective opening or closing.
  • Critique: Tell the writer where the readability could be improved. Can you, for example, suggest better forecasting or clearer transitions? If the overall organization of the essay needs work, make suggestions for rearranging parts or strengthening connections.
Printed Page 287

Before concluding your peer review, be sure to address any of the writer’s concerns that have not been discussed already.

Making Comments Electronically Most word processing software offers features that allow you to insert comments directly into the text of someone else’s document. Many readers prefer to make their comments this way because it tends to be faster than writing on hard copy and space is virtually unlimited; it also eliminates the process of deciphering handwritten comments. Where such features are not available, simply typing comments directly into a document in a contrasting color can provide the same advantages.