Critical Thinking Questions

Printed Page 583

1.

Question

What role does audience analysis play in establishing your credibility? Is the speaker’s responsibility to back up claims with solid evidence the same for a sympathetic audience as it is for a hostile or neutral audience?

2.

Question

As an audience member, how can you identify logical fallacies during a speech? How can you identify weak or misleading evidence? How do you react when a speaker’s claims are based on unsound evidence or reasoning?

3.

Question

How should a speaker who favors a particular tradition develop a logical argument for that tradition that avoids committing an appeal to tradition fallacy? For example, how might a speaker build a case for the general education requirement described in the text on page 568? In a broader sense, how can you build a strong and ethical argument for maintaining a tradition that you support?

4.

Question

What types of presentation aids can you use to build your credibility?

5.

Question

Reflect on your position on a controversial issue in society. What evidence could persuade you to adopt a more neutral position or change your mind? Who or what would be a credible source to possibly induce you to rethink your position? How can the answers to these questions help you in your own efforts as a persuasive speaker?