The election of 1856 revealed that the Republicans had become the Democrats’ main challenger, and slavery in the territories, not nativism, was the election’s principal issue. When the Know-Nothings insisted on a platform that endorsed the Kansas-Nebraska Act, most of the Northerners walked out, and the party came apart. The few Know-Nothings who remained nominated ex-president Millard Fillmore.

The Republican platform focused mostly on “making every territory free.” When Republicans labeled slavery a “relic of barbarism,” they signaled that they had written off the South. For president, they nominated the soldier and California adventurer John C. Frémont. Frémont lacked political credentials, but his wife, Jessie Frémont, the daughter of Senator Thomas Hart Benton of Missouri, knew the political map well. Though careful to maintain a proper public image, the vivacious young mother and antislavery zealot helped attract voters and draw women into politics.

The Democrats, successful in 1852 in bridging sectional differences by nominating a northern man with southern principles, chose another “doughface,” James Buchanan of Pennsylvania. They portrayed the Republicans as extremists (“Black Republican Abolitionists”) whose support for the Wilmot Proviso risked pushing the South out of the Union.

The Democratic strategy carried the day for Buchanan, who won 174 electoral votes against Frémont’s 114 and Fillmore’s 8 (see Map 14.4). But the big news was that the Republicans, despite being a brand-new party, carried all but five of the states north of the Mason-Dixon line. Sectionalism had fashioned a new party system, one that spelled danger for the Democrats and the Republic. Indeed, war had already broken out between proslavery and antislavery forces in distant Kansas Territory.

QUICK REVIEW