Why did the relationship between urban and rural America deteriorate in the 1920s?

Printed Page 692

image
Figure false: WKKK Badge
Figure false: Half a million women were members of the Women of the Ku Klux Klan (WKKK). Klanswomen fit perfectly within the KKK because the organization proclaimed itself the defender of the traditional virtues of pure womanhood and decent homes. This badge from Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, advertises the local WKKK’s support for a “home for orphan and dependent children.” Collection of Janice L. and David J. Frent.

LARGE AREAS OF THE COUNTRY did not share in the wealth of the 1920s. By the end of the decade, 40 percent of the nation’s farmers were landless, and 90 percent of rural homes lacked indoor plumbing, gas, or electricity. Rural America’s traditional distrust of urban America turned to despair in the 1920s when the census reported that the majority of the population had shifted to the city (Map 23.2). Urban domination over the nation’s political and cultural life and sharply rising economic disparity drove rural Americans in often ugly, reactionary directions.

Cities seemed to stand for everything rural areas stood against. Rural America imagined itself as solidly Anglo-Saxon (despite the presence of millions of African Americans in the South and Mexican Americans, Native Americans, and Asian Americans in the West), and the cities seemed to be filled with undesirable immigrants. Rural America was the home of old-time Protestant religion, and the cities teemed with Catholics, Jews, liberal Protestants, and atheists. Rural America championed old-fashioned moral standards — abstinence and self-denial — while the cities spawned every imaginable vice. In the 1920s, frustrated rural people sought to recapture their country by helping to push through prohibition, dam the flow of immigrants, revive the Ku Klux Klan, defend the Bible as literal truth, and defeat an urban Roman Catholic for president.

CHRONOLOGY

1921

  • – Congress restricts immigration.

1924

  • – Johnson-Reed Act.
  • – Indian Citizenship Act.

1925

  • – Scopes trial.

1927

  • – Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti are executed.

1928

  • – Herbert Hoover is elected president.

image
Figure false: MAP 23.2 The Shift from Rural to Urban Population, 1920–1930
Figure false: The movement of whites and Hispanics toward urban and agricultural opportunity made Florida, the West, and the Southwest the regions of fastest population growth. By contrast, large numbers of blacks left the rural South to find a better life in the North. Almost all migrating blacks went from the countryside to cities in distant parts of the nation, while white and Hispanic migrants tended to move shorter distances toward familiar places.
Figure false: MAP ACTIVITY
Figure false: READING THE MAP: Which states had the strongest growth? To which cities did southern blacks predominantly migrate?
Figure false: CONNECTIONS: What conditions in the countryside made the migration to urban areas appealing to many rural Americans? In what social and cultural ways did rural America view itself as different from urban America?