Patterns of Editing in Bonnie and Clyde (1967) |
|
|
01:00:08 |
|
Narrator: Although it is set in the 1930s, nothing
felt more contemporary than Arthur Penn’s Bonnie
and Clyde when it burst on the screen in 1967. Dede Allen’s editing turns this tragic comedy
about the notorious outlaws’ crime spree into a visceral experience capturing
the restless energy of a country divided by generation, race, and political
ideology. |
01:00:33 |
|
Narrator: The film opens with a series of still
snapshots edited together as a documentary photo montage, implying that these
lifeless images cannot tell the whole story until they are animated and edited
together in a meaningful way. |
01:00:52 |
|
Narrator: Bonnie
and Clyde frequently uses continuity editing to give clear spatial and
temporal cues. For example, in the scene
showing the couple’s first small town bank robbery, we are first shown a
long shot of their car parked outside the bank followed by a shot from inside
the bank showing the car parked outside; this shows us the geography of the
scene as well as what’s happening during these linked shots. But at other times the film’s editing
emphasizes psychological or emotional effects over realism. For |
01:01:23 |
|
example, Bonnie is
first introduced with an extreme close-up of her lips. The camera then pulls back as she turns right
to look in a mirror. This is followed by
a cut on action as she stands and looks back over her shoulder to the left in a
medium shot and then by another cut on action as she drops to her bed, her face
visible in a close-up through the bed frame which she petulantly punches. She pulls herself up and looks out between
the bars of the bedframe. With another |
01:01:50 |
|
cut she rises from
the bed with her back turned toward us and reaches to the right for her
dress. This central character is described
by a series of jerky shots: her boredom and frustration are also built into the
editing through cutting on action. The
lack of an establishing shot combines with the multiple framings to emphasize
the claustrophobic mise-en-scéne, taking us right into the character’s
psychologically-rendered space. The
meeting with Clyde comes next and |
01:02:21 |
|
the editing indicates
the break he represented from the trap Bonnie feels herself to be in. She goes to her window and then a point-of-view
construction spots a strange man near her mother’s car. |
01:02:42 |
|
Narrator: She comes downstairs to investigate and her
conversation with Clyde is handled in a series of shot/reverse shots, starting
with long shots as she comes outside, and proceeding to closer pairs of
shots. The two-shot of the characters
together is delayed. The way this
introduction is handled emphasizes the inevitability of their pairing. |
01:03:09 |
|
Narrator: Because Bonnie
and Clyde is a gangster film in which cars and guns figure prominently,
complex spatial connections are repeatedly set up between the pursuers and the
pursued. |
01:03:25 |
|
Narrator: Editing on movement pervades the film. Its stop-and-go rhythm is probably one of the
most striking features. As the Barrow
gang flees from the police in one car chase, shots alternate between the police
and the gang. Intercut, as a parallel
action, are interviews with witnesses to the robbery who brag about having been
part of a Bonnie and Clyde caper. The
influence French New Wave storytelling and editing is apparent in this ironic
counterpoint. |
01:04:00 |
|
Narrator: The film was probably most well known for
its climactic sequence in which Bonnie and Clyde are gunned down. It is, in fact, two discrete scenes—distinguished
by changes in action. But it is the
changes in pacing in these two scenes that leave viewers feeling as if they too
have been ambushed. In the first scene,
Bonnie and Clyde pull up beside the broken down truck of the man who has been
sheltering them. His anxiety about
having betrayed them to the |
01:04:28 |
|
cops is signaled by a
quick glance at the bushes followed by a point-of-view shot in which a flock of
birds suddenly rises. Bonnie and Clyde
are each shown following his gaze in eyeline matches. The collaborator takes cover and a remarkable
series of shots ensues alternating rhythmically between close-ups of the
lovers’ faces as they look at each other in alarm, realizing they are
surrounded. Then the shooting
begins. Next, accompanied by the
staccato of machine gun bullets, Bonnie’s and Clyde’s |
01:05:03 |
|
deaths are filmed in
slow motion; their bodies reacting with almost balletic grace to the impact of
the gunshots and to the rhythm of the film’s shots, which are almost as
numerous. In nearly thirty cuts and
approximately forty seconds, the film alternates between close-ups of the two
victims’ spasms and bodies and medium to long shots that re-establish the scene
of their deaths. The sense that their
deaths are |
01:05:32 |
|
happening in slow
motion is created by overlapping the action. For example, Clyde’s fall to the ground is split into three shots. The hail of bullets finally stops and the
film’s final minute is comprised of a series of seven shots of the police and
other onlookers gathering around without a single reverse shot of what they are
seeing. |
01:06:03 |
|
Narrator: For linking sex with violence, glamorizing
its protagonists through beauty and fashion, and addressing itself to the anti-authoritarian
feelings of young audiences, Bonnie and
Clyde is among the most important US films of the 1960s. It heralded the beginning of a new, youth-oriented
film market—one that revisited film genres of the past with a modern
sensibility. There’s no doubt that the
climactic linkage of gunshots with camera shots profoundly |
01:06:32 |
|
influenced the
editing of the blockbuster action movies that would follow. |