THINKING CRITICALLY ABOUT ITALICS
Reading with an eye for italics
Read the following passage about a graduate English seminar carefully, particularly noting the effects created by the italics. How would it differ without any italic emphasis? What other words or phrases might the author have italicized?
There were four big tables arranged in a square, with everyone’s feet sticking out into the open middle of the square. You could tell who was nervous, and how much, by watching the pairs of feet twist around each other. The Great Man presided awesomely from the high bar of the square. His head was a majestic granite-gray, like a centurion in command; he looked famous. His clean shoes twitched only slightly, and only when he was angry.
It turned out he was angry at me a lot of the time. He was angry because he thought me a disrupter, a rioter, a provocateur, and a fool; also crazy. And this was twenty years ago, before these things were de rigueur in the universities. Everything was very quiet in those days: there were only the Cold War and Korea and Joe McCarthy and the Old Old Nixon, and the only revolutionaries around were in Henry James’s The Princess Casamassima.
—CYNTHIA OZICK, “We Are the Crazy Lady”
Question
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
Read the following passage about a graduate English seminar carefully, particularly noting the effects created by the italics. How would it differ without any italic emphasis? What other words or phrases might the author have italicized? There were four big tables arranged in a square, with everyone’s feet sticking out into the open middle of the square. You could tell who was nervous, and how much, by watching the pairs of feet twist around each other. The Great Man presided awesomely from the high bar of the square. His head was a majestic granite-gray, like a centurion in command; he looked famous. His clean shoes twitched only slightly, and only when he was angry. It turned out he was angry at me a lot of the time. He was angry because he thought me a disrupter, a rioter, a provocateur, and a fool; also crazy. And this was twenty years ago, before these things were de rigueur in the universities. Everything was very quiet in those days: there were only the Cold War and Korea and Joe McCarthy and the Old Old Nixon, and the only revolutionaries around were in Henry James’s The Princess Casamassima. —CYNTHIA OZICK, “We Are the Crazy Lady”
Thinking about your own use of italics
Write a paragraph or two describing the most eccentric person you know, italicizing some words for special emphasis. Read your passage aloud to hear the effect of the italics. Now explain each use of italics. If you find yourself unable to give a reason, ask yourself whether the word should be italicized at all.
Then revise the passage to eliminate all but one use of italics. Try revising sentences and choosing more precise words to convey emphasis. Decide which version is more effective. Can you reach any conclusions about using italics for emphasis?
Question
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
Write a paragraph or two describing the most eccentric person you know, italicizing some words for special emphasis. Read your passage aloud to hear the effect of the italics. Now explain each use of italics. If you find yourself unable to give a reason, ask yourself whether the word should be italicized at all. Then revise the passage to eliminate all but one use of italics. Try revising sentences and choosing more precise words to convey emphasis. Decide which version is more effective. Can you reach any conclusions about using italics for emphasis?