Argument: Bob Herbert, “Tweet Less, Kiss More”

Tweet Less, Kiss More

Bob Herbert

Bob Herbert is a New York City–based journalist and television correspondent. Born in Brooklyn, he studied journalism at SUNY Empire State College and has taught journalism at Brooklyn College and the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism. He began his career in 1970 as a reporter for the Star-Ledger in Newark, New Jersey, and has since worked for the Daily News, The Today Show, NBC Nightly News, and the New York Times. He is the author of the 2005 book Promises Betrayed: Waking Up from the American Dream and currently lives in Manhattan. In the article “Tweet Less, Kiss More,” originally featured in his weekly column for the New York Times, Herbert argues against our obsession with multitasking and technology. As you read, notice his use of personal anecdotes to support his claims.

1

I was driving from Washington to New York one afternoon on Interstate 95 when a car came zooming up behind me, really flying. I could see in the rearview mirror that the driver was talking on her cellphone.

2

I was about to move to the center lane to get out of her way when she suddenly swerved into that lane herself to pass me on the right—still chatting away. She continued moving dangerously from one lane to another as she sped up the highway.

3

A few days later, I was talking to a guy who commutes every day between New York and New Jersey. He props up his laptop on the front seat so he can watch DVDs while he’s driving.

4

“I only do it in traffic,” he said. “It’s no big deal.”

5

Beyond the obvious safety issues, why does anyone want, or need, to be talking constantly on the phone or watching movies (or texting) while driving? I hate to sound so 20th century, but what’s wrong with just listening to the radio? The blessed wonders of technology are overwhelming us. We don’t control them; they control us.

6

We’ve got cellphones and BlackBerrys and Kindles and iPads, and we’re e-mailing and text-messaging and chatting and tweeting—I used to call it Twittering until I was corrected by high school kids who patiently explained to me, as if I were the village idiot, that the correct term is tweeting. Twittering, tweeting—whatever it is, it sounds like a nervous disorder.

7

This is all part of what I think is one of the weirder aspects of our culture: a heightened freneticism that seems to demand that we be doing, at a minimum, two or three things every single moment of every hour that we’re awake. Why is multitasking considered an admirable talent? We could just as easily think of it as a neurotic inability to concentrate for more than three seconds.

WORD POWER

aspects particular parts or features

freneticism a wild and frantic state

8

Why do we have to check our e-mail so many times a day, or keep our ears constantly attached, as if with Krazy Glue, to our cellphones? When you watch the news on cable television, there are often additional stories being scrolled across the bottom of the screen, stock market results blinking on the right of the screen, and promos for upcoming features on the left. These extras often block significant parts of the main item we’re supposed to be watching.

9

A friend of mine told me about an engagement party that she had attended. She said it was lovely: a delicious lunch and plenty of Champagne toasts. But all the guests had their cellphones on the luncheon tables and had text-messaged their way through the entire event.

10

Enough already with this hyperactive behavior, this techno-tyranny and nonstop freneticism. We need to slow down and take a deep breath.

WORD POWER

hyperactive displaying excessively active behavior

11

I’m not opposed to the remarkable technological advances of the past several years. I don’t want to go back to typewriters and carbon paper and yellowing clips from the newspaper morgue. I just think that we should treat technology like any other tool. We should control it, bending it to our human purposes.

WORD POWER

morgue a place where dead bodies are kept

12

Let’s put down at least some of these gadgets and spend a little time just being ourselves. One of the essential problems of our society is that we have a tendency, amid all the craziness that surrounds us, to lose sight of what is truly human in ourselves, and that includes our own individual needs—those very special, mostly nonmaterial things that would fulfill us, give meaning to our lives, enlarge us, and enable us to more easily embrace those around us.

13

There’s a character in the August Wilson play Joe Turner’s Come and Gone who says everyone has a song inside of him or her, and that you lose sight of that song at your peril. If you get out of touch with your song, forget how to sing it, you’re bound to end up frustrated and dissatisfied.

14

As this character says, recalling a time when he was out of touch with his own song, “Something wasn’t making my heart smooth and easy.”

15

I don’t think we can stay in touch with our song by constantly Twittering or tweeting, or thumbing out messages on our BlackBerrys, or piling up virtual friends on Facebook.

16

We need to reduce the speed limits of our lives. We need to savor the trip. Leave the cellphone at home every once in awhile. Try kissing more and tweeting less. And stop talking so much.

17

Listen.

18

Other people have something to say, too. And when they don’t, that glorious silence that you hear will have more to say to you than you ever imagined. That is when you will begin to hear your song. That’s when your best thoughts take hold, and you become really you.

Reacting to Language

Most of this essay is written in the past tense, but in paragraphs 3 and 4, Herbert shifts to the present tense. Why does he make this shift?

Question

ALMF/kS1zzW73MouRsoXk1h0lKY=
Argument: Bob Herbert, “Tweet Less, Kiss More” - Reacting to Language: Most of this essay is written in the past tense, but in paragraphs 3 and 4, Herbert shifts to the present tense. Why does he make this shift?

Reacting to Ideas

  1. In paragraph 5, Herbert says, “The blessed wonders of technology are overwhelming us.” What does he mean? Why does he use the word blessed?

    Question

    ALMF/kS1zzW73MouRsoXk1h0lKY=
    Argument: Bob Herbert, “Tweet Less, Kiss More” - Reacting to Ideas: In paragraph 5, Herbert says, “The blessed wonders of technology are overwhelming us.” What does he mean? Why does he use the word blessed?
  2. In paragraph 6, Herbert indicates that he is out of touch with electronic media. Why do you think he includes this paragraph? Does it undercut his credibility? Explain.

    Question

    ALMF/kS1zzW73MouRsoXk1h0lKY=
    Argument: Bob Herbert, “Tweet Less, Kiss More” - Reacting to Ideas: In paragraph 6, Herbert indicates that he is out of touch with electronic media. Why do you think he includes this paragraph? Does it undercut his credibility? Explain.
  3. Referring to a character in a play by August Wilson, Herbert says that “everyone has a song inside of him or her, and that you lose sight of that song at your peril” (paragraph 13). According to Herbert, what does this observation have to do with our relationship with electronic media?

    Question

    ALMF/kS1zzW73MouRsoXk1h0lKY=
    Argument: Bob Herbert, “Tweet Less, Kiss More” - Reacting to Ideas: Referring to a character in a play by August Wilson, Herbert says that “everyone has a song inside of him or her, and that you lose sight of that song at your peril” (paragraph 13). According to Herbert, what does this observation have to do with our relationship with electronic media?

Reacting to the Pattern

  1. Herbert begins his essay with two anecdotes. How do these stories prepare readers for his thesis in paragraph 5?

    Question

    ALMF/kS1zzW73MouRsoXk1h0lKY=
    Argument: Bob Herbert, “Tweet Less, Kiss More” - Reacting to the Pattern: Herbert begins his essay with two anecdotes. How do these stories prepare readers for his thesis in paragraph 5?
  2. What evidence does Herbert offer to support his thesis? Is this evidence presented inductively or deductively? How effective is this support?

    Question

    ALMF/kS1zzW73MouRsoXk1h0lKY=
    Argument: Bob Herbert, “Tweet Less, Kiss More” - Reacting to the Pattern: What evidence does Herbert offer to support his thesis? Is this evidence presented inductively or deductively? How effective is this support?
  3. In paragraph 11, Herbert discusses an argument against his thesis. How effectively does he refute this argument? What other arguments could he have addressed?

    Question

    ALMF/kS1zzW73MouRsoXk1h0lKY=
    Argument: Bob Herbert, “Tweet Less, Kiss More” - Reacting to the Pattern: In paragraph 11, Herbert discusses an argument against his thesis. How effectively does he refute this argument? What other arguments could he have addressed?

Writing Practice

  1. Write an essay in which you argue against Herbert’s opinion that people should lessen their dependence on technology. Make sure that you state your thesis, and refute one or two opposing arguments.

    Question

    ALMF/kS1zzW73MouRsoXk1h0lKY=
    Argument: Bob Herbert, “Tweet Less, Kiss More” - Writing Practice: Write an essay in which you argue against Herbert’s opinion that people should lessen their dependence on technology. Make sure that you state your thesis, and refute one or two opposing arguments.
  2. Write an editorial for your school’s newspaper in which you propose a one-day holiday from all electronic devices. Be sure to include a clear thesis statement, and use specific examples from your own experience to support your points.

    Question

    ALMF/kS1zzW73MouRsoXk1h0lKY=
    Argument: Bob Herbert, “Tweet Less, Kiss More” - Writing Practice: Write an editorial for your school’s newspaper in which you propose a one-day holiday from all electronic devices. Be sure to include a clear thesis statement, and use specific examples from your own experience to support your points.