Yun Yung Choi, “Invisible Women” (Student Essay)

Instructor's Notes

To assign the questions that follow this reading, click “Browse More Resources for this Unit,” or go to the Resources panel.

Yun Yung ChoiStudent Essay

Invisible Women

Yun Yung Choi examines the adoption of a new state religion in her native Korea and the effects of that adoption on Korean women. In 2013, South Korea elected its first woman president, Park Geun-hye. The election of Park, who is the daughter of a previous president of Korea, Park Chung-hee, was considered a major milestone in gender equality for South Korea. Choi wrote this essay prior to Park Geun-hye’s election.

1

For me, growing up in a small suburb on the outskirts of Seoul, the adults’ preference for boys seemed quite natural. All the important people that I knew—doctors, lawyers, policemen, and soldiers—were men. On the other hand, most of the women that I knew were either housekeepers or housewives whose duty seemed to be to obey and please the men of the family. When my teachers at school asked me what I wanted to be when I grew up, I would answer, “I want to be the wife of the president.” Because all women must become wives and mothers, I thought, becoming the wife of the president would be the highest achievement for a woman. I knew that the birth of a boy was a greatly desired and celebrated event, whereas the birth of a girl was a disappointing one, accompanied by the frequent words of consolation for the sad parents: “A daughter is her mother’s chief help in keeping house.”

131

2

These attitudes toward women, widely considered the continuation of an unbroken chain of tradition, are, in fact, only a few hundred years old, a relatively short period considering Korea’s long history. During the first half of the Yi dynasty, which lasted from 1392 to 1910, and during the Koryo period, which preceded the Yi dynasty, women were treated almost as equals with many privileges that were denied them during the latter half of the Yi dynasty. This turnabout in women’s place in Korean society was brought about by one of the greatest influences that shaped the government, literature, and thoughts of the Korean people—Confucianism°.

3

Throughout the Koryo period, which lasted from 918 to 1392, and throughout the first half of the Yi dynasty, according to Laurel Kendall in her book View from the Inner Room, women were important and contributing members of the society and not marginal and dependent as they later became. Women were, to a large extent, in command of their own lives. They were permitted to own property and receive inheritances from their fathers. Wedding ceremonies were held in the bride’s house, where the couple lived, and the wife retained her surname. Women were also allowed freedom of movement—that is, they were able to go outside the house without any feelings of shame or embarrassment.

4

With the introduction of Confucianism, however, the rights and privileges that women enjoyed were confiscated. The government of the Yi dynasty made great efforts to incorporate into society the Confucian ideologies, including the principle of agnation. This principle, according to Kendall, made men the important members of society and relegated° women to a dependent position. The government succeeded in Confucianizing the country and encouraging the acceptance of Confucian proverbs such as the following: “Men are honored, but women are abased.” “A daughter is a ‘robber woman’ who carries household wealth away when she marries.”

5

The unfortunate effects of this Confucianization in the lives of women were numerous. The most noticeable was the virtual confinement of women. They were forced to remain unseen in the anbang, the inner room of the house. This room was the women’s domain, or, rather, the women’s prison. Outside, a woman was carried through the streets in a closed sedan chair. Walking outside, she had to wear a veil that covered her face and could travel abroad only after nightfall. Thus, it is no wonder that Westerners traveling through Korea in the late nineteenth century expressed surprise at the apparent absence of women in the country.

132

6

Women received no formal education. Their only schooling came from government textbooks. By giving instruction on the virtuous° conduct of women, these books attempted to fit women into the Confucian stereotype—meek, quiet, and obedient. Thus, this Confucian society acclaimed particular women not for their talent or achievement but for the degree of perfection with which they were able to mimic the stereotype.

7

A woman even lost her identity in such a society. Once married, she became a stranger to her natal° family, becoming a member of her husband’s family. Her name was omitted from the family chokpo, or genealogy book, and was entered in the chokpo of her in-laws as a mere “wife” next to her husband’s name.

8

Even a desirable marriage, the ultimate hope for a woman, failed to provide financial and emotional security for her. Failure to produce a son was legal grounds for sending the wife back to her natal home, thereby subjecting the woman to the greatest humiliation and to a life of continued shame. And because the Confucian ideology stressed a wife’s devotion to her husband as the greatest of womanly virtues, widows were forced to avoid social disgrace by remaining faithfully unmarried, no matter how young they were. As women lost their rights to own or inherit property, these widows, with no means to support themselves, suffered great hardships. Thus, as Sandra Martielle says in Virtues in Conflict, what the government considered “the ugly custom of remarriage” was slowly eliminated at the expense of women’s happiness.

9

This male-dominated system of Confucianism is one of the surviving traditions from the Yi dynasty. Although the Constitution of the Republic of Korea proclaimed on July 17, 1948, guarantees individual freedom and sexual equality, these ideals failed to have any immediate effect on the Korean mentality that stubbornly adheres to its belief in the superiority of men. Women still regard marriage as their prime objective in life, and little girls still wish to become the doctor’s wife, the lawyer’s wife, and even the president’s wife. But as the system of Confucianism is slowly being forced out of existence by new legal and social standards, perhaps a day will come, after all, when a little girl will stand up in class and answer, “I want to be the president.”

Questions to Start You Thinking

Meaning

  1. What effect does Choi observe? What cause does she attribute it to?

  2. What specific changes in Korean culture does Choi attribute to the introduction of Confucianism?

  3. What evidence do you find of the writer’s critically rethinking an earlier belief and then revising it? What do you think may have influenced her to change her belief?

133

Writing Strategies

  1. What does Choi gain by beginning and ending with her personal experience?

  2. Where does Choi use the strategy of comparing and contrasting?

  3. How does Choi consider readers for whom her culture might be foreign?

  4. Using highlighters or marginal notes, identify the essay’s introduction, thesis, major causes or effects, supporting explanations and details for each of these, and conclusion. How effective is the organization?

image How would you have answered this question?

image How do you respond to this historical background?

image Why do you think the writer ends with this quotation?