Table 3-4: table: 3-4Comparing the Models

 

Biological

Psychodynamic

Behavioral

Cognitive

Humanistic

Existential

Family-Social

Multicultural

Cause of dysfunction

Biological malfunction

Underlying conflicts

Maladaptive learning

Maladaptive thinking

Self-deceit

Avoidance of responsibility

Family or social stress

External pressures or cultural conflicts

Research support

Strong

Modest

Strong

Strong

Weak

Weak

Moderate

Moderate

Consumer designation

Patient

Patient

Client

Client

Patient or client

Patient or client

Client

Client

Therapist role

Doctor

Interpreter

Teacher

Persuader

Observer

Collaborator

Family/social facilitator

Cultural advocate/teacher

Key therapy technique

Biological intervention

Free association and interpretation

Conditioning

Reasoning

Reflection

Varied

Family/social intervention

Culture-sensitive intervention

Therapy goal

Biological repair

Broad psychological change

Functional behaviors

Adaptive thinking

Self-actualization

Authentic life

Effective family or social

Cultural awareness and comfort