1.4 Current Trends

It would hardly be accurate to say that we now live in a period of great enlightenment about or dependable treatment of mental disorders. In fact, surveys have found that 43 percent of respondents believe that people bring mental disorders on themselves, and 35 percent consider such disorders to be caused by sinful behavior (Stuber et al., 2014; Stanford, 2007; NMHA, 1999). Nevertheless, there have been major changes over the past 50 years in the ways clinicians understand and treat abnormal functioning. There are more theories and types of treatment, more research studies, more information, and—perhaps because of those increases—more disagreements about abnormal functioning today than at any time in the past. In some ways the study and treatment of psychological disorders have made great strides, but in other respects clinical scientists and practitioners are still struggling to make a difference.

18

How Are People with Severe Disturbances Cared For?

From Juilliard to the streets Nathaniel Ayers, subject of the book and movie The Soloist, plays his violin on the streets of Los Angeles while living as a homeless person in 2005. Once a promising musical student at the Juilliard School in New York, Ayers developed schizophrenia and eventually found himself without treatment and without a home. Tens of thousands of people with severe mental disorders are currently homeless.

In the 1950s, researchers discovered a number of new psychotropic medications—drugs that primarily affect the brain and reduce many symptoms of mental dysfunctioning. They included the first antipsychotic drugs, which correct extremely confused and distorted thinking; antidepressant drugs, which lift the mood of depressed people; and antianxiety drugs, which reduce tension and worry.

psychotropic medications Drugs that mainly affect the brain and reduce many symptoms of mental dysfunctioning.

When given these drugs, many patients who had spent years in mental hospitals began to show signs of improvement. Hospital administrators, encouraged by these results and pressured by a growing public outcry over the terrible conditions in public mental hospitals, began to discharge patients almost immediately.

Since the discovery of these medications, mental health professionals in most of the developed nations of the world have followed a policy of deinstitutionalization, releasing hundreds of thousands of patients from public mental hospitals. On any given day in 1955, close to 600,000 people were confined in public mental institutions across the United States (see Figure 1-1). Today the daily patient population in the same kinds of hospitals is less than 40,000 (Althouse, 2010).

deinstitutionalization The practice, begun in the 1960s, of releasing hundreds of thousands of patients from public mental hospitals.

Figure 1.1: figure 1-1
The impact of deinstitutionalization
The number of patients (fewer than 40,000) now hospitalized in public mental hospitals in the United States is a small fraction of the number hospitalized in 1955.

In short, outpatient care has now become the primary mode of treatment for people with severe psychological disturbances as well as for those with more moderate problems. When severely disturbed people do need institutionalization these days, they are usually hospitalized for a short period of time. Ideally, they are then provided with outpatient psychotherapy and medication in community programs and residences (Goldman & Tansella, 2013; McEvoy & Richards, 2007).

Chapters 3 and 15 will look more closely at this recent emphasis on community care for people with severe psychological disturbances—a philosophy called the community mental health approach. The approach has been helpful for many patients, but too few community programs are available to address current needs in the United States (Dixon et al, 2013; Lieberman, 2010). As a result, hundreds of thousands of persons with severe disturbances fail to make lasting recoveries, and they shuttle back and forth between the mental hospital and the community. After release from the hospital, they at best receive minimal care and often wind up living in decrepit rooming houses or on the streets. In fact, only 40 to 60 percent of persons with severe psychological disturbances currently receive treatment of any kind (Gill, 2010; NIMH, 2010). At least 100,000 people with such disturbances are homeless on any given day; another 135,000 or more are inmates of jails and prisons (Kooyman & Walsh, 2011; Althouse, 2010). Their abandonment is truly a national disgrace.

How Are People with Less Severe Disturbances Treated?

The treatment picture for people with moderate psychological disturbances has been more positive than that for people with severe disorders. Since the 1950s, outpatient care has continued to be the preferred mode of treatment for them, and the number and types of facilities that offer such care have expanded to meet the need.

Before the 1950s, almost all outpatient care took the form of private psychotherapy, an arrangement by which an individual directly pays a psychotherapist for counseling services. This tended to be an expensive form of treatment, available only to the wealthy. Since the 1950s, however, most health insurance plans have expanded coverage to include private psychotherapy, so that it is now also widely available to people with more modest incomes. In addition, outpatient therapy is now offered in a number of less expensive settings, such as community mental health centers, crisis intervention centers, family service centers, and other social service agencies. The new settings have spurred a dramatic increase in the number of people seeking outpatient care for psychological problems. Surveys suggest that nearly one of every six adults in the United States receives treatment for psychological disorders in the course of a year (NIMH, 2010). The majority of clients are seen for fewer than five sessions during the year.

private psychotherapy An arrangement in which a person directly pays a therapist for counseling services.

19

Outpatient treatments are also becoming available for more and more kinds of problems. When Freud and his colleagues first began to practice, most of their patients suffered from anxiety or depression. Almost half of today’s clients suffer from those same problems, but people with other kinds of disorders are also receiving therapy. In addition, at least 20 percent of clients enter therapy because of milder problems in living—problems with marital, family, job, peer, school, or community relationships (Ten Have et al., 2013; Druss & Bornemann, 2010; Druss et al., 2007).

Yet another change in outpatient care since the 1950s has been the development of programs devoted exclusively to one kind of psychological problem. We now have, for example, suicide prevention centers, substance abuse programs, eating disorder programs, phobia clinics, and sexual dysfunction programs. Clinicians in these programs have the kind of expertise that can be acquired only by concentration in a single area.

A Growing Emphasis on Preventing Disorders and Promoting Mental Health

Although the community mental health approach has often failed to address the needs of people with severe disorders, it has given rise to an important principle of mental health care—prevention (Grill & Monsell, 2014; Hutton & Taylor, 2014; Eckenrode, 2011). Rather than wait for psychological disorders to occur, many of today’s community programs try to correct the social conditions that underlie psychological problems (poverty or violence in the community, for example) and to help individuals who are at risk for developing emotional problems (for example, teenage mothers or the children of people with severe psychological disorders). As you will see later, community prevention programs are not always successful and they often suffer from limited funding, but they have grown in number throughout the United States and Europe, offering great promise as the ultimate form of intervention.

prevention Interventions aimed at deterring mental disorders before they can develop.

20

Green spaces and mental health A young woman soaks in the green environment at Battersea Park in London. Recent positive psychology research has found that people who live in urban areas feel less distress and report higher life satisfaction if they reside in greener areas of their cities (White et al., 2013). Small wonder then that Londoners with easy access to parks and green spaces say that they have a better quality of life than those living without it.

Prevention programs have been further energized in the past few years by the field of psychology’s ever-growing interest in positive psychology (Ramirez et al., 2014; Seligman & Fowler, 2011). Positive psychology is the study and enhancement of positive feelings such as optimism and happiness, positive traits like hard work and wisdom, positive abilities such as social skills and other talents, and group-directed virtues, including altruism and tolerance (see InfoCentral below).

positive psychology The study and enhancement of positive feelings, traits, and abilities.

Why do you think it has taken psychologists so long to start studying positive behaviors?

In the clinical arena, positive psychology suggests that practitioners can help people best by promoting positive development and psychological wellness. While researchers study and learn more about positive psychology in the laboratory, clinicians with this orientation teach people coping skills that may help protect them from stress and adversity and encourage them to become more involved in personally meaningful activities and relationships (Sergeant & Mongrain, 2014; Bolier et al., 2013). In this way, the clinicians are trying to promote mental health and prevent mental disorders.

Multicultural Psychology

We are, without question, a society of multiple cultures, races, and languages. Members of racial and ethnic minority groups in the United States collectively make up 35 percent of the population, a percentage that is expected to grow to more than 50 percent in the coming decades (Santa-Cruz, 2010; U.S. Census Bureau, 2010). This change is partly because of shifts in immigration trends and partly because of higher birth rates among minority groups in the United States (NVSR, 2010).

In response to this growing diversity, a new area of study called multicultural psychology has emerged. Multicultural psychologists seek to understand how culture, race, ethnicity, gender, and similar factors affect behavior and thought and how people of different cultures, races, and genders may differ psychologically (Alegría et al., 2013, 2010, 2004). As you will see throughout this book, the field of multicultural psychology has begun to have a powerful effect on our understanding and treatment of abnormal behavior.

multicultural psychology The field that examines the impact of culture, race, ethnicity, and gender on behaviors and thoughts and focuses on how such factors may influence the origin, nature, and treatment of abnormal behavior.

Positive psychology in action Often positive psychology and multicultural psychology work together. Here, for example, two young girls come together as one at the end of a “slave reconciliation” walk by 400 people in Maryland. The walk was intended to promote racial understanding and to help Americans overcome the lasting psychological effects of slavery.

The Increasing Influence of Insurance Coverage

So many people now seek therapy that private insurance companies have changed their coverage for mental health patients. Today the dominant form of coverage is the managed care program—a program in which the insurance company determines such key issues as which therapists its clients may choose, the cost of sessions, and the number of sessions for which a client may be reimbursed (Domino, 2012; Glasser, 2010).

managed care program Health care coverage in which the insurance company largely controls the nature, scope, and cost of medical or psychological services.

At least 75 percent of all privately insured persons in the United States are currently enrolled in managed care programs (Deb et al., 2006; Kiesler, 2000). The coverage for mental health treatment under such programs follows the same basic principles as coverage for medical treatment, including a limited pool of practitioners from which patients can choose, preapproval of treatment by the insurance company, strict standards for judging whether problems and treatments qualify for reimbursement, and ongoing reviews and assessments. In the mental health realm, both therapists and clients typically dislike managed care programs (Lustig et al., 2013; Schneid, 2010). They fear that the programs inevitably shorten therapy (often for the worse), unfairly favor treatments whose results are not always lasting (for example, drug therapy), pose a special hardship for those with severe mental disorders, and result in treatments determined by insurance companies rather than by therapists (Turner, 2013; Glasser, 2010).

21

InfoCentral

HAPPINESS

Positive psychology is the study of positive feelings, traits, and abilities. A better understanding of constructive functioning enables clinicians to better promote psychological wellness. Happiness is the positive psychology topic currently receiving the most attention. Many, but far from all, people are happy. In fact, only one-third of adults declare themselves “very happy.” Let’s take a look at some of today’s leading facts, figures, and notions about happiness.

22

An ounce of prevention The clinical field’s growing emphasis on prevention has affected how employers address the problem of stress in the workplace. About 20 percent of corporate employers now offer some kind of stress-reduction program, such as this regular yoga class at Armani (the fashion company) in New York City. Corporate spending has helped fuel the $12 billion stress-management industry.

A key problem with insurance coverage—both managed care and other kinds of insurance programs—is that reimbursements for mental disorders tend to be lower than those for medical disorders. This places persons with psychological difficulties at a distinct disadvantage (Abelson, 2013). In 2008, the U.S. Congress passed a federal parity law that directed insurance companies to provide equal coverage for mental and medical problems. However, a number of insurance companies found ways around that law and continued to deny or limit payments for mental health treatments. Thus in 2013, the Departments of Health and Human Services, Labor, and Treasury jointly issued a federal regulation that defined the principles of parity more clearly (SAMHSA, 2014; Calmes & Pear, 2013), and in 2014 the mental health provisions of the Affordable Care Act (the ACA)—referred to colloquially as “Obamacare”—went into effect and extended the reach of the 2013 regulations still further. For example, the ACA designates mental health care as 1 of 10 types of “essential health benefits” that must be provided by all insurers (SAMHSA, 2014; Pear, 2013). It also requires all health plans to provide preventive mental health services at no additional cost (for example, free screenings for depressive disorders) and to allow new and continued membership to individuals who have preexisting mental conditions. Although such changes have heartened mental health advocates, it is not yet clear whether such provisions will in fact result in significantly better treatment for people with psychological problems.

What Are Today’s Leading Theories and Professions?

BETWEEN THE LINES

Gender Shift

28%

Psychologists in 1978 who were female

52%

Psychologists today who are female

77%

Current undergraduate psychology majors who are female

72%

Current psychology graduate students who are female

(Cherry, 2014; Carey, 2011; Cynkar, 2007; Barber, 1999)

One of the most important developments in the clinical field has been the growth of numerous theoretical perspectives that now coexist in the field. Before the 1950s, the psychoanalytic perspective, with its emphasis on unconscious psychological problems as the cause of abnormal behavior, was dominant. Then the discovery of effective psychotropic drugs inspired new respect for the somatogenic, or biological, view. As you will see in Chapter 3, other influential perspectives that have emerged since the 1950s are the behavioral, cognitive, humanistic-existential, and sociocultural schools of thought. At present, no single viewpoint dominates the clinical field as the psychoanalytic perspective once did. In fact, the perspectives often conflict and compete with one another, yet in some instances they complement one another and together provide more complete explanations and treatments for psychological disorders.

In addition, a variety of professionals now offer help to people with psychological problems. Before the 1950s, psychotherapy was offered only by psychiatrists, physicians who complete three to four additional years of training after medical school (a residency) in the treatment of abnormal mental functioning. After World War II, however, with millions of soldiers returning home to countries throughout North America and Europe, the demand for mental health services expanded so rapidly that other professional groups had to step in to fill the need.

Among those other groups are clinical psychologists—professionals who earn a doctorate in clinical psychology by completing four to five years of graduate training in abnormal functioning and its treatment and also complete a one-year internship in a mental health setting. Psychotherapy and related services are also provided by counseling psychologists, educational and school psychologists, psychiatric nurses, marriage therapists, family therapists, and—the largest group—clinical social workers (see Table 1-2). Each of these specialties has its own graduate training program. Theoretically, each conducts therapy in a distinctive way, but in reality clinicians from the various specialties often use similar techniques.

23

Table 1.2: table: 1-2Profiles of Mental Health Professionals in the United States

 

Degree

Began to Practice

Current Number

Average Annual Salary

Percent Female

Psychiatrists

MD, DO

1840s

  50,000

$144,020

25

Psychologists

PhD, PsyD, EdD

Late 1940s

174,000

  $63,000

52

Social workers

MSW, DSW

Early 1950s

607,000

  $43,040

77

Counselors

Various

Early 1950s

475,000

  $47,530

90

Information from: Cherry, 2014; U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2014, 2011, 2002; AMA, 2011; Carey, 2011; Weissman, 2000.

BETWEEN THE LINES

In Their Words

“I would rather have anything wrong with my body than something wrong with my head.”

Sylvia Plath, The Bell Jar

A related development in the study and treatment of mental disorders since World War II has been a growing appreciation of the need for effective research (NIMH, 2011). Clinical researchers have tried to determine which concepts best explain and predict abnormal behavior, which treatments are most effective, and what kinds of changes may be required. Well-trained clinical researchers conduct studies in universities, medical schools, laboratories, mental hospitals, mental health centers, and other clinical settings throughout the world. Their work has produced important discoveries and has changed many of our ideas about abnormal psychological functioning.

Technology and Mental Health

Technology is always changing and, like most other fields, the mental health field is in the position of trying to keep pace with that change. This is not a new state of affairs. Technological change occurred 25, 50, 100 years ago and beyond. What is new, however, is the breathtaking rate of technological change that characterizes today’s world. This growth has begun to have significant effects—both positive and negative—on the mental health field, and it will undoubtedly affect the field even more in the coming years.

Let’s consider just a small sample of the ways that the mental health field has been affected by recent technological advances. You will come across these and many others throughout the textbook.

Our digital world provides new triggers and vehicles for the expression of abnormal behavior. As you’ll see in Chapter 12, for example, many individuals who grapple with gambling disorder have found the ready availability of Internet gambling to be all too inviting. Similarly, the Internet, texting, and social media have become convenient tools for those who wish to stalk or bully others, express sexual exhibitionism, or pursue pedophilic desires (Taylor & Quayle, 2010). Likewise, some clinicians believe that violent video games may contribute to the development of antisocial behavior, and perhaps even to the onset of conduct disorders among children and teenagers (Zhuo, 2010). And, in the opinion of many clinicians, constant texting, tweeting, and Internet browsing may contribute to shorter attention spans and establish a foundation for attention problems (Richtel, 2010).

24

BETWEEN THE LINES

Public Opinion: Who is “Mentally Ill”?

  • According to surveys, 2 percent of the public believe that people who see a therapist are mentally ill.

  • Approximately 37 percent believe that individuals who are prescribed medications by a psychiatrist are mentally ill.

  • Around 44 percent believe voluntary patients in a mental hospital are mentally ill.

  • Around 70 percent believe that involuntary patients in a mental hospital are mentally ill.

(Miller, 2014)

A number of clinicians also worry that social networking can contribute to psychological dysfunctioning in certain cases. On the positive side, research indicates that, on average, social media users maintain more close relationships than other people do, receive more social support, are more trusting and open to differing points of view, and are more likely to participate in groups and lead active lives (Hampton et al., 2011; Rainie et al., 2011). On the negative side, however, there is research suggesting that social networking sites may provide a new venue for peer pressure that increases social anxiety in some adolescents (Charles, 2011; Hampton et al., 2011). The sites may, for example, cause some people to develop fears that others in their network will exclude them socially. Similarly, there is clinical concern that sites such as Facebook may facilitate shy or socially anxious people’s withdrawal from valuable face-to-face relationships.

In addition, the face of clinical treatment is constantly changing in our fastmoving digital world. The use of cybertherapy, for example, is growing by leaps and bounds as a treatment option (Carrard et al., 2011; Pope & Vasquez, 2011). As you’ll see in Chapter 3, cybertherapy takes such forms as long-distance therapy between clients and therapists using Skype, therapy offered by computer programs, treatment enhanced by the use of video game-like avatars and other virtual reality experiences, and Internet-based support groups. Similarly, countless Web sites offer a wealth of mental health information, enabling people to better inform themselves, their friends, and their family members about psychological dysfunctioning and treatment options. And literally thousands of apps are devoted to relaxing people, cheering them up, or otherwise improving their psychological states (see MindTech).

cybertherapy The use of computer technology, such as Skype or avatars, to provide therapy.

MindTech

Mental Health Apps Explode in the Marketplace

About a decade ago, some clinicians and researchers began using text messages to help track the behaviors, thoughts, and emotions of clients with psychological problems (Bauer, 2003). That pioneering work has mushroomed into an industry of smartphone apps that often help provide mental health assistance to consumers (Sifferlin, 2013). There are, in fact, now thousands of such apps in the marketplace—many of them free, the rest low in cost (Saedi, 2012).

Many of these apps provide individuals with mental health education and resources; others help users to keep track of their shifting moods, thoughts, and bodily changes (called biometrics); still others are interactive and are designed to serve as co-therapists or even substitute therapists, offering reminders, advice, and exercises in response to the needs and input of users. Some of today’s more popular apps include My Mood Tracker, MindShift, PTSD Coach, Moody Me, Live Happy, Optimism, Moodscope, and Mood 247 (Kiume, 2013; Szalavitz, 2013; Landau, 2012; Saedi, 2012).

What kinds of problems might result from the growing availability and use of mental health apps in today’s world?

Many of today’s apps are promising (Konrath, 2013), and they have increasingly been recommended by therapists and mental health researchers, and even by the National Institutes of Health. But, be aware, most of them are unregulated. Only in the past year has the FDA announced its intention to systematically regulate smartphone apps that monitor health and mental health (Alter, 2013). In the meantime, in the absence of regulation and proper research, consumers and therapists alike would be wise to investigate the reputation, manufacturer, content, and therapeutic principles of apps that they are considering (Sifferlin, 2013).

25

BETWEEN THE LINES

Famous Psych Lines from the Movies

“She wore the gloves all the time, so I just thought, maybe she has a thing about dirt.” (Frozen, 2013)

“I opened up to you and you judged me.” (Silver Linings Playbook, 2012)

“I just want to be perfect.” (Black Swan, 2010)

“Take baby steps.” (What About Bob? 1991)

“I see dead people.” (The Sixth Sense, 1999)

“I love the smell of napalm in the morning.” (Apocalypse Now, 1979)

“Snakes. Why’d it have to be snakes?” (Raiders of the Lost Ark, 1981)

Unfortunately, as you’ll also see throughout the book, the cybertherapy movement is not without its problems. Along with the wealth of mental health information now available online comes an enormous amount of misinformation about psychological problems and their treatments, offered by persons and sites that at best, are far from knowledgeable. Similarly, the issue of quality control is a major problem for Internet-based therapy, support groups, and the like. Moreover, there are now numerous antitreatment Web sites that try to guide people away from seeking help for their psychological problems (Davey, 2010). In Chapters 4, 9, and 11, for example, you will read about the growing phenomenon of pro-anorexia and pro-suicide Web sites and the dangerous influences they exert on vulnerable people. Clearly, the impact of technological change on the mental health field today is wide-ranging and both positive and negative. Its impact presents formidable challenges for clinicians and researchers alike.