Chapter Introduction

chapter 17

Human Health and Environmental Risks

image
The citizens of Norco, Louisiana, live in the shadows of chemical plants and oil refineries. (Mark Ludak/The Image Works)

588

Module 56 Human Diseases

Module 57 Toxicology and Chemical Risks

Module 58 Risk Analysis

589

Citizen Scientists

The neighborhood of Old Diamond in Norco, Louisiana, was composed of four city blocks located between a chemical plant and an oil refinery, both owned by the Shell Oil Company. There were approximately 1,500 residents in the neighborhood, largely lower-income African Americans. In 1973, a pipeline explosion blew a house off its foundation and killed two residents. In 1988, an accident at the refinery killed seven workers and sent more than 70 million kg (159 million pounds) of potentially toxic chemicals into the air. Nearly one-third of the children in Old Diamond suffered from asthma and there were many cases of cancer and birth defects. The unusually high rates of disease raised suspicions that the two nearby industrial facilities were harming the residents.

The unusually high rates of disease raised suspicions that the two nearby industrial facilities were harming the residents.

By 1989, local resident and middle school teacher Margie Richard had seen enough. Richard organized the Concerned Citizens of Norco. The primary goal of the group was to get Shell to buy the residents’ properties at a fair price so they could move away from the industries that were putting their health at risk. Richard contacted environmental scientists and quickly learned that to make a solid case to the company and to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), she needed to be more than an organizer; she also needed to be a scientist.

The residents knew that the local air had a foul smell, but they had no way of knowing which chemicals were present and in what concentrations. To determine whether they were being exposed to chemicals at concentrations that posed a health risk, the air had to be tested. Richard learned about specially built buckets that could collect air samples. She organized a “Bucket Brigade” of volunteers and slowly collected the data she and her collaborators needed. As a result of these efforts, scientists were able to document that the Shell refinery was releasing more than 0.9 million kg (2 million pounds) of toxic chemicals into the air each year.

590

The fight against Shell met strong resistance from company officials and went on for 13 years. But in the end, Margie Richard won her battle. In 2002, Shell agreed to purchase the homes of the Old Diamond neighborhood. The company also agreed to pay an additional $5 million for community development and it committed to reducing air emissions from the refinery by 30 percent to help improve the air quality for those residents who remained in the area. In 2007, Shell agreed that it had violated air pollution regulations in several of its Louisiana plants and paid the state of Louisiana $6.5 million in penalties.

For her tremendous efforts in winning the battle in Norco, Margie Richard was the 2004 North American recipient of the Goldman Environmental Prize, which honors grassroots environmentalists. Since then, Richard has brought her message to many other minority communities located near large polluting industries. She teaches that protecting human health and the local environment requires community action—and learning how to be a citizen scientist.

Sources: The Goldman Environmental Prize: Margie Richard. http://www.goldmanprize.org/2004/northamerica; M. Scallan, Shell, DEQ settle emission charges: Fines and upgrades to cost $6.5 million, Times-Picayune (New Orleans), March 15, 2007, http://royaldutchshellplc.com/2007/03/15/the-times-picayune-shell-deq-settle-emission-charges-fines-and-upgrades-to-cost-65-million/.

The number of health risks that we face in our lives can feel overwhelming. Sometimes it seems that we hear new warnings every day. How do we evaluate and manage these risks? The first step in understanding health risks is to consider the three major categories of risk that can be detrimental to human health: physical, biological, and chemical. Physical risks include environmental factors, such as natural disasters, that can cause injury and loss of life. Physical risks also include less dramatic factors such as excessive exposure to ultraviolet radiation from the Sun, which causes sunburn and skin cancer, and exposure to radioactive substances such as radon, which we discussed in Chapter 15. Biological risks, which cause the most human deaths, are those risks associated with disease. Chemical risks are associated with exposure to chemicals ranging from those that occur naturally, such as arsenic, to those that are manufactured, such as synthetic chemicals and pesticides. In this chapter, we will focus on biological and chemical risks, and we will determine which of those risks are common and the current state of our understanding about each of them. We will look at how to assess and manage these risks. As we will see, although many health risks exist in both the developed and developing worlds, we can do a great deal to manage these risks and improve our lives.