10.1 The Nature of Prejudice: Pervasiveness and Perspective

Prejudice probably is the most heavily studied topic in social psychology. The historical pervasiveness and destructiveness of prejudice is probably why. Virtually every person currently living on this planet has been profoundly affected by prejudice. If you are Arab American, African American, Hispanic American, Jewish American, or Native American, this is likely obvious to you. But it is equally true regardless of your ethnic background. Every ethnic and cultural group has been powerfully influenced by historical intergroup conflicts and oppression. The French have been targets of prejudice by Americans, have been involved historically in conflicts with England (including a 100-year war) and Germany. French culture has been greatly influenced by France’s colonization of places such as Canada, Algeria, and Vietnam. Japan and China have exchanged many acts of hostility and violence over a long period of time. Many innocent Japanese people were killed by the atomic bombs that American pilots dropped on Nagasaki and Hiroshima during World War II. And during that war, the U.S. government forced many Japanese Americans into internment camps. Within Japan is an oppressed minority group called the Burakumin. And in most if not all cultures, women are to varying degrees targets of violence and restricted in their freedoms and opportunities. Pick a group, and you could read volumes about how that group has been affected by prejudice.

In everyday language, the word prejudice has a number of meanings, all based on the notion of judging something or someone prematurely from insufficient evidence. In social psychology, prejudice is defined as a negative attitude toward an individual based solely on that person’s presumed membership in a particular group. Thus the person is disliked not because of her personal attributes or actions but simply because she is perceived to be in some supposedly undesirable category: physically disabled, Italian, African American, Hindu, female, lesbian, fat, old, teenager, communist.

Prejudice

A negative attitude toward an individual solely on the basis of that person’s presumed membership in a particular group.

An interesting aspect of prejudice is that, on the one hand, many if not most people seem to be prejudiced against some group. (Right now, you might be feeling some prejudice against prejudiced people!) and they usually feel that their particular prejudice is justified. On the other hand, social psychologists generally assume that prejudice against a person based simply on her or his membership in a group is never justified. This assumption is based on three characteristics of prejudice.

351

First, prejudice involves judging an individual negatively independent of the person’s actual attributes or actions. Social psychologists follow the hope famously articulated by Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. (1992): “I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character.” If someone harms you or someone you care about, you are justified in disliking that person. If a person simply practices a religion different from your own, has a different skin tone, or comes from a different country, you are not justified in disliking that person.

Think ABOUT

Second, any large category of people will include tremendous variability in virtually every possible attribute by which one might judge another person positively or negatively (Allport, 1954). There may be a group mean (what the average member of a group is like), but there also is always a normal distribution that captures the range along which most people vary from that mean. Think of members of your own extended family—siblings, parents, aunts, uncles, cousins, grandparents. Can you think of some who are generous, some who are cheap; some who are likeable, some who are unpleasant; some who are smart, some not so much; some who are honest, some who are deceitful; some who are ambitious, some who are not? If you can find variability in such a small group, imagine the variability in the many millions of people who are identified as Americans, Muslim, Hispanic, or gay. Because of this variation, assuming anything about all members of such groups will necessarily lead to many errors. To use an example where measurable data are available, consider that although the average American (male, 5′9 1/2″, female, 5′4″) is taller than the average Chinese person (male, 5′7″; female, 5′2 1/2″) (Yang et al., 2005), literally millions of Americans are shorter than the average Chinese person, and millions of Chinese people are taller than the average American (see FIGURE 10.1).

Figure 10.1:
FIGURE 10.1a
Human Variability
Although Americans on average are taller than Chinese people, there is great variability in the height of individuals in both groups, leading to many exceptions.
FIGURE 10.1b
Overlapping Normal Distributions of Two Groups With Different Mean Heights
The normal distribution of Chinese and American males’ heights, based on the group means, might look something like this. The shaded areas represent cases in which we would be wrong if we simply assumed that American males are taller than the average Chinese male or that Chinese males are shorter than the average American male.

352

The third reason social psychologists judge prejudice negatively is that it has so often led to appalling acts of violence against innocent people—including babies and children—who happened to be, or were presumed to be, members of particular groups. Like Milgram in his research on obedience, many early social psychologists were inspired to focus on prejudice because of one of the most egregious examples of what prejudice can lead to: the Nazi Holocaust, which resulted in the deaths of an estimated 6 million Jews and 5 million members of other groups despised by the Nazis (e.g., Gypsies, Slavs, the physically disabled).

So that’s the case for prejudice being a bad thing. The people who hold prejudices usually justify them with stereotypes: overgeneralized beliefs about the traits and attributes of members of a particular group: “African Americans are violent,” “Jews are cheap,” “Latinos are lazy,” and so forth. Not all stereotypic traits attributed to a group are negative, but overall, stereotypes of outgroups tend to be negative. Later in this chapter, we will consider where these stereotypes come from, how they affect us, and how they are perpetuated. As we will learn, stereotypes can operate both as conscious justifications of prejudices against others and as implicit assumptions that guide how we think about groups and their members. Even when we don’t acknowledge it or want it to happen, stereotypes can still sometimes bias how we think, feel, and behave toward those whom we perceive as different from us in some way.

Stereotypes

Overgeneralized beliefs about the traits and attributes of members of a particular group.

Discrimination

Negative behavior toward an individual solely on the basis of that person’s membership in a particular group.

When people hold prejudices and stereotypes, either consciously or unconsciously, this often leads to discrimination: negative behavior toward an individual solely on the basis of membership in a particular group. Discrimination comes in many forms, ranging from cold behavior at a party to declining someone’s loan application to torture and genocide. Discrimination is often the consequence of the negative attitude (prejudice) and beliefs (stereotypes) a person holds. But as you’ll recall, attitudes don’t always guide behavior. Because of laws, cultural norms, and competing values to be egalitarian, we can be thankful that people’s behavior is not always biased by prejudice and stereotypes.

SECTION review: The Nature of Prejudice: Pervasiveness and Perspective

The Nature of Prejudice: Pervasiveness and Perspective

Prejudice is probably the most heavily studied topic in social psychology, likely because of its historical pervasiveness and destructiveness.

In social psychology, prejudice is defined as a negative attitude toward an individual based solely on that person’s presumed membership in a particular group.

The people who hold prejudices usually justify them with stereotypes, overgeneralized beliefs about the traits and attributes of members of a particular group.

Prejudices and stereotypes, held either consciously or unconsciously, often lead to discrimination: negative behavior toward an individual based solely on that person’s presumed membership in a particular group.