Comparative Analysis Chicano and Native American Freedom Movements Documents 26.2 and 26.3

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS

Chicano and Native American Freedom Movements

In April 1969, a group of students met at the University of California at Santa Barbara and formed the Movimiento Estudiantil Chicano de Aztlán (MEChA; Chicano Student Movement of Aztlán). MEChA organizers drafted “El Plan de Santa Barbara,” excerpted in Document 26.2, which set out their basic philosophy and objectives. The same year, eighty-nine California college students representing a number of different tribes of American Indians seized Alcatraz Island located in San Francisco Bay and presented their grievances, which are excerpted in Document 26.3, to the American government. They claimed that under a Sioux Treaty of 1868, Alcatraz belonged to the Indians.

Document 26.2

Chicano Student Movement of Aztlán, 1969

For decades Mexican people in the United States struggled to realize the “American Dream.” And some—a few—have. But the cost, the ultimate cost of assimilation, required turning away from el barrio [one’s neighborhood] and la colonia [one’s community]. In the meantime, due to the racist structure of this society, to our essentially different life style, and to the socioeconomic functions assigned to our community by Anglo-American society—as suppliers of cheap labor and a dumping ground for the small-time capitalist entrepreneur—the barrio and colonia remained exploited, impoverished, and marginal.

As a result, the self-determination of our community is now the only acceptable mandate for social and political action; it is the essence of Chicano commitment. Culturally, the word Chicano, in the past a pejorative and class-bound adjective, has now become the root idea of a new cultural identity for our people. It also reveals a growing solidarity and the development of a common social praxis [customary conduct]. The widespread use of the term Chicano today signals a rebirth of pride and confidence. Chicanismo simply embodies an ancient truth: that man is never closer to his true self as when he is close to his community.

Chicanismo draws its faith and strength from two main sources: from the just struggle of our people and from an objective analysis of our community’s strategic needs. We recognize that without a strategic use of education, an education that places value on what we value, we will not realize our destiny. Chicanos recognize the central importance of institutions of higher learning to modern progress, in this case, to the development of our community. But we go further: we believe that higher education must contribute to the information of a complete man who truly values life and freedom.

Source: Carlos Muñoz Jr., Youth, Identity, Power: The Chicano Movement (London: Verso, 1989), 191–92.

Document 26.3

The Alcatraz Proclamation, 1969

We, the native Americans, re-claim the land known as Alcatraz Island in the name of all American Indians by right of discovery.

We wish to be fair and honorable in our dealings with the Caucasian inhabitants of this land, and hereby offer the following treaty:

We will purchase said Alcatraz Island for 24 dollars ($24) in glass beads and red cloth, a precedent set by the white man’s purchase of a similar island about 300 years ago. We know that $24 in trade goods for these 16 acres is more than was paid when Manhattan Island was sold, but we offer that land values have risen over the years. Our offer of $1.24 per acres is greater than the 47 cents per acre the white men are now paying the California Indians for their land. We will give to the inhabitants of this island a portion of that land for their own, to be held in trust by the American Indian Government—for as long as the sun shall rise and the rivers go down to the sea—to be administered by the Bureau of Caucasian Affairs (BC). We will further guide the inhabitants in the proper way of living. We will offer them our religion, our education, our life-ways in order to help them achieve our level of civilization and thus raise them and all their white brothers up from their savage and unhappy state. We offer this treaty in good faith and wish to be fair and honorable in our dealings with the white men.

. . . In the name of all Indians, therefore, we reclaim this island for Indian nations, for all these reasons. We feel this claim is just and proper, and that this land should rightfully be granted to us for as long as the rivers run and the sun shall shine.

Signed, Indians of All Tribes, November 19, 1969, San Francisco, California

Source: Camilla Townsend, ed., American Indian History: A Documentary Reader (Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell, 2009), 186–88.

Interpret the Evidence

  1. Why does MEChA focus on the use of the term Chicano, and what does it hope to gain by its usage?

  2. Why do the Alcatraz protesters believe they are being fair to the United States?

  3. What connections do Chicano and Indian protesters make between cultural awareness and political activism?

Put It in Context

How did the civil rights and black power movements influence other freedom movements?