Interpret the Evidence and Put It in Context

Document Links:

Document 23.1 Why We Fight: Prelude to War Transcript (1942)

Document 23.2 Poster to All Persons of Japanese Ancestry (1942)

Document 23.3 CHIEF JUSTICE HARLAN F. STONE, Hirabayashi v. United States Decision (1943)

Document 23.4 JUSTICE FRANK MURPHY, Dissent in Korematsu v. United States (1944)

Document 23.5 CHARLES KIKUCHI, Internment Diary (1942)

INTERPRET THE EVIDENCE

  1. How does the Why We Fight transcript portray Japan and its leadership? How does it compare Japan to Germany and Italy (Document 23.1)?

  2. How would you describe the government’s strategy for relocating the Japanese (Document 23.2)? What hardships would Japanese people face? What assistance did the government offer to relocated people?

  3. Why did Chief Justice Harlan F. Stone uphold the constitutionality of Executive Order 9066 (Document 23.3)? How does he counter arguments that a curfew for Japanese people constitutes racial discrimination?

  4. Why did Justice Frank Murphy argue that internment was unconstitutional (Document 23.4)? Why, in his opinion, did the government specifically target Japanese citizens?

  5. What did Charles Kikuchi mean by his statement that Americans who protested his right to vote were more dangerous than Japanese American citizens (Document 23.5)?

  6. How did opponents of internment invoke American values in their arguments?

PUT IT IN CONTEXT

  1. In what ways was internment different from other instances when the United States suppressed civil liberties during wartime?

  2. What might have been alternatives to Japanese internment?