PROBLEMS

WORKING WITH THE FIGURES

Question 20.1

In Figure 20-5, note that the difference in survival rates between AS and AA genotypes declines as children get older. Offer one possible explanation for this observation.

Question 20.2

Examining Figure 20-8, explain why the rate of evolution at nonsynonymous sites is lower. Do you expect this to be true only of globin genes or of most genes?

Question 20.3

From Table 20-3, would you expect the noncoding mutation g4205a to be fixed before or after the coding mutation G238S in a population of bacteria evolving resistance to the antibiotic cefotaxime? Give at least two reasons for your answer.

Question 20.4

Examining Table 20-4, what do you think would be the order of mutations fixed during selection in a third evolving virus line? Would the mutations become fixed in the same order as the TX or ID virus?

Question 20.5

Examining Table 20-5, how would the interpretation of the McDonald–Kreitman test results differ if the number of nonsynonymous observed species differences was 1 instead of 7?

Question 20.6

Using Figure 20-17, explain how the mutation in the GATA sequence of the Duffy gene imparts resistance to P.vivax infection.

Question 20.7

In Figure 20-18, what is the evidence that polyploid formation has been important in plant evolution?

BASIC PROBLEMS

Question 20.8

Compare Darwin’s description of natural selection as quoted in Section 10.1 with Wallace’s description of the tendency of varieties to depart from the original type quoted below it, on the same page. What ideas do they have in common?

Question 20.9

What are the three principles of the theory of evolution by natural selection?

Question 20.10

Why was the neutral theory of molecular evolution a revolutionary idea?

Question 20.11

What would you predict to be the relative rate of synonymous and nonsynonymous substitutions in a globin pseudogene?

Question 20.12

Are AS heterozygotes completely resistant to malarial infection? Explain the evidence for your answer.

CHALLENGING PROBLEMS

Question 20.13

If the mutation rate to a new allele is 10–5, assuming there is no migration, how large must isolated populations be to prevent chance differentiation among them in the frequency of this allele?

792

Question 20.14

Glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) is a critical enzyme involved in the metabolism of glucose, especially in red blood cells. Deficiencies in the enzyme are the most common human enzyme defect and occur at a high frequency in certain populations of East African children.

  1. Offer one hypothesis for the high incidence of G6PD mutations in East African children.

  2. How would you test your hypothesis further?

  3. Scores of different G6PD mutations affecting enzyme function have been found in human populations. Offer one explanation for the abundance of different G6PD mutations.

Question 20.15

Large differences in HbS frequencies among Kenyan and Ugandan tribes had been noted in surveys conducted by researchers other than Tony Allison. These researchers offered alternative explanations different from the malarial linkage proposed by Allison. Offer one counterargument to, or experimental test for, the following alternative hypotheses:

  1. The mutation rate is higher in certain tribes.

  2. There is a low degree of genetic mixing among tribes, so the allele rose to high frequency through inbreeding in certain tribes.

Question 20.16

How many potential evolutionary paths are there for an allele to evolve six different mutations? Seven different mutations? Ten different mutations?

Question 20.17

The MC1R gene affects skin and hair color in humans. There are at least 13 polymorphisms of the gene in European and Asian populations, 10 of which are nonsynonymous. In Africans, there are at least 5 polymorphisms of the gene, none of which are nonsynonymous. What might be one explanation for the differences in MC1R variation between Africans and non-Africans?

Question 20.18

Opsin proteins detect light in photoreceptor cells of the eye and are required for color vision. The nocturnal owl monkey, the nocturnal bush baby, and the subterranean blind mole rat have different mutations in an opsin gene that render it nonfunctional. Explain why all three species can tolerate mutations in this gene that operates in most other mammals.

Question 20.19

Full or partial limblessness has evolved many times in vertebrates (snakes, lizards, manatees, whales). Do you expect the mutations that occurred in the evolution of limblessness to be in the coding or noncoding sequences of toolkit genes? Why?

Question 20.20

Several Drosophila species with unspotted wings are descended from a spotted ancestor. Would you predict the loss of spot formation to entail coding or noncoding changes in pigmentation genes? How would you test which is the case?

Question 20.21

It has been claimed that “evolution repeats itself.” What is the evidence for this claim from

  1. the analysis of HbS alleles?

  2. the analysis of antibiotic resistance in bacteria?

  3. the analysis of experimentally selected bacteriophage ϕX174?

  4. the analysis of Oca2 mutations in cave fish?

  5. the analysis of stickleback Pitx1 loci?

Question 20.22

What is the molecular evidence that natural selection includes the “rejection of injurious change”?

Question 20.23

What are three alternative fates of a new gene duplicate?

Question 20.24

What is the evidence that gene duplication has been the source of the α and β gene families for human hemoglobin?

Question 20.25

DNA-sequencing studies for a gene in two closely related species produce the following numbers of sites that vary:

Synonymous polymorphisms

50

Nonsynonymous polymorphisms

20

Synonymous species differences

18

Nonsynonymous species differences

  2

Does this result support neutral evolution of the gene? Does it support an adaptive replacement of amino acids? What explanation would you offer for the observations?

Question 20.26

In humans, two genes encoding the opsin visual pigments that are sensitive to green and red wavelengths of light are found adjacent to one another on the X chromosome. They encode proteins that are 96 percent identical. Nonprimate mammals possess just one gene encoding an opsin sensitive to the red/green wavelength.

  1. Offer one explanation for the presence of the two opsin genes on the human X chromosome.

  2. How would you test your explanation further and pinpoint when in evolutionary history the second gene arose?

Question 20.27

About 9 percent of Caucasian males are color-blind and cannot distinguish red-colored from green-colored objects.

  1. Offer one genetic model for color blindness.

  2. Explain why and how color blindness has reached a frequency of 9 percent in this population.