LESSON 11: Atomic Pudding: Models of the Atom

51

LESSON 11
Atomic Pudding
Models of the Atom

THINK ABOUT IT

The drawing depicts a very tiny sample of gold taken from a gold ring.

image
Joel Sartore/National Geographic/Getty Images

The spheres in the cube of gold are so small that they cannot be seen. What are the spheres, and what does this drawing tell you about the element gold?

How are the smallest bits of matter described?

To answer this question, you will explore

Atoms: Small Bits of Matter

EXPLORING THE TOPIC

Atoms: Small Bits of Matter

image

Imagine you break a piece of matter in half, and then break it in half again and again. How many times can you do this? Can you keep going, getting ever smaller? Around 460 B.C.E., the Greek philosopher Democritus wondered the same thing. He thought that if he could just keep breaking matter in half he would eventually end up with the smallest bit of matter possible.

Democritus proposed that all matter was composed of tiny particles that could not be divided further. Today, we use the word atom to describe these bits of matter. Of course, atoms are too small to be seen. Democritus’ idea was disregarded for the next two thousand years, in part because Democritus did not have evidence to support it.

In 1803, the British scientist John Dalton suggested that the idea of atoms could help explain why elements come together in specific ratios when they form compounds. He imagined atoms of different elements combining to form compounds in the ratios specified by the chemical formulas of the compounds. For example, to form the compound titanium sulfide, TiS2, titanium and sulfur atoms combine in a 1:2 ratio.

Dalton had more than an idea about atoms. He conducted experiments and made observations to back up his idea. His observations provided strong evidence to support his explanation of how matter behaves.

52

In science, the word theory indicates that an explanation is supported by overwhelming evidence. The word theory allows room for doubt and revision, but indicates a greater degree of certainty than the word does in everyday use. The atomic theory states that all matter is made up of atoms. The atomic theory helps us make accurate predictions about the behavior of matter.

Models of the Atom

Models of the Atom

Since Dalton’s time, scientists have created many models to describe atoms and their parts. Models are simplified representations of something you want to explain. For example, a model airplane is a small representation of a larger aircraft. Models take many forms. They can be a plan, a physical structure, a drawing, a mathematical equation, or even a mental image. A model that represents the structure of an atom is called an atomic model.

53

image

TECHNOLOGY CONNECTION

TECHNOLOGY

CONNECTION

Today, using a scanning tunneling microscope, it is possible to create an image of atoms. This instrument does not magnify a sample of matter like a traditional microscope. Instead, the instrument has a tiny tip that scans the surface of the sample to create a topographic map of the surface.

image
© Andrew Dunn/Alamy

Dalton pictured the atom as a hard, solid sphere. Over the next two hundred years, scientists gathered evidence to support and expand on Dalton’s model of the atom. It became clear that the atom was more than just a solid sphere.

But how did scientists gather evidence about something too small to be seen? Scientists found they could learn more about atoms and their structure by shooting small pieces of matter at them or by heating them in a flame. Observations from these experiments provided evidence that helped scientists make changes and refine the model of the atom.

54

The model of the atom was refined and changed as scientists gathered new evidence. This is what science is all about—a continual process of gathering new knowledge to improve our understanding of the world.

Simple Atomic Model

Simple Atomic Model

image

The six models shown on the timeline all have something valuable to offer in terms of visualizing matter at an atomic level. At right is a simple atomic model of an atom. In the very center of the atom is the nucleus. The nucleus consists of positively charged protons, and neutrons, which have no charge. The electrons are even tinier than the protons and neutrons, and they orbit the nucleus. In this particular atom, the electrons are located at two different distances from the nucleus.

Each electron has a charge of –1. The neutrons are neutral and so have no charge. Each proton has a charge of +1. A neutral atom has no overall charge. It has equal numbers of positive protons and negative electrons.

Big Idea

Big Idea

An atom has a nucleus made of protons and neutrons, with electrons orbiting the nucleus.

image
© Marvin E. Newman/Getty Images
The nucleus occupies a very tiny volume. If an atom were the size of a baseball stadium, the nucleus would be smaller than a baseball.

LESSON SUMMARY

LESSON SUMMARY

How are the smallest bits of matter described?

KEY TERMS

atom

atomic theory

model

nucleus

proton

neutron

electron

Long ago, some philosophers imagined that matter was made up of tiny particles called atoms. Over time, scientists gathered evidence from experimental observations to create models of the atom. Today, we know the atom is made up of protons, neutrons, and electrons. The protons and neutrons are in the center of the atom, in the nucleus. Electrons are outside the nucleus. They are much smaller than the protons and neutrons. In a neutral atom, the positive charges on the protons are equal to the negative charges on the electrons.

55

Exercises

Reading Questions

  1. What evidence caused Thomson to change Dalton’s solid sphere model into the plum pudding model?

  2. What evidence caused Rutherford to change Thomson’s plum pudding model into the nuclear model?

  3. What evidence caused Bohr to change Rutherford’s nuclear model into the solar system model?

image
When charged particles are placed near each other, they move toward or away from one another. Similar charges repel, or move away from, one another. Opposite charges attract, or move toward, one another. This photo shows iron filings that have oriented themselves around a magnet’s positive and negative ends.
Arthur S. Aubry/Photodisc/Getty Images

Reason and Apply

  1. Positive and negative charges are attracted to one another. Which of the following are attracted to a negative charge: an electron, a proton, a neutron, a nucleus, an atom? Explain your thinking.

  2. Hydrogen and helium are different elements. How can you use the plum pudding model to show how atoms of the two elements might be different from one another?

  3. Suppose you discovered protons shortly after Thomson discovered electrons. How would you revise the plum pudding model to include protons? Draw a picture of your revised model of the atom.

  4. Draw a solar system model showing one electron, one proton, and one neutron.

  5. Use the Internet or another resource to find out how the size of an atom compares with the size of its nucleus. Is the diameter of an atom 10 times, 1,000 times, or 100,000 times the diameter of the nucleus?
  6. The nuclear model and the solar system model both show atoms with electrons circling around the nucleus.

    1. How do these two models differ?

    2. How are these two models similar?

    3. How can you refine the solar system model so that the atoms do not look flat?

  7. The ancient Greeks discarded the atomic theory because there was no evidence to support it. Try to provide evidence that atoms do indeed exist. Use the Internet to help you.
  8. The ancient Greeks claimed that atoms were the smallest pieces of matter. Were they correct? Explain your thinking.

  9. Give an example that shows how science is a process of gathering evidence and refining models.