The Friars

Monks and nuns carried out their spiritual and social services largely within the walls of their institutions, but in the thirteenth century, new types of religious orders were founded whose members lived out in the world. Members of these new groups were friars, not monks. Friars stressed apostolic poverty, a life based on the teaching of the Gospels in which they would own no property and depend on Christian people for their material needs. The friars’ service to the towns and the poor, their ideal of poverty, and their compassion for the human condition made them popular.

One order of friars was started by Domingo de Gúzman (1170?–1221), born in Castile. Domingo (later called Dominic), a well-educated priest, accompanied his bishop in 1206 on an unsuccessful mission to win the Albigensians in southern France back to orthodox teaching. Determined to succeed through ardent preaching, he subsequently returned to France with a few followers. In 1216, the Dominicans won papal recognition as a new religious order.

Francesco di Bernardone (1181–1226), son of a wealthy Italian cloth merchant of Assisi, had a religious conversion and decided to live and preach the Gospel in absolute poverty. Francis of Assisi, as he came to be known, did not emphasize withdrawal from the world but joyful devotion. In contrast to the Albigensians, who saw the material world as evil, Francis saw all creation as God-given and good.

The simplicity, humility, and joyful devotion with which Francis carried out his mission soon attracted others. Although he resisted pressure to establish an order, his followers became so numerous that he was obliged to develop some formal structure. In 1221, the papacy approved the Rule of the Little Brothers of Saint Francis, generally called the Franciscans (frahn-SIHS-kuhnz).

Friars worked among the poor but also addressed the spiritual and intellectual needs of the middle classes and the wealthy. The Dominicans preferred that their friars be university graduates in order to better preach to a sophisticated urban society. Dominicans soon held professorial chairs at leading universities, and the Franciscans followed suit.

Beginning in 1231, the papacy also used friars to investigate heretics, sometimes under the auspices of a new ecclesiastical court, the Inquisition.

Women sought to develop similar orders devoted to active service out in the world. Clare of Assisi (1193–1253) became a follower of Francis, who established a place for her to live in a church in Assisi. She was joined by other women, and they attempted to establish a rule that would follow Francis’s ideals of absolute poverty and allow them to serve the poor. This rule was accepted by the papacy only after many decades, and then only because Clare agreed that the order, the Poor Clares, would be cloistered.

In the growing cities of Europe, especially in the Netherlands, groups of laywomen seeking to live religious lives came together in groups that later came to be known as Beguines (bay-GEENS). They lived communally, combining lives of prayer with service to the needy. Beguine spirituality emphasized direct personal communication with God, sometimes through mystical experiences, rather than through the intercession of a saint or official church rituals. Initially some church officials gave guarded approval of the movement, but the church grew increasingly uncomfortable with women who were neither married nor cloistered nuns. By the fourteenth century, beguines were declared heretical, and much of their property was confiscated.

Cistercians Emphasized austerity and manual labor; helped spread new agricultural methods and technology
Dominicans Order of friars focused on scholarship, preaching, and combatting heresy
Franciscans Order of friars that emphasized poverty and work among the poor
Poor Clares Founded by Clare of Assisi, a follower of Francis; established by papacy after Clare accepted that the new order would be cloistered
Beguines Groups of laywomen who lived communally and emphasized direct personal communication with God; suppressed in the fourteenth century
Table 9.2: New Religious Orders

>QUICK REVIEW

How and why did monasticism change over the course of the High Middle Ages?