The National Convention

The outbreak and progress of revolution in France produced great excitement and a sharp division of opinion in Europe and the United States. Liberals and radicals saw a triumph of liberty over despotism, while conservative leaders were deeply troubled by the aroused spirit of reform. In 1790 Edmund Burke published Reflections on the Revolution in France, one of the great expressions of European conservatism. He derided abstract principles of “liberty” and “rights” and insisted on the importance of inherited traditions and privileges as a bastion of social stability. He predicted that reform like that occurring in France would lead only to chaos and tyranny. Burke’s work intensified the international debate over the French Revolution.

The kings and nobles of continental Europe, who had at first welcomed the revolution in France as weakening a competing power, now feared its impact. In June 1791 the royal family was arrested and returned to Paris after a failed attempt to escape France. To the monarchs of Austria and Prussia, the arrest of a crowned monarch was unacceptable. Two months later they issued the Declaration of Pillnitz, proclaiming their willingness to intervene in France to restore Louis XVI’s rule, if necessary.

The new French representative body, called the Legislative Assembly, was dominated by members of the Jacobin Club. Political clubs had proliferated in Parisian neighborhoods since the beginning of the Revolution, drawing men and women to debate the issues of the day. The Jacobins and other deputies reacted with patriotic fury to the Declaration of Pillnitz. They said that if the kings of Europe were attempting to incite war against France, then “we will incite a war of people against kings.”1 In April 1792 France declared war on Francis II of Austria, the Habsburg monarch.

The fall of the monarchy marked a rapid radicalization of the Revolution. In late September 1792 a new assembly, called the National Convention, was elected by universal manhood suffrage. The Convention proclaimed France a republic, a nation in which the people, instead of a monarch, held sovereign power. Under the leadership of the Mountain, the radical faction of the Jacobin Club led by Maximilien Robespierre and Georges Jacques Danton, the Convention tried the king for treason. By a narrow majority, it found him guilty, and on January 21, 1793, Louis was executed by the guillotine, a recent invention intended to provide quick, humane executions. His wife, Marie Antoinette, suffered the same fate later that year.

image
Areas of French Insurrection, 1793

In February 1793 the National Convention declared war on Britain, the Dutch Republic, and Spain. Republican France was now at war with almost all of Europe, and it faced mounting internal opposition. Peasants in western France revolted against being drafted into the army, with the Vendée region of Brittany emerging as the epicenter of revolt. Devout Catholics, royalists, and foreign agents encouraged their rebellion, and the counter-revolutionaries were able to recruit veritable armies to fight for their cause.

By March 1793 the National Convention was locked in a political life-and-death struggle between two factions of the Jacobin Club, the radical Mountain and the more moderate Girondists. With the middle-class delegates so bitterly divided, the laboring poor of Paris once again emerged as the decisive political factor. The laboring poor and the petty traders were often known as the sans-culottes (san-koo-LAHT; “without breeches”) because their men wore trousers instead of the knee breeches of the aristocracy and the bourgeoisie. They demanded radical political action to guarantee them their daily bread. The Mountain, sensing an opportunity to outmaneuver the Girondists, joined with sans-culotte activists to engineer a popular uprising. On June 2, 1793, armed sans-culottes invaded the Convention and forced its deputies to arrest twenty-nine Girondist deputies for treason. All power passed to the Mountain.

France’s crusade against tyranny went poorly at first. Prussian forces joined Austria against the French, who broke and fled at their first military encounter with this First Coalition of antirevolutionary foreign powers. The Legislative Assembly declared the country in danger, and volunteers rallied to the capital. In August the Assembly suspended the king from all his functions, imprisoned him, and called for a legislative and constitutional assembly to be elected by universal male suffrage.

image
Picturing the PastContrasting Visions of the Sans-Culottes These two images offer profoundly different representations of a sans-culotte woman. The image on the left was created by a French artist, while the image on the right is English. The French words above the image on the right read in part, “Heads! Blood! Death! . . . I am the Goddess of Liberty! . . . Long Live the Guillotine!” (left: Musée de la Ville de Paris, Musée Carnavalet, Paris, France/Archives Charmet/The Bridgeman Art Library; right: by James Gillray [1757–1815]. © Courtesy of the Warden and Scholars of New College, Oxford, UK/The Bridgeman Art Library)ANALYZING THE IMAGE How would you describe the woman on the left? What qualities does the artist seem to ascribe to her, and how do you think these qualities relate to the sans-culottes and the French Revolution? How would you characterize the facial expression and attire of the woman on the right? How does the inclusion of the text contribute to your impressions of her?CONNECTIONS What does the contrast between these two images suggest about differences between French and English perceptions of the sans-culottes and of the French Revolution? Why do you think the artists have chosen to depict women?

This military and political crisis led to the most radical period of the Revolution, which lasted from spring 1793 until summer 1794. To deal with threats from within and outside France, the Convention formed the Committee of Public Safety in April 1793. Led by Robespierre, the Committee held dictatorial power to deal with the national emergency, allowing it to use whatever force necessary to defend the Revolution. Robespierre and the Committee of Public Safety advanced on several fronts in 1793 and 1794. First, they collaborated with the sans-culottes, who continued pressing the common people’s case for fair prices and a moral economic order. In September 1793 Robespierre and his coworkers established a planned economy with egalitarian social overtones. Rather than let supply and demand determine prices, the government set maximum allowable prices for key products. Though the state was too weak to enforce all its price regulations, it did fix the price of bread in Paris at levels the poor could afford.

The government also put the people to work producing arms, munitions, and uniforms for the war effort. The government told craftsmen what to produce, nationalized many small workshops, and requisitioned raw materials and grain. These economic reforms amounted to an emergency form of socialism, which thoroughly frightened Europe’s propertied classes and greatly influenced the subsequent development of socialist ideology.

Second, while radical economic measures supplied the poor with bread and the armies with weapons, the Reign of Terror (1793–1794) enforced compliance with republican beliefs and practices. Special revolutionary courts tried “enemies of the nation” for political crimes. As a result, some forty thousand French men and women were executed or died in prison. Presented as a necessary measure to save the republic, the Terror was a weapon directed against all suspected of opposing the revolutionary government. As Robespierre himself put it, “Terror is nothing more than prompt, severe inflexible justice.”2 For many Europeans of the time, however, the Reign of Terror represented a frightening perversion of the ideals of 1789.

KEY EVENTS OF THE FRENCH REVOLUTION

May 5, 1789 Estates General meets at Versailles
June 20, 1789 Oath of the Tennis Court
July 14, 1789 Storming of the Bastille
July–August 1789 Great Fear
August 4, 1789 National Assembly abolishes feudal privileges
August 27, 1789 National Assembly issues Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen
July 1790 Civil Constitution of the Clergy establishes a national church; Louis XVI agrees to a constitutional monarchy
June 1791 Royal family is arrested while attempting to flee France
August 1791 Austria and Prussia issue the Declaration of Pillnitz
April 1792 France declares war on Austria
August 1792 Legislative Assembly takes Louis XVI prisoner and suspends him from functions
September 1792 National Convention declares France a republic and abolishes monarchy
January 21, 1793 Louis XVI is executed
February 1793 France declares war on Britain, the Dutch Republic, and Spain; revolts take place in some provinces
March 1793 Struggle between Girondists and the Mountain
June 1793 Sans-culottes invade the National Convention; Girondist leaders are arrested
September 1793 Price controls are instituted to aid the poor
1793–1794 Reign of Terror
Spring 1794 French armies are victorious on all fronts
July 1794 Robespierre is executed; Thermidorian reaction begins
1795 Economic controls are abolished, and suppression of the sans-culottes begins
1795–1799 Directory rules
1798–1799 Austria, Britain, and Russia form the Second Coalition against France
1799 Napoleon Bonaparte overthrows the Directory and seizes power
Table 22.2: KEY EVENTS OF THE FRENCH REVOLUTION

In their efforts to impose unity, the Jacobins also took actions to suppress women’s participation in political debate, which they perceived as disorderly and a distraction from women’s proper place in the home. On October 30, 1793, the National Convention declared, “The clubs and popular societies of women, under whatever denomination are prohibited.” Among those convicted of sedition was writer Olympe de Gouges, who was sent to the guillotine in November 1793.

The third element of the Committee’s program was to bring about a cultural revolution that would transform former royal subjects into republican citizens. The government sponsored revolutionary art and songs as well as secular holidays and open-air festivals to celebrate republican virtues. It also attempted to rationalize daily life by adopting the decimal system for weights and measures and a new calendar based on ten-day weeks. A campaign of de-Christianization aimed to eliminate Catholic symbols and beliefs. Fearful of the hostility aroused in rural France, however, Robespierre called for a halt to de-Christianization measures in mid-1794.

The final element in the program of the Committee of Public Safety was its appeal to a new sense of national identity and patriotism. With a common language and a common tradition reinforced by the revolutionary ideals of popular sovereignty and democracy, many French people developed an intense emotional attachment to the nation, and they saw the war against foreign opponents as a life-and-death struggle between good and evil. This was the birth of modern nationalism, the strong identification with one’s nation, which would have a profound effect on subsequent European history.

To defend the nation, a decree of August 1793 imposed a draft on all unmarried young men. By January 1794 French armed forces outnumbered those of their enemies almost four to one.3 Well trained, well equipped, and constantly indoctrinated, the enormous armies of the republic were led by young, impetuous generals. These generals often had risen from the ranks, and they personified the opportunities the Revolution offered gifted sons of the people. By spring 1794 French armies were victorious on all fronts and domestic revolt was largely suppressed. The republic was saved.