Viewpoints 23.2: Women’s Role in Industrialized Europe

Higher wages for men during the Industrial Revolution contributed to social changes that encouraged the nineteenth-century ideology of separate spheres, which emphasized the importance of women’s role of caretaker of the domestic realm. Sarah Stickney Ellis’s “The Women of England: Their Social Duties and Domestic Habits,” excerpted below, was one of a flood of publications offering middle-class women household advice. For the vast majority of European women and children, however, life still included hard toil. As middle-class reformers began to investigate working-class living conditions, they were shocked by what they found. The second document comes from an 1845 interview of doctors by a reformer in a German industrial city.

Sarah Stickney Ellis, “The Women of England: Their Social Duties and Domestic Habits,” 1839

What shall I do to gratify myself — to be admired — or to vary the tenor of my existence?” are not the questions which a woman of right feelings asks awaking to the avocations of the day. Much more congenial to the highest attributes of woman’s character, are inquiries such as these: “How shall I endeavor through this day to turn the time, the health, and the means permitted me to enjoy, to the best account? Is any one sick, I must visit their chamber without delay, and try to give their apartment an air of comfort, by arranging such things as the wearied nurse may not have thought of. Is any one about to set off on a journey, I must see that the early meal is spread, to prepare it with my own hands, in order that the servant, who was working late last night, may profit by unbroken rest. Did I fail in what was kind or considerate to any of the family yesterday; I will meet her this morning with a cordial welcome, and show, in the most delicate way I can, that I am anxious to atone for the past. Was any one exhausted by the last day’s exertion, I will be an hour before them this morning, and let them see that their labor is so much in advance. Or, if nothing extraordinary occurs to claim my attention, I will meet the family with a consciousness that, being the least engaged of any member of it, I am consequently the most at liberty to devote myself to the general good of the whole, by cultivating cheerful conversation, adapting myself to the prevailing tone of feeling, and leading those who are least happy, to think and speak of what will make them more so.

Interview Concerning the Lives of Women and Children in a German Industrial City, 1845

Question: What is your usual experience regarding the cleanliness of these classes?

Dr. Bluemner: Bad! Mother has to go out to work, and can therefore pay little attention to the domestic economy, and even if she makes an effort, she lacks time and means. A typical woman of this kind has four children, of whom she is still suckling one, she has to look after the whole household, to take food to her husband at work, perhaps a quarter of a mile away on a building site; she therefore has no time for cleaning and then it is such a small hole inhabited by so many people. The children are left to themselves, crawl about the floor or in the streets, and are always dirty; they lack the necessary clothing to change more often, and there is no time or money to wash these frequently. There are, of course, gradations; if the mother is healthy, active and clean, and if the poverty is not too great, then things are better.

Question: What is the state of health among the lower class? . . .

Dr. Kalckstein: . . . The dwellings of the working classes mostly face the yards and courts. The small quantity of fresh air admitted by the surrounding buildings is vitiated by the emanations from stables and middens [garbage heaps]. Further, because of the higher rents, people are forced to share their dwellings and to overcrowd them. The adults escape the worst influences by leaving the dwellings during the day, but the children are exposed to it with its whole force.

Sources: Sarah Stickney Ellis, “The Women of England: Their Social Duties and Domestic Habits,” in Walter Arnstein, ed., The Past Speaks, 2d ed. (Lexington, Mass.: D. C. Heath, 1993), 2:172–175; Laura L. Frader, ed., The Industrial Revolution: A History in Documents (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006), p. 85.

QUESTIONS FOR ANALYSIS

  1. What daily tasks and duties does Sarah Stickney Ellis prescribe for the mother of the family?
  2. Based on the second document, what obstacles to achieving the ideals prescribed by Stickney Ellis existed for working-class women? To what extent do the doctors seem to blame the women themselves for their situation?