Abolition in Cuba and Brazil

Cuba and Brazil followed long and indirect paths to abolition. In Cuba nationalist rebels fought for independence from Spain in the Ten Years’ War (1868–1878). Many slaves and free blacks joined the failed anticolonial struggle, and rebel leaders expressed support for abolition. Spanish authorities sought to defuse the tensions feeding that struggle by enacting the Moret Law in 1870, which granted freedom to slaves who fought on the Spanish side in the war, to the children of slaves born since 1868, and to slaves over age sixty. By 1878 Spanish forces had defeated the nationalists, but the conflict had set in motion an irreversible process of abolition.

In Brazil the 1871 Law of the Free Womb also granted freedom to children born to slaves, and an 1885 law granted freedom to slaves over age sixty. At best, these laws were half measures, aimed at placating abolitionists without disrupting the economic reliance on slave labor. At worst, they mocked the meaning of abolition: children freed under the free womb laws remained apprenticed to their mother’s master until they turned eighteen in Cuba or twenty-one in Brazil. The emancipation of slaves over age sixty freed very few people, given the life expectancy of slaves and freed persons alike. Those few it freed were elderly and lacked education or property. These laws preserved masters’ access to the labor of the children of slaves, while freeing masters from their obligations to care for elderly slaves.

image
Slave Labor in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil This lithograph by French traveler Jean-Baptiste Debret shows different facets of urban slavery in Rio de Janeiro. In the foreground slaves lay paving stones in a plaza, while behind them other slaves peddle food. A funeral procession passes in the background. (from Voyage pittoresque et historique au Brésil, 1824 color lithograph by Jean-Baptiste Debret [1768–1848] published in 1839/Bibliotheque Nationale, Paris, France/Archives Charmet/The Bridgeman Art Library)

Slavery was finally abolished in Cuba in 1886 and in Brazil in 1888, making them the last regions of the Americas to end slavery. These acts came just as the first freeborn “apprentices” reached adulthood. In Brazil, Emperor Pedro II had long supported abolition and had freed his own household’s slaves. But Pedro II never sought to abolish slavery, because he believed that if he upset the planters they would force him from power. When he traveled to Europe for medical treatment in 1888, his daughter Princess Isabel became regent. Unencumbered by her father’s concerns, she issued a concise decree, known as the Golden Law, which simply read: “Article 1, Slavery is declared extinct as of the date of this decree; Article 2, All laws to the contrary are revoked.”

Abolition did not come about solely through laws from the top down. Social pressure, often exerted by slaves themselves, contributed to abolition. For example, in Cuba many officers in the nationalist army, including its second-in-command, General Antonio Maceo, were free black abolitionists. In Brazil free blacks like engineer André Rebouças, journalist José do Patrocínio, and novelist Joaquim Machado de Assis were fervent abolitionists who shaped public opinion against slavery and found common cause with a republican movement that saw both slavery and monarchy as outdated.

Slave resistance, in its many forms, also intensified in the last years of the nineteenth century. Slaves ran off from plantations in growing numbers. In many cases, they settled in communities of runaway slaves, particularly in Brazil, where the vast interior offered opportunities to resettle out of the reach of former masters. (See “Viewpoints 27.2: The Abolition of Slavery, from Above and Below.”) In the years preceding abolition, in some regions of Brazil slave flight became so widespread that slaves might simply leave their plantation and hire themselves out to a nearby planter whose own slaves had also run away. In the end, the costs of slavery had become unsustainable.