5.7 Developmental differences between populations create migration pressures

The Statue of Liberty in New York Harbor is one of the most well-known monuments to immigration. Indeed, the Americas have received large numbers of immigrants from all over the world. For instance, in the wake of the Irish potato famine over 150 years ago, 1 million Irish came to the United States. However dramatic, this event involved a small fraction of the millions of people from all over Earth who now seek better prospects: Sri Lankan boat people seeking asylum in Australia, Nicaraguans entering richer Costa Rica, Eastern Europeans moving into Western Europe, young Africans stumbling onto the beaches of southern Spain, or Mexicans immigrating to the United States (Figure 5.15).

DEVELOPED COUNTRIES FACE AN INCREASING FLOW OF ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS
image
FIGURE 5.15 Here, Italian immigration police detain a boatload of people attempting to enter Italy illegally.
(© Franco Cufari European Press Agency/Newscom)

140

image

How does one reconcile the aspirations of immigrants with the concerns of many residents in countries attracting high flows of immigrants?

These encounters among people, often with different cultures and languages, have commonly involved competition for land, jobs, and other resources. Consequently, immigration is one of the most sensitive and complicated issues related to human population dynamics, and history is filled with attempts to stop or control the flow of immigrants (Figure 5.16).

BARRIERS BUILT TO CONTROL HUMAN MOVEMENTS HAVE A LONG HISTORY
image
FIGURE 5.16 The border fence between the Spanish city of Melilla and Morocco is intended to reduce illegal migration into Spain from Africa. The border fence between the United States and Mexico is intended to reduce illegal migration into the United States along its southern border.
(Blasco de Avellaneda/AFP/Getty Images) (Frederic Brown/AFP/Getty Images)

Migration and Population Dynamics

Today, migration augments population growth in some regions and contributes to population declines in other regions. The main sources of immigrants are poor countries in Asia, Latin America, the Caribbean, and Africa, whose principal destinations are rich countries in North America, Europe, Australia, and New Zealand (Figure 5.17). In the richest countries, the number of immigrant residents totaled over 111 million in 2013, or about 11% of the overall population. About 2.5 million people migrate from one country to another every year. Of this total, approximately 1 million, or 40%, legally immigrate to the United States. Another several hundred thousand persons per year illegally enter the United States. Most of the others go to Europe, Canada, or Australia.

IMMIGRANTS USUALLY GO TO AREAS OF BETTER ECONOMIC OPPORTUNITY
image
FIGURE 5.17 The major flow paths of international immigration mainly connect Latin America, the Caribbean, Africa, and Asia with North America, Western Europe, Australia, and New Zealand. However, significant flows of immigration also occur between countries within regions, where there are differences in economic opportunity—for example, to South Africa from nearby less developed countries. (Data from United Nations Human Development Report, 2009)

High rates of immigration have been associated with some incidents of political and social conflict. In South Africa, for example, controversy over immigration from surrounding countries, both legal and illegal, exploded into widespread rioting and violence in 2008 and 2015. In the United States, a number of local governments and states frustrated by the number of illegal migrants have made life harder for immigrants by preventing them from getting driver’s licenses or arresting them when they cannot show proof of legal status. These legal moves have drawn opposition from the U.S. federal government and have become flashpoints for debate among political parties, citizen groups, and the U.S. Supreme Court (Figure 5.18).

IMMIGRATION: A SIGNIFICANT ISSUE IN MANY COUNTRIES
image
FIGURE 5.18 In the United States, intense debate swirls around the issues of how to reform immigration policy and to deal with the millions of illegal immigrants in the country. Here, some demonstrators protest a controversial immigration law passed by a state legislature, while others show support for it.
(Michael Rieger/Zuma Press/Newscom)

Immigration policy in the United States is governed by the Immigration and Naturalization Act, which limits permanent immigrants to 675,000 annually. U.S. immigration policy has historically given priority to reuniting families, admitting immigrants with skills valuable to the U.S. economy and providing shelter to refugees. Many naturalized citizens, human rights groups, and business owners worried about their labor force have called for immigration policy reform.

Think About It

  1. In setting immigration policy, what criteria can be used to screen immigrants? Are some criteria unethical? Explain your answers.

  2. Do developed countries have an obligation to accept immigrants from developing countries with large populations? Do poor countries have a right to expect that rich countries will accept their immigrants?

141

5.4–5.7 Issues: Summary

Understanding the impact of a population on the environment requires an accurate measurement of its level of development. The United Nations incorporates life expectancy, wealth, and access to education into a single index of development called the Human Development Index, or HDI. The two main factors influencing its impact are the number of individuals in the population and the per capita consumption of natural resources. These effects can be summarized by the IPAT equation: I (environmental impact) = P (population) × A (affluence or resource consumption) × T (technology). Ecological footprints, which are on average higher in more developed countries, also quantify the impact of populations on the environment. Migration has had a significant influence on human populations throughout history. Today, migration augments the population growth of many countries, while contributing to population declines in others. Immigration can be a significant contributor to population growth trends and, in some situations, may lead to social conflict.