A Well-Presented Subject: Establishing and Applying Criteria in Music Reviews

E-Page 71
 Analyze 
Use the basic features.

Typically, critics of music, films, and other forms of entertainment identify—directly or indirectly—the category of the work they are evaluating in the review: for example, pop, hip-hop, classical, or jazz in the case of music, or drama, documentary, comedy, or action-adventure in the case of films. They then apply criteria or standards that make sense based on how people normally judge works of that kind. A documentary film, for instance, might be judged in part on the quality of the sources interviewed or observed.

ANALYZE & WRITE

Write a paragraph or two analyzing how evaluative criteria are set up and applied in the Gig Alert feature on Bright Eyes:

Printed Page 2072
  1. How can you tell what category or categories the featured band fits into?
  2. What criteria does Marlon Bishop seem to be using to evaluate the songs? Are these criteria appropriate to the category (or categories) you identified? Why or why not?
  3. Does Bishop do enough to make his judgments of the songs clear? In your response, consider whether featuring these songs and this musician in a Gig Alert qualifies as offering an evaluation.
  4. In cases like this, when people can judge the music for themselves by listening to the MP3s, does the writer still need to come right out and say whether he or she thinks the music is good or not, and why? Explain your answer.

    Question