Josh Harkinson/Mother Jones
In the following interview, the magazine Mother Jones talks to environmental sociologist Anthony Silvaggio about the environmental effects of unregulated (and illegal) marijuana farming operations in California. To make his argument, Silvaggio, who teaches in the sociology department at Humboldt State University, uses Google Earth to point out where marijuana is being farmed in Humboldt County, California, and how those grow sites affect the surrounding ecology. As you watch this interview, think about the larger implications of Silvaggio’s argument.
No place in America is better known for marijuana growing than Northern California’s Humboldt County. The same forgiving climate and rugged terrain that gave rise to ancient redwoods (and decades of frenzied clear-cutting) has brought about a “green rush”—of pot growers looking to tend rows of Afghani Goo or Sour Diesel strains in remote canyons or ridge-lines far beyond the reach of the feds.
Erstwhile loggers can earn much more than they ever did splitting trees. By one recent estimate, cannabis accounts for more than a quarter of Humboldt County’s $1.6 billion economy, a share that’s likely to grow with the legalization of marijuana for recreational use in nearby Washington State. But the pot economy’s need for land and water has sparked a whole new wave of environmental problems.
In this video, made with hi-res satellite images from Google Earth, Anthony Silvaggio, an environmental sociologist with Humboldt State University’s new Institute for Interdisciplinary Marijuana Research, exposes the extent of the devastation wrought on private forestland by industrial-scale growth.
Topics for Critical Thinking and Writing
In a couple of sentences, summarize what argument you think Anthony Silvaggio is trying to make.
What evidence does Silvaggio use to support his claim? Do you find this evidence effective? Why, or why not?
One of the solutions Silvaggio offers for helping address the environmental destruction caused by marijuana farming is to legalize and regulate marijuana. Can you think of any other solutions besides the one Silvaggio advocates? Explain.