Loading [MathJax]/jax/output/CommonHTML/jax.js

EXAMPLE 2Showing a Force Field Is Not a Conservative Vector Field

  1. (a) Show that the force field F=(x+y)i+(yx)j is not a conservative vector field.
  2. (b) Show that the work W done by F in moving an object is dependent on the path by using two paths starting at the origin (0,0) and ending at the point (1,1).

Solution (a) Let P(x,y)=x+y and Q(x,y)=yx. Then Py=y(x+y)=1andQx=x(yx)=1

Since PyQx, the force field F is not a conservative vector field.

(b) To show that the work W done by F is dependent on the path, we choose two paths beginning at the origin (0,0) and ending at the point (1,1).

For Path 1, we let C be defined by y=x, where 0x1. That is, x(t)=t, y(t)=t, 0t1. Then F(x(t),y(t))=2ti, r(t)=ti+tj, and dr=(i+j)dt. So, Fdr=2tdt

The work W done by F along C is W=CFdr=102tdt=[t2]10=1

For Path 2, we let C be the piecewise-smooth curve made up of:

  • C1, which is traced out by x(t)=t, y(t)=0, 0t1, and
  • C2, which is traced out by x(t)=1, y(t)=t, 0t1.
  • For C1, F(x(t),y(t))=titj, r(t)=ti, and dr=idt. So, Fdr=tdt

    For C2, F(x(t),y(t))=(1+t)i+(t1)j, r(t)=i+tj, and dr=jdt. So, Fdr=(t1)dt

    The work W done by F along Path 2 is W=C1Fdr+C2Fdr=10tdt+10(t1)dt=0

    Since the work done along Path 1 and Path 2 are not equal, the work W done by the force F is dependent on the path.