P1 Commas

H-51

Instructor's Notes

LearningCurve activities on commas are available at the end of the Punctuation section of this handbook.

Use a comma to set off and separate sentence elements.

P1-a Add a comma between independent clauses joined by a coordinating conjunction.

When independent clauses are joined by a coordinating conjunction, a comma is required to tell the reader that another independent clause follows the first one.

image

If the independent clauses are brief and unambiguous, a comma is not required, though it is never wrong to include it.

image

P1-b Place a comma after an introductory word, phrase, or clause.

Sentences often begin with words, phrases, or clauses that precede the independent clause and modify an element within it. The comma following each introductory element lets the reader know where the modifying word or phrase ends and the main clause begins.

image

image

image

If an introductory phrase or clause is brief — four words or fewer — the comma may be omitted unless it is needed to prevent misreading.

image

P1-c Use commas to set off a nonrestrictive word group.

To test whether a word group is nonrestrictive (supplemental, nondefining, and thus nonessential) or restrictive (defining and thus essential), read the sentence with and without the word group. If the sentence is essentially unchanged in meaning without it, the word group is nonrestrictive. Use commas to set it off.

image

H-52

Conversely, if omitting the word group changes the meaning of the sentence, it is restrictive. In this case, do not use commas.

image

Use a comma to set off a nonrestrictive word group at the end of a sentence.

image

Use a pair of commas to set off a nonrestrictive word group in the middle of a sentence.

image

(See also P2-b.)

P1-d Use commas to set off a transitional, parenthetical, or contrasting expression or an absolute phrase.

Transitional expressions help the reader follow a writer’s movement from point to point. Parenthetical comments interrupt a sentence with a brief aside. Contrasting expressions are introduced by not, no, or nothing. Absolute phrases modify the whole clause and often include a past or present participle as well as modifiers. By using commas to set off such expressions, you signal that they are additions, supplementing or commenting on the information in the rest of the sentence.

image

P1-e Use commas to separate three or more items in a series, placing the final comma before the conjunction.

The commas in a series separate the items for the reader.

image

image

H-53

Note: Newspapers, magazines, and British publications often omit the comma before the conjunction. In your academic writing, however, include it for clarity.

P1-f Use a comma before a trailing nonrestrictive participial phrase.

Participial phrases are generally nonrestrictive word groups. When they follow the independent clause in a sentence, they should be set off with commas. See P1-c.

image

The comma before the phrase signals the end of the main clause and sets off the important modifying phrase.

image

Note: If the participial phrase is restrictive, providing essential information, do not use a comma. See P1-c and P2-b.

P1-g Place a comma between a complete direct quotation and the text identifying the speaker.

The comma, along with the quotation marks, helps the reader determine where the quotation begins and ends. (See also P6.)

image

P1-h Add a comma (or pair of commas in the middle of a sentence) to set off expressions commonly included in dialogue.

Use commas to set off from the main part of the sentence the name of a person directly addressed by a speaker, words such as yes and no, and mild interjections. Also use a comma to set off questions added to the end of sentences.

image

H-54

image

P1-i Use a comma between coordinate adjectives.

If you can change the order of a series of adjectives or add and between them without changing the meaning, they are coordinate and should be separated with a comma.

image

The comma signals that the adjectives are equal, related in the same way to the word modified.

If the adjectives closest to the noun cannot be logically rearranged or linked by and, they are cumulative adjectives and should not be separated by commas.

image

P1-j Add commas where needed to set off dates, numbers, and addresses.

When you include a full date (month, day, and year), use a pair of commas to set off the year.

image

If you present a date in reverse order (day, month, and year) or if the date is partial, do not add commas.

In large numbers (except four-digit years), separate groups of three digits (thousands, millions, and so forth) with commas.

image

When you write out an address, add commas between the street address, the city, and the state.

image